Reviews

The Invisible Library, by Genevieve Cogman

hellocookie's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous mysterious medium-paced

5.0

Such a fun concept and book! I loved every moment of it.

passifloraincarnata's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous funny lighthearted mysterious fast-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Plot
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? No

5.0

Jorge Luis Borges' Library of Babel is always a tantalizing theme for book-lovers to dream about, and I'm a total sucker for stories that riff on it.  This is the most delightful romp through Babel Library since Jasper Fforde's Thursday Next series:  a bit of Victoriana, a bit of steampunk, action, mystery, and despite the monsters, vampires, and psychokillers...   lighthearted and fast-paced, without excessive vulgarity or graphic sex.  Just what I was looking for to while away a lazy afternoon. 

lyndsreadsbooks's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous mysterious tense medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Plot
  • Strong character development? No
  • Loveable characters? No
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? No

3.5

flosch's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Random human: Hey Finn, wanna read a book about books. A whole pile of books that live in a library that connect to alternate universes?

Me: Do you even have to ask?

*end of story*

munderoon's review against another edition

Go to review page

DNF at 30% (no rating because... no, better not.)
This surely is a book for Sherlock Holmes lovers or people who like a bit dusty and abstract parallel worlds, but for me there was just something missing. I couldn't connect to Irene, thought she was a bit one dimensional and Kai was promising but their conversations lacked chemistry. I hate to say it, but The Invisible Library is one of the few books I'm not gonna finish reading. It was between Throne of Glass and this one and the mainstream movement just influenced me to give Sarah J. Maas another try.
Sorry!
(May be included in a Give-Away for my 1 year blog anniversary)

verity_____'s review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous mysterious tense fast-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Plot
  • Strong character development? It's complicated
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.5

bloggingwithdragons's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Review originally posted on Blogging with Dragons
 
Oh my gosh! I did not expect to love this book as much as I did! In fact, I read the whole thing in one day, without being able to put it down! The idea of this book just blew me away and I truly wish I had thought of it! Like the title suggests, in this book, an invisible library exists outside of space and time. It connects to all of the worlds and their alternates and its Librarians travel to these worlds as spies and thieves—for a lack of better terms—to collect copies of unique books, which don’t exist in other worlds, to archive and preserve them in the secret Library. I am always a bit skeptical about anything involving alternate realities, as I am not a big fan of time paradoxes and their ramifications—been there and played that video game, thank you very much—but this book proves that alternate realities can actually be quite fun! And to top it off, this captivating idea is carried out in a witty, well-thought out way, with a capable and level-headed heroine, whom I instantly liked, at the forefront of this well-developed world—er, rather—worlds.
 
The novel follows Librarian Irene on the most dangerous mission of her career yet. As she puts it,
“She’d had dozens of missions where she’d simply wandered in, quietly bought a copy of the book in question, and left without anyone so much as noticing her. And at least ten assignments where there had been some minor illegality involved, but none had featured chases through the streets, dangerously flamboyant personalities, or cyborg alligators.”
 
On her latest mission, Irene is given a sinister, skin-snatching villain to fight against, a dragon as a love interest, as well as the aid of a private detective with a saber hidden in his walking stick, and the use of the library’s Language, an ever-evolving language that only Librarians can read and use. This Language affects certain characteristics of reality and works best when “instructing things to be what they naturally were or to do what they naturally wanted to do.” Nothing like escaping a villain and his cronies in a museum by bringing stuffed animals back to life, eh?
 
But having the Language of the Library at her disposal does not make Irene any less relatable. She, like most normal librarians and book lovers of all world, “just wanted—had always wanted—a good book to read” and as she puts it, “Being chased by hellhounds and blowing things up were comparatively unimportant parts of the job. Getting the books—now, that was what really mattered to her.” Plus, I love her sense of humor and found myself snickering at many of her remarks, one such being to her trainee, Kai, “Let’s just be grateful that corsets aren’t required wear any longer.” When he asks why he should be grateful about this, she responds, “Because you don’t have to deal with me while I’m wearing one.” And another scene depicts her struggle to decide whether it was “more important to maintain her cover as a helplessly feminine secretary or to beat the bag–snatcher over the head with the chair and take him prisoner.”
 
The book isn’t just a light-hearted romp; however, it also poses very interesting questions and moral dilemmas. Many of these questions makes the heroine realize that she doesn’t even know all of the answers. For instance, as there are alternate universes, what is stopping a Librarian from entering that alternate world , introducing new technology available in other worlds—that could even save lives or make that world a better place—or instead, making it into her own world built around her desires? I quite liked the implications of this moral dilemma and was even more pleased by the heroine’s consideration of it when confronted with a villain who aims to make worlds into his very own. It’s interesting, and a different spin than the usual go-to-an-alternate-world-and-stop-something-from-happening-and-then-deal-with-all-of-the-consequences-of-that-new-action time-paradox junk that is everywhere. Sure, I’m sure everyone wonders what would happen if they hadn’t poured that glass of orange juice and spilled it all over their white sweater, but it’s been done so many times, and as such, I find it quite boring.
 
