mehsi's review against another edition
5.0
Re-read 2021: Decided to do some rereading of graphic novels, this one was the first on my pile to read. I really enjoyed this re-read, especially since now, despite it being 5 years later, I knew what to expect of this book. I loved seeing the family explore the island and see what happened to the buildings and stuff and remember memories of their time there. From ordering pizza, going to school on the mainland, friendships, and more.
--------------------------
4.5 stars. Not entirely what I was hoping for/thinking this one was.
What I was thinking this would be (based on the blurb + cover) was a book about a girl who lived a big part of her youth on a prison island. About her struggles, about living life on such a place, on making friends. Starting from the beginning, until the moment they had to move again/she was moving because she was older.
Instead it was just bits and pieces here and there, hotchpotch in ages, and mostly triggered due to the island shutting down and them taking one last trip.
It was good, don't get me wrong, but again, I expected a totally different book. I kept re-reading the blurb to make sure I had the right book/that I wasn't missing anything. So I do have to deduce a half a star for it being totally different.
Of course, like I said, the book was still good, it was really interesting to read about her experiences on the island, to see the island itself, and see how everything looked. I can imagine that kids might get bored on the island. They couldn't play in the forests, because it was a protected area. They couldn't play in the ocean, because of the currents. They only could go to the park, or if they really wanted go to the mainland, though that seemed to be quite a Russian roulette of trying to get there on time to do stuff + then having to get back on time for the last boat.
It also seemed quite exciting, living on an island with inmates in a prison. Inmates who at times escape, or are unaccounted for and thus causes a lockdown.
So I did enjoy the book, it was interesting, though I wish it was a bit more in-depth. It felt a bit bare bones at times. Maybe also because of my expectations, maybe because it was truly just that.
The art was pretty decent, it is a style I see often in graphic novels, it looks quite good close-up, but when it gets to further away perspective it turns into stick-puppets, which is not really so great.
But all in all, I would recommend this one. Don't be fooled by the blurb though.
Review first posted at http://twirlingbookprincess.com/
--------------------------
4.5 stars. Not entirely what I was hoping for/thinking this one was.
What I was thinking this would be (based on the blurb + cover) was a book about a girl who lived a big part of her youth on a prison island. About her struggles, about living life on such a place, on making friends. Starting from the beginning, until the moment they had to move again/she was moving because she was older.
Instead it was just bits and pieces here and there, hotchpotch in ages, and mostly triggered due to the island shutting down and them taking one last trip.
It was good, don't get me wrong, but again, I expected a totally different book. I kept re-reading the blurb to make sure I had the right book/that I wasn't missing anything. So I do have to deduce a half a star for it being totally different.
Of course, like I said, the book was still good, it was really interesting to read about her experiences on the island, to see the island itself, and see how everything looked. I can imagine that kids might get bored on the island. They couldn't play in the forests, because it was a protected area. They couldn't play in the ocean, because of the currents. They only could go to the park, or if they really wanted go to the mainland, though that seemed to be quite a Russian roulette of trying to get there on time to do stuff + then having to get back on time for the last boat.
It also seemed quite exciting, living on an island with inmates in a prison. Inmates who at times escape, or are unaccounted for and thus causes a lockdown.
So I did enjoy the book, it was interesting, though I wish it was a bit more in-depth. It felt a bit bare bones at times. Maybe also because of my expectations, maybe because it was truly just that.
The art was pretty decent, it is a style I see often in graphic novels, it looks quite good close-up, but when it gets to further away perspective it turns into stick-puppets, which is not really so great.
But all in all, I would recommend this one. Don't be fooled by the blurb though.
Review first posted at http://twirlingbookprincess.com/
sizrobe's review against another edition
4.0
Interesting enough memiors about living as a child on a the titular prison island where their parents work. Interesting enough. The art isn't super detailed but is serviceable.
pikasqueaks's review against another edition
The art style here was cute, but the story itself was less about her time growing up on the island, and more about her family revisiting once it'd been shut down.
thebookishlibrarian's review against another edition
Colleen Frakes was an island brat growing up: she and her family lived on the last prison that was only accessible via boat or plane, and of course her parents worked there as well. Now she’s older and the prison is closing down for good. What was once her life will now become distant memories.