Reviews

Carrot by Vanita Oelschlager

kittykult's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Disclaimers: I received a free digital copy of this book in return for an honest review.

Disclaimers, Pt. II: I read this to my very own little orange kitty, Hobbes, as a bedtime story. Go ahead and judge me, but he is very contentedly snoozing right meow.

An adorable book about a little orange kitty who gets jealous when she sees another kitty being pampered - however, after reflecting, she comes to the conclusion that she likes her own life! This would be great for teaching children values about appreciating what they have and that there are ups and downs to every life. This is a book for kiddies (and kitties) of all ages.

kaylana's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

A classic tale on 'the grass is always greener on the other side' story. Carrot lives in the city and dreams of living the high life on a yacht and in a big mansion. But she comes around and realizes she's got it pretty good by realizing the freedoms she has that the rich kitty doesn't. It's cute. My son enjoyed the illustrations and the adventures of Carrot.

I received this through NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.

booksonhermind's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

Carrot the cat has a pretty good life. She lives in a house that's not too big and not too small, she gets to nap the day away, and chase mice up and down streets but also ends up helping a mouse recovering from the flu.



One day she sees this cat on a boat but not just any boat - a yacht. She starts imagining what life would be like as this beautiful and rich cat. Infinite amounts of comfort, food, and grooming. Doesn't sound too bad but really what would her family do without her and is that life really worth it?

Okay. This was my first review of a picture book in a long time. As you know I've decided to read more picture books so here's the first in what I hope to be many. So far so good.

I love cats even though they do tend to break my heart. I've raised a kitten before and you can't believe the quirks you notice on a cat that you raised. So of course I wanted to read this book and especially with all the hilarious cat photos cropping up all over the place I felt like reading a book about cats.

Maybe it's just me but the rhymes felt not as natural as I would have liked. I think it's just because it's a new author and I'm pretty new at reviewing picture books. It was a nice tale about loving where you are and who you are but it didn't make me jump for joy at how amazing it was.


The illustrations were pretty unique in that it looked like the pictures were cut out and pasted to make a 3-D effect without it actually being a pop-up book. It was a nice effect but the pictures were all right. I rather have had the colors encompass the whole page though. I don't want a patch of white on my picture book. It was still a nice read and according to the back of the book the net profits of the book will go to charitable organizations including the author's husbands disease - multiple sclerosis which is a truly great thing and I commend the author on doing that. Also she has her own publishing - VanitaBooks so she's indie! A great thing to be.

http://shesgotbooksonhermind.blogspot.com/

boghunden's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Got this from Netgalley.

Such a cute little story. The illustrations are stunning. I can imagine children wanting to stare at them for hours. The story is good and teaches us that love and friendship is worth more than money. Definitely recommeding this one!
More...