The ethical quandary The Invisible Library presents is completely refreshing to me, making Librarians, who are actually the keepers and protectors of many worlds—in the form of books—into their literal role and ramping it up, by giving them the potential to be God-like entities. And on top of this, I also liked that all of the worlds to which the Librarians traveled, had a very delicate balance of lawful and chaotic forces—making some worlds more prone to the impossible and others quite structured and logical. Plus, the balance often shifts with the interference of dragons (lawful) and fae (chaotic) beings, making even more endless possibilities to an already endless strew of worlds and universes and the librarians that travel them. In fact, it is mentioned many times throughout the novel, that it is very dangerous for the secret of Librarians and the many worlds to get out—one wrong word here and there about technologies that don’t exist, and things can get very chaotic, and fast. The precarious balances of the world and the secret mission of the Librarian visitors gives the series a potential that I can easily see being very interesting in future installments of the series.
 
Though I am always a sucker for stories about kickass Librarians, this book went above and beyond my expectations and I am honestly more than ready to splurge and to buy the rest of the series (even though I have so many other books I should read first). So if you’re looking for a book about Librarians, definitely don’t hesitate to pick this one up, especially if you liked “Ink and Bone.” Ultimately, I prefer this book to the former, and I cannot wait to learn more about this series, most especially the secrets of this mysterious Library—something that this book certainly laid groundwork for—but didn’t illuminate on too much. I also have my prediction about Irene’s parents and her true origins, which I can’t wait to confirm or to deny. And even though the book states that “a good Librarian [is] supposed to read headlines, not make them,” I have a feeling Librarian Irene will be making a lot of headlines in the future and I will definitely be reading them.
 

immanythings's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

This a so good. I started reading and couldn't put it down. The changes in places and how things are moved about through time remind me of Makayla's dimensional travels in Karen Marie Moning's Fever Series. WOW!! Can't wait to start the next installment for the 2017 Challenge!! Woo-Hoo!!

I just finished this book; if being a librarian means having these adventures then sign me up NOW!!

dryhop's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

This book was fun. There was a decent amount of intrigue and complicated world building. It played on well worn tropes without just parading them out as new and innovative when they clearly aren't. I enjoyed this book.

I will say one thing; this book seemed to have a wee bit of an identity crisis. It wanted to be a mystery, I think, and it had intrigue moments and thriller moments and character exploration moments and what I am going to call a Dieselpunk motif. The problem isn't that it had all of these. The problem was that it wasn't quite sure which one was paramount. I would have to say that the mystery was king, but a great deal of the book was spent on the various relationships of the characters. Which is good, but it made the thriller/intrigue moments seem not clunky but odd that everyone was just suddenly cool with each other. For a minute.

I also would say that this book does one thing I am not a big fan of in first books. It doesn't end satisfactorily for me assuming that the mystery was the primary focus. Sure, there is a sort-of ending to the mystery of the Grimm book. But I do mean sort-of. And so many more questions are asked that are not answered. Personally, I want to see a first book wrap up in a convincing and satisfactory manner. It can leave questions unanswered (and should). But not primary questions. I want to see a complete story before I am willing to invest in a trilogy or whatever. I feel cheated when a first book introduces a bunch of characters and conflicts and questions and then says, "Stay tuned for book two!"

Overall, though, I did like this book. The character relationships are interesting even if I can't decipher some of them. The politics of the Library are baffling and seem complex. The main character, Irene, and her battle between her humanity and her duty is intriguing. The setting is interesting and I think that the magic system, at least the Language, is well constructed and thought out. So while I am not a fan of cliffhanger endings, I am hooked enough to look for book two.

rankkaapina's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

I really liked this book. It was a fast read for me. But in the end I'm somewhat disappointed. I kind of expected from the premise that I would LOVE this book, which is the reason for the disappointment. I think my problem is that I love character driven books and I would say that even though the characters aren't one-dimensional or anything, this felt more like a short introduction and I kind of wanted more. There was a lot happening and I guess the plot was more important to the book, but I always prefer character driven books to plot driven ones. Definitely checking out the next book too, though. I did give 4 stars, though, cause I think that that's what I would've thought without my expectations.

*****
Edit 11.8.2016: I came upon a review that summed up what was bothering me about this book. So, I ended up taking one star away and most likely won't go to the next book. I won't be listing the reasons here, rather here is the link.