Reviews

The Great Death by John E. Smelcer

librariann's review

Go to review page

4.0

Ages 10+ (an attempted rape, but the attack is not explicit)

A simple yet effective story of two Alaskan sisters who survive a smallpox epidemic that kills every other person in their native village. Desperate to find other survivors, the girls travel downriver as winter takes hold. Good for reluctant or hi/lo readers.

thebooksupplier's review

Go to review page

3.0

Preview at the (book) supplier: http://wp.me/p1D93k-su

kukushka's review

Go to review page

5.0

This would work well as a middle grade book, or enjoyable as an adult reader.

Though not particularly graphic, the subject matter is obviously rather horrific. The scenes near the beginning of the dying/dead village were particularly difficult.

I really liked the two girls and their changing relationship, and the writing style has a very "storyteller" feel to it (it reads almost as though I was being told the story out loud). There's a lot of emotional punch for such a short story.

luaucow's review

Go to review page

3.0

The storyline was interesting, but I listened to this one and I really thought the grandmotherly voiced narrator detracted from this audiobook. It would have had more teen appeal if an age-appropriate narrator performed it.
More...