heatherjay94's review against another edition
2.0
I was really excited when I found this book sitting on a shelf in MPH. I have realized recently that I'd never read any stories that take place in Malaysia - something I decided that I'd like to change. I bought it despite the finding the manifesto rather off-putting, which felt like the most pretentious thing I've read in a while. The book was okay, I suppose. Out of the 15 stories it offered I felt like the only ones I truly enjoyed were 'A Gift of Flowers' (i liked the idea of the travelling bouquet, though the execution left a lot to be desired still) and the witty 'Mud' (with politically incorrect jokes that had me laughing and then feeling mildly guilty afterwards). Many others felt like they had promising premises but the execution fell short of their ambitions. I didn't come expecting to like all the stories - it's an anthology, after all, and a mixed bag is to be expected - but 2 out of 15 is disappointing, to be honest. Maybe I'll have better luck with the next volume. I can appreciate the message most of these stories are trying to bring to light, though, and the fact that this book is even a thing at all.
qomareads's review against another edition
3.0
Oh well, this is the first from the 4 volumes. I have to say I can't wait for the next volumes. Since there are 14 short stories inside this volume it's hard to rate it. I love a little twist at the ending of few stories. It's like watching a thriller movie. There's murder, death and blood. Not that creepy but heck this is not innocent at all.
My favourites will be The Runner, After Dark My Love and The Machete and Me.
A must try if you love thriller. You'll never ever see KL as it used to be.
My favourites will be The Runner, After Dark My Love and The Machete and Me.
A must try if you love thriller. You'll never ever see KL as it used to be.
misspalah's review against another edition
4.0
I literally have no regret buying this book. I was a bit skeptical at first because it's a local product. Fixi has Been famous of producing a very odd and peculiar novels but no once I took interest in buying them until I've found this one in book stores. There are some mind blowing stories but there are some stories is so Sub par to me. However, I'm satisfied with how this book turned out to me. I'm giving this book 4 stars.
heyfarahey's review against another edition
3.0
I only liked 7 short stories out of 15. These seven shorties in my preference are better than my favs in White KL Noir.
But the remaining shorties (which I didnt like) in White KL Noir are better than the Red ones.
My favourites:
- Kiss From A Rose by F. Johanabas
- Chasing Butterflies In The Night by Kris Williamson
- Vanished by Khairulnizam Bakeri (you sir, never disappoint me)
- Cannibal vs Ah Long by Megat Ishak
- The Machete and Me by Dayang Noor
- The Unbeliever by Amir Hafizi
- Mud by Brian Gomez
But the remaining shorties (which I didnt like) in White KL Noir are better than the Red ones.
My favourites:
- Kiss From A Rose by F. Johanabas
- Chasing Butterflies In The Night by Kris Williamson
- Vanished by Khairulnizam Bakeri (you sir, never disappoint me)
- Cannibal vs Ah Long by Megat Ishak
- The Machete and Me by Dayang Noor
- The Unbeliever by Amir Hafizi
- Mud by Brian Gomez
qomareads's review
3.0
Oh well, this is the first from the 4 volumes. I have to say I can't wait for the next volumes. Since there are 14 short stories inside this volume it's hard to rate it. I love a little twist at the ending of few stories. It's like watching a thriller movie. There's murder, death and blood. Not that creepy but heck this is not innocent at all.
My favourites will be The Runner, After Dark My Love and The Machete and Me.
A must try if you love thriller. You'll never ever see KL as it used to be.
My favourites will be The Runner, After Dark My Love and The Machete and Me.
A must try if you love thriller. You'll never ever see KL as it used to be.
misspalah's review
4.0
I literally have no regret buying this book. I was a bit skeptical at first because it's a local product. Fixi has Been famous of producing a very odd and peculiar novels but no once I took interest in buying them until I've found this one in book stores. There are some mind blowing stories but there are some stories is so Sub par to me. However, I'm satisfied with how this book turned out to me. I'm giving this book 4 stars.
frhwrdn's review
3.0
Not my cup of tea. But cool, I tried something new although some stories felt a bit cliche(?)
giralka's review
3.0
I only like three out of fifteen short stories. All the stories are well written but most of them are left hanging, the not so great kind of hanging because it's like you're more of spreading rumors instead of telling a proper story. Good try though.
audreyintheheadphones's review
3.0
Overall, a mixed bag, but that's what you have to say about 95% of anthologies. It's difficult to find 14 short story writers and an essayist who can all hold it together on theme, plot, character and technical excellence. And rating this anthology is complicated by the fact I'm a white non-Malaysian, so I have exactly zero standing to comment on things like authenticity or exoticness. For me it's just good enough that now I know there's a place in the world called Port Klang.
So, in the order they appear in the book:
"The Runner" by Adib Zaini: Teenage girl gets in over her head with drug-runners, has to figure out how to get out. Solid ending.
"Rukun Tetangga" by Preeta Samarasan: About a weird bachelor uncle who gets weirder, but not in any interesting way.
"Mamak Murder Mystery" by Marc de Faoite: was indeed mysterious, and a little ambiguous, but I got the idea it was mostly written to draw attention to the existence of an Indian immigrant population who staff Malaysian fast food restaurants and dream of returning to India. And on that front it was successful.
"Asian Angel" by Shaz Johar: Nice twists, but mostly forgettable.
