linbee83's review against another edition
5.0
I am always fascinated with different beliefs and cultures. This book is well written and thoughtful, and discusses the culture and beliefs of the Amish. Very useful information.
sarahfett's review
4.0
This is an enjoyable, informative read. It's part memoir of the author's life, part ethnography of Amish culture, and the author shares parenting advice that she has learned from her Amish friends at the end of each chapter.
thejpearson's review against another edition
4.0
There are some really interesting ideas, especially regarding intentional parenting. I think the author handles the balance of being influenced by but not worshiping the Amish.
That being said, it got a little long in some areas, and felt a little redundant. Definitely a thought provoking read on parenting.
That being said, it got a little long in some areas, and felt a little redundant. Definitely a thought provoking read on parenting.
pinkpengin's review against another edition
4.0
Interestingly, I have what in many ways is a very different parenting view from most Amish families I know, yet I found many themes in common regarding intentionality and lifelong learning. Definitely made me think.
mollykwhelan's review against another edition
informative
inspiring
medium-paced
4.25
A really insightful look at Amish family life and why it often works so well. Unlike "Almost Amish," this book does not feel preachy or judgy at all. The author, herself a ministers wife, presents the truths as she knows them and gives practical advice for Englisch parents to emulate them in our own cultures. Gave me a lot to think about and will have a big effect on my parenting and homemaking!
Content Warnings
Minor: Child death
deannah's review against another edition
4.0
I am simply fascinated with Amish living. I sort of want to be them, in that I want their self-sufficiency and simplicity but with the perks of electricity. This book only added to my crush. Points that stood out: making your children contributing members of the family. Amish children go everywhere with their parents: to their work, to funerals, to weddings, to church, etc. And they have responsibilities that are appropriate for their ages. They contribute at a very early age to family life. Also Community. The community I think is the reason for their success. They can parent the way that they do because they have the support of an entire community. A rather homogeneous community with identical values, just not spiritual values but lifestyle values. You can send you children to play with the neighbors and not worry about what they are watching, games their are playing, etc. because they have the same ideas regarding those topics. That is a very alluring idea.
sandreasen's review against another edition
3.0
Pretty bland narrative, but some interesting insights into the Amish culture.