trufyre's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.0
cheeriospank's review against another edition
3.0
This is my favorite of the series so far. He seemed to repeat himself a lot less and there was a lot going on. . I was a little sad to have no Eddie or Susie in this one but Dead Boy was in interesting character.
Spoiler
It was so obvious that Mr. and Mrs. Cavendish were the Murder Masquesanubis9's review against another edition
3.0
3 1/2 stars
Overall this is a good series, but I didn't enjoy this third installment as much as the second. There was a little too much deus ex machina for my taste, but I did enjoy the Dead Boy character, and I'm really enjoying the slow revelation of the main character's lineage.
While the story wasn't my favorite, this one did have some vivid, awesome descriptions that are some of the best in the series. One of my favorites was the descriptions of The Primal at the Necrpolis:
"…and when it spoke, its voice was like a choir of children whispering obscenities."
That's pure nightmare fuel.
Overall this is a good series, but I didn't enjoy this third installment as much as the second. There was a little too much deus ex machina for my taste, but I did enjoy the Dead Boy character, and I'm really enjoying the slow revelation of the main character's lineage.
While the story wasn't my favorite, this one did have some vivid, awesome descriptions that are some of the best in the series. One of my favorites was the descriptions of The Primal at the Necrpolis:
"…and when it spoke, its voice was like a choir of children whispering obscenities."
That's pure nightmare fuel.
flosch's review against another edition
4.0
Guilty pleasure summer read for a dark souled snarky human who wants to believe there is more than our khaki experience.
hbaier94's review
adventurous
dark
mysterious
reflective
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
queenterribletimy's review against another edition
3.0
My review can be read on my blog as well: https://starlitbook.com/2018/04/03/nightingales-lament-by-simon-r-green/
Nightingale's Lament starts with John working on a case, helping out an old friend. As a result, he manages to bring down one of the biggest electricity provider in the Nightside, causing all kinds of trouble - this later in the book comes back to kick him in the ass every once in a while. To be honest, this first chapter - and the story contained in it - was my favorite part, and it would have deserved a whole story. Instead, John is being hired to find out if everything is fine with the up and coming star Rossignol, who lately didn't seemed to be herself, and there were rumors regarding fans committing suicide. John sets out to look into the bottom of it. As usual, he gets partners, and we get to know some new characters - Julian, the editor of the Night Times, Dead Boy who ends up playing a crucial role, and my favorite in this book, Otto, the hurricane page boy.
The biggest strength of this series is the world building, and that you can really never forsee what's to come (or most of the time anyway, this time one of the twists were pretty obvious to me). I also like the humor, however, compared to the first book, this book seems to lack it. Sadly. Or it might be I wasn't in the mood to appreciate it. I don't know.
And now the rant part of my review. I've read 3 books now out of 12, but I can't see the improvement in the writing (or editing for that matter). On the contrary. This series has the potential to be one of the best, but it fails to deliver, which pisses me off. Green throws around the phrase "in the Nightside" like it's a fucking confetti. I mean, yeah, by book 3 we know we are in the Nightside, thanks. You don't have to add itt every second page. The repetitiveness can be boring after a while, and John's constant whining about not knowing about her mom. I hope we'll learn something about her soon, or poor John will have mommy issues sooner or later (or he has already, come to think of it). I also can't understand why the characters have to call each others names in every conversation (altough I have to say, I like the names like Razor Eddie the Punk God or Shotgun Suzie). You know we readers aren't stupid, we've been reading for pages this scene, we know full well, that you are together. Meh. However, I'm starting to realise that this might be a british thing and pretty common in their everyday lives. Strange.
Anyway, I really, really, want to love this series, and I keep carry on hoping it gets better. But if this continues, I might have to reconsider reading the series and stop wasting my money on it (living in Budapest, library is not an option or second hand bookshops for that matter. I have to buy every book I read, which can be a gamble at times). So far Nightingale's Lament was my least favorite, despite music playing a part in it. The story felt off, I didn't find it interesting enough, and felt like it was just an excuse to show off different scenes and parts of the Nightside, throwing it all in one book and hoping something will come out of it. And again, one of the twists were too obvious. I find myself getting tired of books where the MC just wanders around, keeps getting injured or something just so we know he is not immortal. Then in the last 10% of the book suddenly everyone pops up, reveals some big secret then every problem gets solved in the blink of an eye. Is it me or this just really gets boring after a while? Also, these books are short, and I get that the story must be wrapped up, but felt a bit rushed to me. I hope the next book will bring back some of the humor of the first book, because that made me snort loudly, and if I have to deal with all the repetitiveness, then at least I'd like to have some fun too.
Nightingale's Lament starts with John working on a case, helping out an old friend. As a result, he manages to bring down one of the biggest electricity provider in the Nightside, causing all kinds of trouble - this later in the book comes back to kick him in the ass every once in a while. To be honest, this first chapter - and the story contained in it - was my favorite part, and it would have deserved a whole story. Instead, John is being hired to find out if everything is fine with the up and coming star Rossignol, who lately didn't seemed to be herself, and there were rumors regarding fans committing suicide. John sets out to look into the bottom of it. As usual, he gets partners, and we get to know some new characters - Julian, the editor of the Night Times, Dead Boy who ends up playing a crucial role, and my favorite in this book, Otto, the hurricane page boy.
The biggest strength of this series is the world building, and that you can really never forsee what's to come (or most of the time anyway, this time one of the twists were pretty obvious to me). I also like the humor, however, compared to the first book, this book seems to lack it. Sadly. Or it might be I wasn't in the mood to appreciate it. I don't know.
And now the rant part of my review. I've read 3 books now out of 12, but I can't see the improvement in the writing (or editing for that matter). On the contrary. This series has the potential to be one of the best, but it fails to deliver, which pisses me off. Green throws around the phrase "in the Nightside" like it's a fucking confetti. I mean, yeah, by book 3 we know we are in the Nightside, thanks. You don't have to add itt every second page. The repetitiveness can be boring after a while, and John's constant whining about not knowing about her mom. I hope we'll learn something about her soon, or poor John will have mommy issues sooner or later (or he has already, come to think of it). I also can't understand why the characters have to call each others names in every conversation (altough I have to say, I like the names like Razor Eddie the Punk God or Shotgun Suzie). You know we readers aren't stupid, we've been reading for pages this scene, we know full well, that you are together. Meh. However, I'm starting to realise that this might be a british thing and pretty common in their everyday lives. Strange.
Anyway, I really, really, want to love this series, and I keep carry on hoping it gets better. But if this continues, I might have to reconsider reading the series and stop wasting my money on it (living in Budapest, library is not an option or second hand bookshops for that matter. I have to buy every book I read, which can be a gamble at times). So far Nightingale's Lament was my least favorite, despite music playing a part in it. The story felt off, I didn't find it interesting enough, and felt like it was just an excuse to show off different scenes and parts of the Nightside, throwing it all in one book and hoping something will come out of it. And again, one of the twists were too obvious. I find myself getting tired of books where the MC just wanders around, keeps getting injured or something just so we know he is not immortal. Then in the last 10% of the book suddenly everyone pops up, reveals some big secret then every problem gets solved in the blink of an eye. Is it me or this just really gets boring after a while? Also, these books are short, and I get that the story must be wrapped up, but felt a bit rushed to me. I hope the next book will bring back some of the humor of the first book, because that made me snort loudly, and if I have to deal with all the repetitiveness, then at least I'd like to have some fun too.