The design and UX isn't done, Rob and Abbie, okkurrrr! 😌
zivi's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
dark
emotional
funny
mysterious
sad
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.75
artbysmashley's review against another edition
4.0
3.5 stars. It was a bit slow to get into, and the dialogue/Noah’s voice didn’t charm me quite as much as it did in Becoming - but that ENDINg. I’m ready for the last book NOW. It felt like this was one of those books that acts as an in between - like nothing major really happened until the last 30 or so pages. Not the best in the series but it left my eager for the final installment!!!
tatumoshea's review against another edition
2.0
this series will literally just live on my little shelf with no final book huh
ashleyziegler's review against another edition
3.0
WHAT THE HECK DID I JUST READ??? Man. I'm giving this book a solid 3 stars. It was good but nothing that left me desperate to finish in one sitting. So many things were revealed that I just didn't see coming. I really missed Mara being gone from the entire book but it was intriguing to see Noah figure things out and notice things and how the whole story just tied together like a perfectly tied shoe. I still can't wrap my mind around the ending and I have so many freaking questions. The first one is, WHY IS THE NEXT BOOK JUST NOW BEING WRITTEN???? I would've died if I had read this series in 2018 knowing the next book wasn't coming for at least 5 years???? I'd be so mad but I'm glad we're even getting another book and hopefully, we'll finally get answers and this entire thing will have a happy ending.... or hopefully an ending at all??
polygrapheyes's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
funny
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
nata_sa_b's review against another edition
2.0
*To hodnotenie ma bolí!*
Jedno slovo: Zbytočné!
Celý čas sa nič nedeje, akože absolútne nič, okrem toho, že Noah fajčí, pije a berie nejaké tie drogy, pretože jeho život je už aj bez toho tak doje...ehm pokazený, že už ani tie drogy ho nevedia viac dosrať... Myslela som, že toto možno zachráni tú prvú časť, ale toto bolo fakt zlé - neverím, že som to povedala o Noahovom príbehu, ale je to pravda.
Noah sa opúšťa, Noah spomína Maru (nie je strana, kde by ju nespomenul), pričom ona sa v príbehu ani neobjaví (ok, tak na dvoch stranách), zistila som nejaké tie info, ktoré mi síce slabo obohatili moje vedomosti o udalostiach z Horizonu, ale je to zbytočné!Noah naháňa nejakého ducha, Noah sa zas opúšťa.....A toto je celé... Jedine posledných 20 strán ma zničilo, pretože tie postavy mám vážne rada a tá udalosť ma nenechala chladnou. Takže tých posledných 20 strán sa oplatí, zvyšok je.... ehm... sh*t. (Bolí ma srdce, že to musím takto napísať) Prosím, Hodkin, keď si už tak všetky postavy dopinkala, tak aspoň nechaj Maru Marou a nech tam nabehne a spraví poriadky. Pretože ona jediná asi zo všetkých dokáže byť normálna (odvážne tvrdenie, ja viem, ale verte mi, že by ste to videli rovnako ako ja) a nech im tam nakope všetkým zadky...Možno potom trojka nebude fiasko.
Jedno slovo: Zbytočné!
Celý čas sa nič nedeje, akože absolútne nič, okrem toho, že Noah fajčí, pije a berie nejaké tie drogy, pretože jeho život je už aj bez toho tak doje...ehm pokazený, že už ani tie drogy ho nevedia viac dosrať... Myslela som, že toto možno zachráni tú prvú časť, ale toto bolo fakt zlé - neverím, že som to povedala o Noahovom príbehu, ale je to pravda.
Noah sa opúšťa, Noah spomína Maru (nie je strana, kde by ju nespomenul), pričom ona sa v príbehu ani neobjaví (ok, tak na dvoch stranách), zistila som nejaké tie info, ktoré mi síce slabo obohatili moje vedomosti o udalostiach z Horizonu, ale je to zbytočné!Noah naháňa nejakého ducha, Noah sa zas opúšťa.....A toto je celé... Jedine posledných 20 strán ma zničilo, pretože tie postavy mám vážne rada a tá udalosť ma nenechala chladnou. Takže tých posledných 20 strán sa oplatí, zvyšok je.... ehm... sh*t. (Bolí ma srdce, že to musím takto napísať) Prosím, Hodkin, keď si už tak všetky postavy dopinkala, tak aspoň nechaj Maru Marou a nech tam nabehne a spraví poriadky. Pretože ona jediná asi zo všetkých dokáže byť normálna (odvážne tvrdenie, ja viem, ale verte mi, že by ste to videli rovnako ako ja) a nech im tam nakope všetkým zadky...Možno potom trojka nebude fiasko.
kristie5's review against another edition
3.0
This book wasn't my favorite....I really enjoyed Michelle Hodkin's Mara Dyer trilogy so I was excited to read the story of Noah Shaw, but this novel just let me down. The plot is all over the place and very random with a plot twist thrown in at the end. Overall, I would say the story is ok but I don't know if I would continue with this series.
333bias's review against another edition
5.0
I kinda barely remember this book but I feel like it was messy I mean I don’t mind I do love this series but