Scan barcode
moonytoast's review against another edition
adventurous
funny
mysterious
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
3.5
Thank you to Netgalley and Algonquin Young Reader's for providing me with a digital ARC of this book!
William Ritter’s Rook is a blessed return to form with its quirky, mystery-solving duo of Abigail Rook and R.F. Jackaby that demonstrates the true strength of the original Jackaby series. This novel picks up several months after the previous book, where an inter-dimensional war was waged, the veil between New Fiddleham and the other side was left partially open, and Abigail Rook inherited the title of the Seer from Jackaby. While it does essentially operate as a “standalone mystery” within the world Ritter has created, my first attempt at reading Rook—having only read the first book in the series—felt like jumping into a television series at the halfway point, i.e. watching Teen Wolf for the first time but starting with season 3B.
William Ritter’s Rook is a blessed return to form with its quirky, mystery-solving duo of Abigail Rook and R.F. Jackaby that demonstrates the true strength of the original Jackaby series. This novel picks up several months after the previous book, where an inter-dimensional war was waged, the veil between New Fiddleham and the other side was left partially open, and Abigail Rook inherited the title of the Seer from Jackaby. While it does essentially operate as a “standalone mystery” within the world Ritter has created, my first attempt at reading Rook—having only read the first book in the series—felt like jumping into a television series at the halfway point, i.e. watching Teen Wolf for the first time but starting with season 3B.
After holing herself up in 929 Augur Lane for months trying to understand and test her new powers, Abigail Rook returns to her role as a detective and is shocked to find how much supernatural chaos has been happening on the streets of New Fiddleham. Tasked with a new case, it is up to Abigail herself to solve a string of homicides and missing persons cases that threatens the new, tenuous dynamic between humans and the supernatural world.
I truly enjoyed seeing the way in which Abigail is struggling to adjust to her new role as the Seer and the shift in dynamic between her and Jackaby, now that he has lost the sight. (The Watson has become the Holmes, if you will.) Their different personalities and manners of investigating have been a fun draw to this series for me and I appreciated that the change in the role of Seer did not completely alter their dynamic and, frankly, further enhanced their friendship.
The original four books in the Jackaby series have their highs and lows and, while this may not technically be the fifth installment, I would consider it among the highs of the world Ritter created. These books shine when focused on the nitty-gritty of investigating odd supernatural mysteries, the dynamic between Rook and Jackaby, and their complicated love of the city of New Fiddleham and people—and creatures—who have made their home there.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Death and Violence
Moderate: Kidnapping and Murder
More...