alexisixela14's review against another edition
3.0
since i’m not religious i’m not really the target audience for this book but i still love reading about conservation of biodiversity and showing love for nature!!!!
jclare2's review against another edition
2.0
E.O. Wilson is compelling, as ever. But I bought the book for its premise of making a plea to a Baptist minister for science and religion to find common ground in the cause of conservation (and, thus, the obvious link to my current work). Unfortunately, this premise was the weakest part of the book. He couldn't stop justifying and defending his science-based point-of-view long enough to actually address the common ground with religion for more than a few paragraphs, and typically without any tone of actual respect for a Baptist's point-of-view. A disappointment.
emonroe26's review against another edition
2.0
I had some problems with this book. I really liked the argument format in theory and I think the idea of writing about biodiversity aimed at traditionalist Christian ministers was really interesting. However, I found that the argument seemed to carry a very narrow scope and often seemed to forget about the literal Bible interpretation audience that it is posed to speak to. I also just found a lot of the discussion of biodiversity dull, but that is more of a personal interest thing, not as much of an issue that the book had.
jdoetsch's review against another edition
4.0
Beautifully written call to action towards religious leaders to help prevent the continued loss of Earth's biodiversity. Amazed at how passionate this man is about this subject without getting preachy about it. Would definitely recommend to that religious person you know.
poeticmama's review against another edition
5.0
Beautifully written in the form of a letter, appealing to the morality of religious folk in getting them to see why the fight to save the planet should matter to them!
jrpoole's review against another edition
5.0
This is perhaps the best non-fiction book I've ever read. Ostensibly, it's an argument, an attempt to find common ground with fundamentalists in order to save the earth, but really it's a meditation on the universe and life on this planet.
sloreader's review against another edition
3.0
There's really only one thing wrong with EO Wilson's The Creation, but unfortunately, it's hard to avoid. The framing device, and voice throughout, is that of a personal letter to a hypothetical Southern Baptist pastor, attempting to find common ground between science and religion in the service of conserving the diversity of life on Earth. The device isn't a bad idea; saving Creation, be it nature's or God's, would seem to be of common interest to scientists and pastors. But in the body of this letter, Wilson seems to be preaching to his choir and not the pastor's. Not that he says anything wrong either. Wilson is one of the most passionate advocates of the natural world and of science, and when this passion is on full display, as it is here, he is as inspirational and moving as he is dead-right. Now EO is a southern boy, raised Southern Baptist himself, so I can only assume that he knows his target better than I. But from my perspective, his arguments and challenges don't seem to offer much to a scripture literalist as he says he is addressing, but instead fit right alongside traditional rationales for saving the Earth. Perhaps his emotion alone can carry the message to the unconverted, but it's on that point that I remain unconvinced.
jdoetsch's review
4.0
Beautifully written call to action towards religious leaders to help prevent the continued loss of Earth's biodiversity. Amazed at how passionate this man is about this subject without getting preachy about it. Would definitely recommend to that religious person you know.
More...