Scan barcode
alilysong's review against another edition
dark
emotional
tense
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
2.75
2.75 rounded up. generally a fine read that has its many puts and takes. i was on board for most of the beginning. writing is solid and the plot does build suspense, and can appreciate that this book portrays some truly morally grey characters (none of that typical watered down ya stuff, albeit there are caveats to this noted below).
had some issues with the pacing.the hurricane and subsequent search sections could have been cut down substantially . and there’s some head scratching plot points. a hotelier wants to strike up a partnership with some dude he meets on vacation?? I get that he’s jewish so needs a partner to put a different name on the deed but felt like a sus plot thread .
there is also a hyper fixation on physical appearances in this book, which i feel can be severely off putting for folks, though i think it is important in the main character’s journey with her loss of innocence and sexual awakening, etc.
i do have a major bone to pick with the ending though.it’s like the author didn’t have the balls to truly lean into the horridness of the characters and had to redeem evie with some morally upright sanctimonious final act. Know it’s written for a ya audience but that’s gonna lose points from me every single time .
had some issues with the pacing.
there is also a hyper fixation on physical appearances in this book, which i feel can be severely off putting for folks, though i think it is important in the main character’s journey with her loss of innocence and sexual awakening, etc.
i do have a major bone to pick with the ending though.
liz56rose's review against another edition
4.0
I really enjoyed this book. It's about a young girl trying to figure out womanhood in a way....
erinthelibrarian's review against another edition
4.0
I'm still mulling this one over. I thought the book had a slow start to it, but once it picked up it stayed fast paced. The writing was good, the characters well drawn and the sense of time and place were well done and vivid. All of that said I don't entirely feel that it deserved the National Book Award for young people. When all was said and done some of the plot points were disappointing and really one of the biggest secrets I saw coming immediately.
mbdwilson's review against another edition
5.0
This book reminded me of a classic movie, like Sunset Boulevard or All About Eve. The description of the characters, the dialogue, and the setting were amazing. I had a hard time putting this book down.
This is the first book that the author wrote under her real name. The members of the Young Adult book club where I work were speculating what her pseudonym was, and we all considered Judy Blume for a bit. I found the author's Web site and saw that she was also known as Jude Monroe, who writes Star Wars books (mainly journals).
I've never read the Star Wars books, so I'm glad I found the author through this genre. She's a great writer.
This is the first book that the author wrote under her real name. The members of the Young Adult book club where I work were speculating what her pseudonym was, and we all considered Judy Blume for a bit. I found the author's Web site and saw that she was also known as Jude Monroe, who writes Star Wars books (mainly journals).
I've never read the Star Wars books, so I'm glad I found the author through this genre. She's a great writer.
elsaduck's review against another edition
4.0
I had expected it to be mysterious but I wasn't quite expecting the events that took place in the last 50 pages or so. Nevertheless, it is a good book.
jrosenstein's review against another edition
4.0
I'm becoming a fan of the National Book Award committee. Second year in a row they've made excellent choices for young people's literature. This book stands out in a lot of ways. Not only is it a noir for young adults (I know of no others), but it is historical fiction that does not feel at all pedantic or educational. The atmosphere is perfectly woven, the characters incredibly complex, and the lessons learned are meaningful and never trite. It may be too slow to appeal to a lot of teens, but those who are willing to give it a chance will get pulled in.
steelcranberrybatman's review against another edition
2.0
Relatively easy read. The characters are 3 dimensional and real. But not much really happens in the book. There is never a 'oh my gosh' moment, eveything sort of just happens and nothing is too exciting.
I wouldn't read it again, it was lovely but not ground breaking.
I wouldn't read it again, it was lovely but not ground breaking.
crystalstarrlight's review against another edition
4.0
Bullet Review:
I'm still pondering over the events of this novel. I'd say it's got a great message and portrays a time period that tends to get sanitized (oh sure, every woman from the 40's was a virgin on her wedding night - right) rather honestly.
Not sure what the rating will be - probably will stick to 4 stars for all the meat and thoughts it's dredged up in me.
