Scan barcode
slimikin's review
2.0
I enjoyed the writing in this quite a bit: it's atmospheric and deftly adopts the voices of its various characters. I like the world, too, but Sip's journey through that world is bleak—too bleak for me, even given the occasional flashes of dark humor and sharp philosophical insights.
skundrik87's review against another edition
2.0
I did not really enjoy this. The story was chopped up and a little too poetic to be understood.
sinac's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
medium-paced
2.0
Content Warnings
Graphic: Suicide
spoerk's review
3.0
Thanks to Netgalley for giving me this opportunity to read this book for an honest review.
I read this book in two days. It's not the type of book you'll want to put down. I can see this book having the same appeal to the fans of A Girl With All The Gifts, although there are no zombies.
I liked it, but it's not without its faults. It's very much first novel, where the prose feels a bit flat. There's a lot of action, but without much description of the area this all takes place. A desert near an ocean where there are grapefruits growing (on the land, not in the ocean) so perhaps Florida? It's just troublesome to get a grasp of the environment.
Carr also throws A LOT at the reader without giving any specifics. Like, where and what are theses Dome cities? What exactly do the trains do? And how can some people hide their shadows? (Not a spoiler, because they don't address it except in passing.) Why the actions? What does Drummond's purpose actually do to the story?
The book raises more questions than it answers, which can be fine. But here, it makes me wonder what else could have been accomplished if these questions were answered? Or if some of the asides were cut.
But hey, it's a good beach read. With all the sun and shadows and such.
I read this book in two days. It's not the type of book you'll want to put down. I can see this book having the same appeal to the fans of A Girl With All The Gifts, although there are no zombies.
I liked it, but it's not without its faults. It's very much first novel, where the prose feels a bit flat. There's a lot of action, but without much description of the area this all takes place. A desert near an ocean where there are grapefruits growing (on the land, not in the ocean) so perhaps Florida? It's just troublesome to get a grasp of the environment.
Carr also throws A LOT at the reader without giving any specifics. Like, where and what are theses Dome cities? What exactly do the trains do? And how can some people hide their shadows? (Not a spoiler, because they don't address it except in passing.) Why the actions? What does Drummond's purpose actually do to the story?
The book raises more questions than it answers, which can be fine. But here, it makes me wonder what else could have been accomplished if these questions were answered? Or if some of the asides were cut.
But hey, it's a good beach read. With all the sun and shadows and such.
academianut's review against another edition
2.0
Too disturbing for me, but poetic?
I was drawn in by the premise but the whole thing was too grim and pointless-seeming to me - I mean, it is a post-apocalyptic nightmare, but still... None of the things that happened seemed to have reason for them, just pointless cruelty and bits of friendship, and the one solution to one problem being just a shift in thinking? No. The only reason I gave this book two stars instead of one is it did have poetic language.
I was drawn in by the premise but the whole thing was too grim and pointless-seeming to me - I mean, it is a post-apocalyptic nightmare, but still... None of the things that happened seemed to have reason for them, just pointless cruelty and bits of friendship, and the one solution to one problem being just a shift in thinking? No. The only reason I gave this book two stars instead of one is it did have poetic language.
bluekaren's review against another edition
3.0
I just finished SIP. I don’t really know what I just read. It was written in such lyrical prose that I had a hard time following it. I did catch the gist of the story, but it was problematic for me.
This is the story of Mira, who has a shadow sipping friend named Murk. In the this dystopian story set in the future, the country is divided into those who sip shadows and those who don’t. It started with a boy who discovered he could get high by sipping his own shadow. When that shadow was gone, he set out to steal other living beings(¹) shadows and the sipping sickness spread.
Except a very few like Mira who have learned to hide their shadow, most non shadow sippers carry guns in an effort to keep the dome they live in free of the sickness. Mira’s own mother’s shadow was stolen years ago and so Mira must find and catch living shadows so her mother can sleep. It isn’t fair. When Mira and Murk find an ex-domer, named Bale, they set out together to find a mythological cure that must be found before Hailey’s Comet come, and it is on it’s way.
