Scan barcode
noellegrace8's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
emotional
hopeful
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
I cannot express how much I love this. Jacks x Evangeline's dynamic just works. He is mean and dark and full of desire, but in a way that makes you know there's a reason he is the way that he is, which gives you hope for him as naive as Evangeline's. He's a fully fleshed out character. She is as well, good-hearted and smart but fully capable of making mistakes. She's like a sweet fluffy pink frosted cupcake. They make every scene interesting. I hate Marisol's character though - she's very much like Taryn from Folk of the Air. And the plot does not disappoint. It is crisp and new, an almost-redo on old fairytales and prophecy stories. So much of the worldbulding/lore and plot twists here are fresh. And I adore the descriptions of all the dresses!!
I give Rebecca Soler's performance 4.5/5⭐️. She gives a steadily good performance in which the listener can tell the difference between the characters. However, sometimes her vocals are far too loud/unequalized.
I give Rebecca Soler's performance 4.5/5⭐️. She gives a steadily good performance in which the listener can tell the difference between the characters. However, sometimes her vocals are far too loud/unequalized.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Blood, Murder, and Injury/Injury detail
Moderate: Confinement, Death, Self harm, Toxic relationship, Violence, and Toxic friendship
Minor: Adult/minor relationship, Animal death, Bullying, Cursing, Emotional abuse, Infidelity, Grief, Cannibalism, Death of parent, Gaslighting, Abandonment, and Alcohol
kenzaett's review
adventurous
emotional
lighthearted
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.75
"Heroes don't get happy endings."
"People called it falling out of love, but falling was easy. Letting go of Luc had been more like climbing the face of a rock. She'd clawed her way out, fighting to shake it off, to let it go, to find something else to hold on to."
"but in every telling of the tale, they fell in love."
"She wasn't making loving choices, she was making compromising choices because she wanted love. Luc wasn't her weakness - love was. Not even just love but the idea of it."
"until I collect it, you're mine, and I do not like to share."
"She didn't make being alone seem lonely as Evangeline had always feared. She made it seem like an adventure, as if every moment were the start of a story with endless possibilities."
So. I gave Stephanie Garber another try after not enjoying the Caraval series. Much to the pressure my friend put on me by gifting me a copy of this and claiming it's much better than Caraval and not necessarily connected - and that the second book is better than the first. I wasn't hooked from the beginning - it was a tad to sweet, too romantic, too whimsical for me. I like a bigger share of action and drama, and less love. But what do you expect from the title. I love the magical, beautiful winter-y universe (though I'd like more lore and world building, alas we're only on book one and I didn't finish the Caraval 3 so that's on me), and the plot was specked with surprises and turns. I'm still unsure how I feel about Jack's. And it's rare that I don't have a favorite character, because some are just too bland for me. Maybe it's LaLa. But her name annoys me. Or the Fortuna's dogs. Agh.
Definitely a few points for absolutely beautiful writing,especially analogies (his lips curved like a crescent blade, she looked like a statue come to life, he looked at her the way that E imagined portraits stared at people when their backs were turned) - damn. I always felt like I was looking into Eve's head, which is a difficult task for third person narration in itself!
I've got a number of wonderfully eloquent quotes I'm saving after this book... Extra star for that!
It's a 3.75 or maybe 4.0 for me, and I'm hoping to give the next part a 4.5! There's definitely more to come and I like how the pace picked up at the end.
"People called it falling out of love, but falling was easy. Letting go of Luc had been more like climbing the face of a rock. She'd clawed her way out, fighting to shake it off, to let it go, to find something else to hold on to."
"but in every telling of the tale, they fell in love."
"She wasn't making loving choices, she was making compromising choices because she wanted love. Luc wasn't her weakness - love was. Not even just love but the idea of it."
"until I collect it, you're mine, and I do not like to share."
"She didn't make being alone seem lonely as Evangeline had always feared. She made it seem like an adventure, as if every moment were the start of a story with endless possibilities."
So. I gave Stephanie Garber another try after not enjoying the Caraval series. Much to the pressure my friend put on me by gifting me a copy of this and claiming it's much better than Caraval and not necessarily connected - and that the second book is better than the first. I wasn't hooked from the beginning - it was a tad to sweet, too romantic, too whimsical for me. I like a bigger share of action and drama, and less love. But what do you expect from the title. I love the magical, beautiful winter-y universe (though I'd like more lore and world building, alas we're only on book one and I didn't finish the Caraval 3 so that's on me), and the plot was specked with surprises and turns. I'm still unsure how I feel about Jack's. And it's rare that I don't have a favorite character, because some are just too bland for me. Maybe it's LaLa. But her name annoys me. Or the Fortuna's dogs. Agh.
Definitely a few points for absolutely beautiful writing,especially analogies (his lips curved like a crescent blade, she looked like a statue come to life, he looked at her the way that E imagined portraits stared at people when their backs were turned) - damn. I always felt like I was looking into Eve's head, which is a difficult task for third person narration in itself!
I've got a number of wonderfully eloquent quotes I'm saving after this book... Extra star for that!
It's a 3.75 or maybe 4.0 for me, and I'm hoping to give the next part a 4.5! There's definitely more to come and I like how the pace picked up at the end.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Bullying, Cannibalism, and Abandonment
Moderate: Death of parent
More...