Superb work by the author who wrote "Jedi Apprentice". More YA needs to be written like this.
Full Review:
Evie Spooner lives with her mom, Bev, and her step-dad, Joe. After the War, the family reunites, but it isn't easy. One day, Joe comes home to whisk them away to Palm Beach. But in Palm Beach, Evie meets Peter, someone Joe knew. While she starts to develop a crush on Peter, other lies and truths come to the forefront and before she knows it, she's the only one who can keep her family together.
Judy Blundell is quite the prolific writer. She is also known as Jude Watson, who many Star Wars fans may recognize as the brilliant mastermind of the Jedi Apprentice Series, several journals (including the standout, [b:Darth Maul|359797|Darth Maul|Jude Watson|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1374773882s/359797.jpg|349914]), the Jedi Quest series, and finally the Last of the Jedi series. They were all about middle grade reading levels, and I got more enjoyment from the Jedi Apprentice series than the others, but for Star Wars entertainment, this was some of the best reading enjoyment you could find.
Anyway, Jude Watson impressed me so much, I wanted to read more from her and stumbled upon her real name, Judy Blundell. I think I've been pretty honest that I don't like World War 1 or 2 novels nor am I a fan of anything too "modern" (i.e. McCarthy/Eisenhower, 50's, 60's, you get my drift). However, it was my desire to read Blundell's non-Star Wars work that really drove me to purchase and read this book - even if it took me YEARS after purchasing to read. (Ah, the life of a book hoarder, amirite?)
What I Saw and How I Lied is really a fascinating character study, a mystery of sorts and a coming of age novel. The characters are just so well done, from Evie to her mom to her dad to the Graysons to Peter. I wouldn't say they are all top-notch "likeable" people, but they are flawed. Imperfect. Joe has a temper - but he really does love his wife and daughter and wants to do right by them. (I also think he shows potential signs of PTSD, which made me think of all the men from WWII who came home with PTSD but never got it treated.) Bev has a wandering eye, hates being a housewife - but she LOVES her daughter and would do anything for her. And Evie comes across as naive, but when she needs to grow up, she does so.
There is so much STUFF that happens here. We talk about the continued persecution of the Jews - in the US! We see slut-shaming and victim-blaming in its 40's glory. (Never once glorified though BTW.) I had hazy, summery vibes, reminders of childhood books like [b:The Pink Motel|229847|The Pink Motel|Carol Ryrie Brink|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1387744656s/229847.jpg|222585], a book my mom read to me in the summer after 3rd grade, and that I've loved to death ever since.
I think if there is a flaw in this book, it's that it's so full with all these tiddly-bits, I'm not sure how to tie them all up in the end. Ruthie...Mrs. Grayson...Peter...murder...lies...adultery...coming of age.
In some ways, though, I feel the ending of this coming of age novel was more powerful than a similar one I read for book club, [b:A Northern Light|64481|A Northern Light|Jennifer Donnelly|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1376507768s/64481.jpg|3337093]. At the end of the day, Evie does something big, something that sacrifices her character for her parents. Is it right? It's hard to say - but one thing that Evie comes away with is that she is her own person, with her own voice, and her own choices, and no longer will she bend and sway to the rhythm of other people.
This was a powerful book, one that definitely stuck with me, but also one I feel you have to be in the "right" mood to read. It's not happy or super uplifting, but it's important and impactful.
Judy Blundell has really showed me that she is a great crafter of words, that she is just as good outside Star Wars as in, that she is better at young adult than middle grade, and that more Young Adult authors need to write like she does - conflicted characters, great stories with touches of realism, and important messages without the feeling of being clubbed over the head. I would definitely pick up another of her books in the future.
I'm still pondering over the events of this novel. I'd say it's got a great message and portrays a time period that tends to get sanitized (oh sure, every woman from the 40's was a virgin on her wedding night - right) rather honestly.
Not sure what the rating will be - probably will stick to 4 stars for all the meat and thoughts it's dredged up in me.
Superb work by the author who wrote "Jedi Apprentice". More YA needs to be written like this.