This book starts off as a straight out story. We are following Mira in her daily struggle to find shadow for her mother. Here we learn so much about the sipping sickness and what it does to those who are effected. Mira is capable of hiding her shadow but how and why are never revealed.
Mira gets this idea to maybe kill herself by trying to cross the tracks that lead to the dome. The tracks are heavily guarded by Domers who don’t want any sippers to get to them, so they shoot on site, and shoot to kill, any who attempt to cross the tracks. Mira isn’t shot by a domer named Bale, who becomes an ex-domer for that act (of not shooting her).
I understood Bale and Mira, but Murk made very little sense to me in this story. We do learn how he became a sipper but he was a hanger-on drug addict that didn’t do much to move the story forward.
The story moves from Mira’s residence at home with her mother, to the “City of Lost Souls”. This is where the story gets a little crooked. There we meet so many new and weird characters. We are also introduced to seemingly random vigilantes from the dome who are either there to kill or save Bale, I am still not sure.
The boss of the city is a man who runs machines that keep limbs alive long enough for their shadows to be sipped on a daily basis, for a price. In the city all three of our characters find what they are looking for and a lot of trouble.
I did say living things right? The shadows don’t have to do anything but be attached to a living thing. The characters talk about sipping from animals but this made me wonder about trees and plants, and even grass since it too can cast shadow and live or die. Maybe I am reading too much into this fictional story. Rules are rules though, so if an author breaks them I do expect some sort of explanation.
I enjoyed parts of this story. I didn’t like the lack of descriptive details setting the scenes for me. We get vague information, like the rind of a grapefruit is bitter, but that was not enough for me to really see this story. There was also banter between characters that did nothing but annoy me. Like the vigilante girls, one of whom tells stories but is as dumb as a rock. While the other girl is just so mean to this stupid girl.
Looking back now, I see this novel was just not something I should have read. I had so many issues with it, but it had a cool concept and I had to give it points for originality. It is almost like the author just wanted to tell the story and let the reader figure out the details for themselves. This takes guts, I think. I got through this whole book because, behind all my complaints, there was a kind of cool story. I wouldn’t say this was a waste of time either, because there is definitely an audience for this style of writing. It just wasn’t for me.
gabriels's review
adventurous
challenging
dark
emotional
hopeful
reflective
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.25
billies_not_so_secret_diary's review against another edition
1.0
this book could've been so much better! The plot and idea were creative, but the writing, not so much. It bounced around so much I stopped caring, but then again it seemed that the author really didn't care much about his characters either.
There were some 'oh!' parts, but not enough for me to recommend this book!
There were some 'oh!' parts, but not enough for me to recommend this book!
hollowspine's review
4.0
A difficult book to describe, Sip, is about a world where people can be addicted to drinking shadows, and if you have your shadow consumed, you become one of the addicted too. The world is split along the same old lines, the haves and the have-nots, those who protect themselves and their shadows in dome cities and the shadow addicted and other assorted survivors outside the domes.
Economies spring up selling sipped shadows from stolen or bartered body parts, kept alive on weird machinery.
One woman with the ability to hide her shadow, a man addicted to shadow, and another recently exiled from one of the dome cities find themselves thrown together, trying to find a cure for having your shadow consumed, testing the theory that if they can kill the person who ate their shadow they can get it back.
Even though it's hard to describe and difficult to explain, the book was well-written, absolutely fascinating and the characters were fun and easy to relate to, even in this mad world. I will check out other books by this author.
Economies spring up selling sipped shadows from stolen or bartered body parts, kept alive on weird machinery.
One woman with the ability to hide her shadow, a man addicted to shadow, and another recently exiled from one of the dome cities find themselves thrown together, trying to find a cure for having your shadow consumed, testing the theory that if they can kill the person who ate their shadow they can get it back.
Even though it's hard to describe and difficult to explain, the book was well-written, absolutely fascinating and the characters were fun and easy to relate to, even in this mad world. I will check out other books by this author.