hstapp's review against another edition
3.0
I'm quite enjoying my read/reread of these books. AN exciting adventure about scamming old people. I guess nothing really changes.
bargainsleuth's review
4.0
For this and other book reviews, check out www.bargain-sleuth.com and join my Facebook page Bargain Sleuth Book Reviews.
Once again, I thought the Revised Text better. There aren't any continuity errors like there were with Walter Karig's OT. Helen Corning Archer is indeed married in this volume. I had forgotten that The Password to Larkspur Lane featured Helen as well as Bess and George; that had never happened before in the series.
Taking out much of the filler of the Original Text, "Carolyn Keene" added a subplot involving Helen's grandparents at their home on Sylvan Lake. Naturally, their favorite dates, Ned, Burt and Dave happen to be camp counselors across the lake at Lake Hiawatha and make several appearances. Of course, the second mystery Nancy gets herself involved in is tied to the first mystery of the elderly woman being held against her will in a shady sanitorium that happens to have larkspur growing on the estate.
Once again, I thought the Revised Text better. There aren't any continuity errors like there were with Walter Karig's OT. Helen Corning Archer is indeed married in this volume. I had forgotten that The Password to Larkspur Lane featured Helen as well as Bess and George; that had never happened before in the series.
Taking out much of the filler of the Original Text, "Carolyn Keene" added a subplot involving Helen's grandparents at their home on Sylvan Lake. Naturally, their favorite dates, Ned, Burt and Dave happen to be camp counselors across the lake at Lake Hiawatha and make several appearances. Of course, the second mystery Nancy gets herself involved in is tied to the first mystery of the elderly woman being held against her will in a shady sanitorium that happens to have larkspur growing on the estate.
bargainsleuth's review against another edition
3.0
For this and other book reviews, visit www.bargain-sleuth.com or join my Facebook page Bargain Sleuth Book Reviews
The Original Text (OT) The Password to Larkspur Lane is just a crazy mess, but I couldn't put it down because I had never read the OT before and had no idea how it would end.
The ghostwriter was Walter Karig. His first Nancy Drew book, Nancy's Mysterious Letter, was just awful, full of misogynist writings. His second book, The Sign of the Twisted Candles was much better. The Password to Larkspur Lane fell somewhere in-between with me. It was good, but not great. There were quite a few head-scratching sentences. "Nancy, despite her remarkable deductive powers, was a normal, healthy girl, and a bedtime lunch appealed to her as much as it does to any young person." Or, "It was Nancy's turn to look astonished. She often forgot that few people were gifted with her sense of observation and deduction."
In true 1930's form, Nancy's encounters are not what you'd find today. Nancy's in her yard one day picking larkspur for a flower show (I prefer the name delphinium for the flower) when a low flying plane (flying so low she can make out a symbol on the tail) hits a bird that lands in the yard. It's a carrier pigeon. That carrier pigeon is injured, and is carrying a message. Nancy calls the International Carrier Pigeon Association (she does not have to look up the number--Nancy is all-knowing!) and finds out the bird is not registered to them. A rogue pigeon and a mysterious message lead Nancy on to her next mystery.
There's a kidnapped doctor and an elderly woman being held hostage at some shady sanitorium. Karig makes Carson Drew sound not-so Carson Drew-like: "It is more important to me that you are free from harm than that all the mysterious women in the world should have their freedom." That does not sound like the caring Carson Drew I grew up with.
There's the racial stereotypes we often find in these 1930's volumes. Helen Corning just calls her servant Cook, who speaks in broken English like the stereotypical black servant. And once again, Karig forgot that Helen Corning should be married to Jim Archer by now. His Helen has her dating random guys.
One line cracked me up. When Nancy is asking for information about the suspected kidnappers, the hotel proprietor says the Tookers are mysterious because "They don't come to church, or don't subscribe to the local paper." Crazy dialogue. Crazy plot lines, but somehow it works.
The Original Text (OT) The Password to Larkspur Lane is just a crazy mess, but I couldn't put it down because I had never read the OT before and had no idea how it would end.
The ghostwriter was Walter Karig. His first Nancy Drew book, Nancy's Mysterious Letter, was just awful, full of misogynist writings. His second book, The Sign of the Twisted Candles was much better. The Password to Larkspur Lane fell somewhere in-between with me. It was good, but not great. There were quite a few head-scratching sentences. "Nancy, despite her remarkable deductive powers, was a normal, healthy girl, and a bedtime lunch appealed to her as much as it does to any young person." Or, "It was Nancy's turn to look astonished. She often forgot that few people were gifted with her sense of observation and deduction."
In true 1930's form, Nancy's encounters are not what you'd find today. Nancy's in her yard one day picking larkspur for a flower show (I prefer the name delphinium for the flower) when a low flying plane (flying so low she can make out a symbol on the tail) hits a bird that lands in the yard. It's a carrier pigeon. That carrier pigeon is injured, and is carrying a message. Nancy calls the International Carrier Pigeon Association (she does not have to look up the number--Nancy is all-knowing!) and finds out the bird is not registered to them. A rogue pigeon and a mysterious message lead Nancy on to her next mystery.
There's a kidnapped doctor and an elderly woman being held hostage at some shady sanitorium. Karig makes Carson Drew sound not-so Carson Drew-like: "It is more important to me that you are free from harm than that all the mysterious women in the world should have their freedom." That does not sound like the caring Carson Drew I grew up with.
There's the racial stereotypes we often find in these 1930's volumes. Helen Corning just calls her servant Cook, who speaks in broken English like the stereotypical black servant. And once again, Karig forgot that Helen Corning should be married to Jim Archer by now. His Helen has her dating random guys.
One line cracked me up. When Nancy is asking for information about the suspected kidnappers, the hotel proprietor says the Tookers are mysterious because "They don't come to church, or don't subscribe to the local paper." Crazy dialogue. Crazy plot lines, but somehow it works.
zenithharpink's review against another edition
4.0
I think so far this is my favorite Nancy Drew, as there was a legitimate mystery to solve for. As the stories progress, the writers have added more "mysteries" to the plot to make it more interesting, but this all comes neatly back together with a single, over-reaching, criminal gang. Nancy's "bravery" borders on reckless superiority, and I've decided that I probably wouldn't like her very much if we were to meet in real life, but that doesn't stop my love for her or these books. I'm addicted, and I'm loving every minute of it!
kiwilizzi's review against another edition
2.0
Wanted to relive my childhood and read a Nancy Drew novel. I picked one that is on the top of several “Best Nancy Drew Books” lists, but I wasn’t very impressed. I probably would’ve enjoyed it in middle school, but I don’t think this particular story aged very well. It wasn’t very suspenseful in my opinion. I remember preferring Hardy Boys over Nancy Drew, so maybe I should try one of those instead.
raes's review against another edition
adventurous
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? N/A
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? N/A
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
5.0
the_ghost_penguin_reader's review against another edition
adventurous
mysterious
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.25
permanentlei's review against another edition
I decided I don’t feel the need to reread these books right now.
jbaronn's review against another edition
adventurous
mysterious
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.0