Full Review:
Evie Spooner lives with her mom, Bev, and her step-dad, Joe. After the War, the family reunites, but it isn't easy. One day, Joe comes home to whisk them away to Palm Beach. But in Palm Beach, Evie meets Peter, someone Joe knew. While she starts to develop a crush on Peter, other lies and truths come to the forefront and before she knows it, she's the only one who can keep her family together.
Judy Blundell is quite the prolific writer. She is also known as Jude Watson, who many Star Wars fans may recognize as the brilliant mastermind of the Jedi Apprentice Series, several journals (including the standout, [b:Darth Maul|359797|Darth Maul|Jude Watson|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1374773882s/359797.jpg|349914]), the Jedi Quest series, and finally the Last of the Jedi series. They were all about middle grade reading levels, and I got more enjoyment from the Jedi Apprentice series than the others, but for Star Wars entertainment, this was some of the best reading enjoyment you could find.
Anyway, Jude Watson impressed me so much, I wanted to read more from her and stumbled upon her real name, Judy Blundell. I think I've been pretty honest that I don't like World War 1 or 2 novels nor am I a fan of anything too "modern" (i.e. McCarthy/Eisenhower, 50's, 60's, you get my drift). However, it was my desire to read Blundell's non-Star Wars work that really drove me to purchase and read this book - even if it took me YEARS after purchasing to read. (Ah, the life of a book hoarder, amirite?)
What I Saw and How I Lied is really a fascinating character study, a mystery of sorts and a coming of age novel. The characters are just so well done, from Evie to her mom to her dad to the Graysons to Peter. I wouldn't say they are all top-notch "likeable" people, but they are flawed. Imperfect. Joe has a temper - but he really does love his wife and daughter and wants to do right by them. (I also think he shows potential signs of PTSD, which made me think of all the men from WWII who came home with PTSD but never got it treated.) Bev has a wandering eye, hates being a housewife - but she LOVES her daughter and would do anything for her. And Evie comes across as naive, but when she needs to grow up, she does so.
There is so much STUFF that happens here. We talk about the continued persecution of the Jews - in the US! We see slut-shaming and victim-blaming in its 40's glory. (Never once glorified though BTW.) I had hazy, summery vibes, reminders of childhood books like [b:The Pink Motel|229847|The Pink Motel|Carol Ryrie Brink|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1387744656s/229847.jpg|222585], a book my mom read to me in the summer after 3rd grade, and that I've loved to death ever since.
I think if there is a flaw in this book, it's that it's so full with all these tiddly-bits, I'm not sure how to tie them all up in the end. Ruthie...Mrs. Grayson...Peter...murder...lies...adultery...coming of age.
In some ways, though, I feel the ending of this coming of age novel was more powerful than a similar one I read for book club, [b:A Northern Light|64481|A Northern Light|Jennifer Donnelly|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1376507768s/64481.jpg|3337093]. At the end of the day, Evie does something big, something that sacrifices her character for her parents. Is it right? It's hard to say - but one thing that Evie comes away with is that she is her own person, with her own voice, and her own choices, and no longer will she bend and sway to the rhythm of other people.
This was a powerful book, one that definitely stuck with me, but also one I feel you have to be in the "right" mood to read. It's not happy or super uplifting, but it's important and impactful.
Judy Blundell has really showed me that she is a great crafter of words, that she is just as good outside Star Wars as in, that she is better at young adult than middle grade, and that more Young Adult authors need to write like she does - conflicted characters, great stories with touches of realism, and important messages without the feeling of being clubbed over the head. I would definitely pick up another of her books in the future.
itsjadenbaby's review against another edition
dark
reflective
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.0
Enjoyable and quick read.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Adult/minor relationship, Infidelity, and Antisemitism
Moderate: Misogyny, Sexism, Murder, War, and Classism
Minor: Bullying, Death, Domestic abuse, Physical abuse, Racism, Grief, and Toxic friendship
jgurniak's review against another edition
4.0
It's not very often I come across a YA historical mystery that I actually like. Well done, Judy Blundell!