Reviews with content warning for Sexual violence - La quinta estación

Very slow in the beginning but really picks up at the end and makes all the bits at the beginning click. Brilliant. Very cool world building. Can’t wait to read the next book

Content Warnings

lua_'s review against another edition

Go to review page

dark mysterious reflective sad slow-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Character
Strong character development? No
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.75

I read this book after seeing several people recomend it and hype it up, and I think my mistake was going in with too high expectations.

N.K. Jeminsin created an extremely interesting and complex wolrd, with a unique magic system and a pretty exciting premise, but despite all that, to me, the actual story felt completely bland.

My biggest issue with the book was the main characters, Damaya, Syen and Essun,

them being all the same person, you can see why all of them bothered me the same

so maybe if you like them more you might enjoy the book a little better. But to me it felt like, mainly Syen, was completely incapable of complex thought, she constantly avoids actually thinking about the problem beyond a surface level, to a point that it gets very frustrating,

the god damn volcano in Allia was SUCH an obvious trap, that I feel like after dealing with the guardians and the Fulcrum her whole life it was just so frustrating seeing her think "wow why would the fulcrum leave things like this" and then REFUSE TO THINK MORE ABOUT IT

there are several times in the novel that Syen's Pov says "she couldn't think" and it was just really frustrating. Essun at the very least has a very good reason to refuse thinking in the beginning of the book, but that also gets frustrating after a while. A few times it just felt like the main characters avoided thinking (not asking questions, not reaching conclusions, not making strategies) just so the plot could progress, wich to me made it fell like all three characters weren't active in their own storylines. The world building is very intense wich I do usually like, but in the book there just wasn't a storyline above it that made me actively exited to keep reading.

I do really like the conflicts and the depiction of the abusive and toxic relations between the Guardians and the orogenes in their charge, N.K. went above and beyond with it, and every scene with Damaya and her Guardian had me at the edge of my sit. The mystery of Hoa was also fun to try and figure out, and the dynamics between Syen and Alabaster felt deep and complex in the most interesting of ways

wich only makes Alabaster's state by the end of the book seem more like a waste of potential to me, I really liked him

for the first half of the book most of what happened with Damaya's storyline caught me by surprise, which made it very fun to read.

But at the end it just didn't feel like a lot actually happened during the book, very few moments during all three storylines felt exciting or had any action, so maybe if someone liked slower and less action packed books they might like this this lack of moments, but it just wasn't my cupof tea.

Also this book is VERY heavy on wolrd building and N.K. makes very little effort to explain it all, so I definitely don't recomend it for people who aren't used to lore heavy fantasy.

Overall, to me, it felt like a really interesting world with a very bland main character

The ending does get a little more intense, and leaves off at a cliffhanger, wich is mostly of the reason for me to give the book a 3,7 instead of 3,5. I think I'll read the rest of the series, but I'll definitely have to change my expectations and mindset before starting book two, so that I'm ready for a slow series of tragic happenings, rather then an intense character fighting her way trough events.

Content Warnings