"A Gift of Flowers" by Shih-Li Kow: I think this story really wanted to go the O. Henry or Isak Dinesen route but the vignettes just weren't sharp enough for the direction to hold.
"Kiss from a Rose" by Fadzlishah Johanabas: Almost worked. Maybe for someone more romantic than me.
"After Dark, My Love" by Dina Zaman: The one essay in the book, it's captivating and informative, but comes totally out of left field. I kept trying to figure out if it was fiction or not.
"The Oracle of Truth" by Eeleen Lee: Brutal and curious, and very nicely done.
"Chasing Butterflies in the Night" by Kris Williamson: Excellent! One of the two most squarely noir stories on offer, and better than a good 80% of the noir shorts I've read lately.
"The Dualist" by Shivani Sivagurunathan: The one story I could not follow at all. At. All. I had no idea who was sleeping with whom, or who thought they were sleeping with someone and who the professor was and who wasn't supposed to know. Someone smarter than me should read this and explain it to me.
"Vanished" by Khairulnizam Bakeri: There's a note in the introduction that the publishers like noir that veers more towards what's thought more as pulp than American conceptions of noir, and this is the story that really kicks off the serious pulp portion of the book. And it's good. It's strange and modern and ghostly and weird.
"Cannibal vs. Ah Long" by Megat Ishak: Not my favorite story in the bunch, but holy crow is it good. It's just balls-out pulp and horror and if that's not enough to convince you to read it, there's this quote from it in the frontispiece to the book: "Several teeth shot out from his rectum and clinked against the porcelain bowl before dropping into the water." Should probably win some sort of award.
"The Machete and Me" by Dayang Noor: My 2nd favorite of the collection, it tells the story of complicated, tragic matriarchies and cursed heirlooms. It passes the Bechdel Test and it's astonishingly good.
"The Unbeliever" by Amir Hafizi: My favorite, hands-down. Three words: Malaysian Cthulhu mythos. All pulp, all the time, no line, no waiting. Like smelling fresh cigar smoke in the library of a mansion when no one's been home for decades. Fantabulous.
"Mud" by Brian Gomez: Mean, nasty and very well done.
Three stars for the collection overall because for me, there was that long section in the middle that felt a little sloggy, but this is the first of four themed volumes from this publisher, so I'll be sure to pick up the next one when it comes out.
So, in the order they appear in the book:
"The Runner" by Adib Zaini: Teenage girl gets in over her head with drug-runners, has to figure out how to get out. Solid ending.
"Rukun Tetangga" by Preeta Samarasan: About a weird bachelor uncle who gets weirder, but not in any interesting way.
"Mamak Murder Mystery" by Marc de Faoite: was indeed mysterious, and a little ambiguous, but I got the idea it was mostly written to draw attention to the existence of an Indian immigrant population who staff Malaysian fast food restaurants and dream of returning to India. And on that front it was successful.
"Asian Angel" by Shaz Johar: Nice twists, but mostly forgettable.
"A Gift of Flowers" by Shih-Li Kow: I think this story really wanted to go the O. Henry or Isak Dinesen route but the vignettes just weren't sharp enough for the direction to hold.
"Kiss from a Rose" by Fadzlishah Johanabas: Almost worked. Maybe for someone more romantic than me.
"After Dark, My Love" by Dina Zaman: The one essay in the book, it's captivating and informative, but comes totally out of left field. I kept trying to figure out if it was fiction or not.
"The Oracle of Truth" by Eeleen Lee: Brutal and curious, and very nicely done.
"Chasing Butterflies in the Night" by Kris Williamson: Excellent! One of the two most squarely noir stories on offer, and better than a good 80% of the noir shorts I've read lately.
"The Dualist" by Shivani Sivagurunathan: The one story I could not follow at all. At. All. I had no idea who was sleeping with whom, or who thought they were sleeping with someone and who the professor was and who wasn't supposed to know. Someone smarter than me should read this and explain it to me.
"Vanished" by Khairulnizam Bakeri: There's a note in the introduction that the publishers like noir that veers more towards what's thought more as pulp than American conceptions of noir, and this is the story that really kicks off the serious pulp portion of the book. And it's good. It's strange and modern and ghostly and weird.
"Cannibal vs. Ah Long" by Megat Ishak: Not my favorite story in the bunch, but holy crow is it good. It's just balls-out pulp and horror and if that's not enough to convince you to read it, there's this quote from it in the frontispiece to the book: "Several teeth shot out from his rectum and clinked against the porcelain bowl before dropping into the water." Should probably win some sort of award.
"The Machete and Me" by Dayang Noor: My 2nd favorite of the collection, it tells the story of complicated, tragic matriarchies and cursed heirlooms. It passes the Bechdel Test and it's astonishingly good.
"The Unbeliever" by Amir Hafizi: My favorite, hands-down. Three words: Malaysian Cthulhu mythos. All pulp, all the time, no line, no waiting. Like smelling fresh cigar smoke in the library of a mansion when no one's been home for decades. Fantabulous.
"Mud" by Brian Gomez: Mean, nasty and very well done.
Three stars for the collection overall because for me, there was that long section in the middle that felt a little sloggy, but this is the first of four themed volumes from this publisher, so I'll be sure to pick up the next one when it comes out.
More...