Reviews

Black Cake by Charmaine Wilkerson

Only show reviews with written explanations

lateresita27's review against another edition

Go to review page

emotional reflective fast-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? No

4.25

cassie_tee's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Lovely book - emotional family connection and a mysterious past that Benny and Byron must uncover.

angelasunshine's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

It took me a long time to finish this book, I found myself putting it down often even though I enjoyed the story. Maybe I was in a funk? Anyway, I liked the story and the flawed, human, characters.

halena's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

it hurts giving this one 3 stars instead of 4, because it’s evident how much love and labor was poured into this. I think Black Cake is an ambitious, well-researched project, that the author should be proud to call a debut. unfortunately, it asks its readers to challenge their suspension of disbelief for a little much, and the roller coaster it takes us through doesn’t always pay off. I would still recommend it however, because there are some great moments here, and where it shines, it’s gorgeous

rrickman33's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

This was a super moving debut novel about two siblings finding each other again after the passing of their mother who left a few family secrets behind for them to find out. The writing in this book was gorgeous and I loved learning about Benny and Byron’s mother’s past as it unfolded. The chapters were super short making it so easy to fall into and had me unable to put it down.

One of the themes of this book was a woman’s shame and was one of the main reasons the family was estranged. Benny had shame and had pulled away from her parents and brother, Benny’s mom had shame and had hidden basically a past life from her children.

To put it perfectly I’ll use a quote from the book itself:
“Why do we women let shame get in the way of our well-being? I thought that times had changed since I was a girl, but apparently, not enough.” This quote really stuck to me while reading this book and had me considering how I’ve let my own shame shape my life and affect my well-being and THAT is a sign of a good book.

I loved reading so much about food and culture in this book and how Black Cake really did tie everything together. I learned so much about the Caribbean Islands and their real life culture in this book and that’s one of my favorite things about reading. It didn’t feel like I was assigned to learn anything but I did anyways and I enjoyed it.

The only reason this ended up not being a five star book for me was the structure of the book. I much preferred the first half of the book and thought the second half couldn’t decide what it wanted to be, it almost ended in a thriller-esque sort of way. Other people from our #tttbookclub did not have a problem with this at all so I think it’s personal to what I was wanting from the ending of the story. As always reading is subjective!

I highly recommend this book, especially for a book club, we had so much to talk about with this one!

mayaperkins's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

A beautiful story of love, loss, and identifying with your culture/who you are through various hardships. I found the past storyline with Covey, Bunny, Grant, and Elly much more engaging and flavourful to read through, as the hardships they go through seemed much more at higher stakes. Nevertheless it was an fascinating contrast (and similarities) to what the younger and current generation struggle through (expectations, mistreatment, race/sexual orientation etc.)