Scan barcode
dilemmanorton's review against another edition
3.0
This book pulled me through, and left my heart exposed open with very little closure. If you're ready for that rollercoaster, then dive right in.
I expected a mystery novel but it's definitely more of a social commentary about the child welfare system, racism, and the fallacy of a being a "good person". Set in Vancouver, BC, Jessica is a social worker who discovered the bodies of two girls in her parent's freezer after her mother's passing. This discovery doesn't line up at all with the mother that Jessica knew, or the woman her father married. The terrible discovery makes Jessica question just about everything in her life. My heart hurt for her realizations, but then broke even more reading the story of the two girls. There are several sad story-lines in this book but I ate each of them up. As I said to my partner as I was frustratingly reading the last few pages, "they aren't going to tell me what happened because I think they want to make a point." I think the point would have been enough had I not assumed this was going to be a murder mystery with a big exciting twist at the ending.
I expected a mystery novel but it's definitely more of a social commentary about the child welfare system, racism, and the fallacy of a being a "good person". Set in Vancouver, BC, Jessica is a social worker who discovered the bodies of two girls in her parent's freezer after her mother's passing. This discovery doesn't line up at all with the mother that Jessica knew, or the woman her father married. The terrible discovery makes Jessica question just about everything in her life. My heart hurt for her realizations, but then broke even more reading the story of the two girls. There are several sad story-lines in this book but I ate each of them up. As I said to my partner as I was frustratingly reading the last few pages, "they aren't going to tell me what happened because I think they want to make a point." I think the point would have been enough had I not assumed this was going to be a murder mystery with a big exciting twist at the ending.
msnreynolds's review against another edition
3.0
This was part of the May Fold Challenge - A Mystery or Crime Fiction by an Asian Canadian author.
sa_wah's review against another edition
2.0
I loved elements of this story and the writer's descriptive style, but I completely hated most of the characters. Their relationships we shallow and unrealistic. I especially disliked how she portrayed gender stereotypes about men, etc. I don't mind a shallow book with shallow characters if it's admittedly that. It felt like it's either a shallow book struggling for depth, or a potentially deeper story pandering to a shallow reader. I couldn't tell which.
horthhill's review against another edition
1.0
'The Conjoined' by Jen Sookfong Lee was disappointing. It was something of a precious read: there was no resolution to the main plot. How did they die? Don't know. Who killed? Don't know. From the first chapter when we meet the bodies I figured by the last chapter we would know. We don't.
fallingletters's review against another edition
4.0
Review originally published 9 September 2016 at Falling Letters. I received a copy from the publisher.
One might argue that the cover and jacket description tricks the reader into thinking this is a dark thriller in the vein so popular these days. That closing statement in the description, however, hints there's more going on here than a gruesome murder mystery. For me, this is a story about family relationships and how they can break and fail. It's also about identity, suffering, broken social systems, and understanding how the past forms us. There's a lot going on here, but these themes organically engage and shape one another in The Conjoined.
Despite knowing that two young foster girls would end up dead in a freezer, I didn't anticipate having my heart broken by Casey and Jamie. The story's focus on family relationships and broken social systems makes for a tough read. Lee takes us inside the the girls' family and shows us how their lives fell apart. This quote from the girls' mother's perspective especially got me:
Prose like Lee's makes me think about why I could never be a strong writer. It's the little vignettes that always make me pause. Those small personal observations of thoughts, characters, events, etc., bring depth and beauty to the story. These sorts of things I would never think to write about. I'm not a close observer of the world around me (alas, one of my faults!). This is why I love reading. To see, experience, feel, things I might otherwise have overlooked. Example:
Some final notes on things I liked: I liked Jess, mostly because I sympathized with her attitude toward her boyfriend and the detective... I also liked how personal recollections interweave with her present day perspective. Jess' memories slip easily into her present day narrative, just as one might slip into a daydream while folding laundry. I liked the role Jess's father, plays in the story.
The Bottom Line: Don't read this for the whodunit side of the story. Read it for the considered exploration of 'the myth of social heroism' and the difficult relationships that factor into it.
One might argue that the cover and jacket description tricks the reader into thinking this is a dark thriller in the vein so popular these days. That closing statement in the description, however, hints there's more going on here than a gruesome murder mystery. For me, this is a story about family relationships and how they can break and fail. It's also about identity, suffering, broken social systems, and understanding how the past forms us. There's a lot going on here, but these themes organically engage and shape one another in The Conjoined.
Despite knowing that two young foster girls would end up dead in a freezer, I didn't anticipate having my heart broken by Casey and Jamie. The story's focus on family relationships and broken social systems makes for a tough read. Lee takes us inside the the girls' family and shows us how their lives fell apart. This quote from the girls' mother's perspective especially got me:
No one would believe that she was a good mother. No one would think she had tried her best. She was on the verge of losing her girls, not to a bearded, smelly man in a rusty pick-up truck, but to a phalanx of people who would look at her and see her mistakes, the gaps of time that she had left her daughters alone, the frank conversations she might have started with them but didn't. She had worried over the wrong threats. (81)
Prose like Lee's makes me think about why I could never be a strong writer. It's the little vignettes that always make me pause. Those small personal observations of thoughts, characters, events, etc., bring depth and beauty to the story. These sorts of things I would never think to write about. I'm not a close observer of the world around me (alas, one of my faults!). This is why I love reading. To see, experience, feel, things I might otherwise have overlooked. Example:
She didn't know what she was crying about - her mother, Trevor, or the girls - but it didn't matter. She knew that weeping was its own vortex. It spun and pulled until identifiable feelings were no more than fragments, like half-words that only hinted at meaning. She let her arms and legs curl until she was huddled, small, on the floor of the hallway. (26)
Spoiler
I did wonder about the fact that neither Jess nor her father (let alone anyone else) ever went into those freezers for 27 years. The detective briefly addresses this conundrum at one point, but it's a moot point. This not a whodunit. For those of us who like tidy stories with clear endings, we might find reason to be unsatisfied here. Personally, I felt only a small bit of disappointment. Of course I would rather know than not know, but not knowing didn't spoil the ending, as it might have in a lesser story. I understand that you can't always get a neat little ending with all the answers (in life or in fiction). This story is, to some extent, about how two girls wind up in a freezer - but it is not about the particular logistics; it's about something more. And I'm sure this ties in, somehow, to Jess's growth as a character and her acceptance with not knowing what happened and not knowing her mother as well as she thought. But that's a bit beyond my literary analysis capabilities. :PSome final notes on things I liked: I liked Jess, mostly because I sympathized with her attitude toward her boyfriend and the detective... I also liked how personal recollections interweave with her present day perspective. Jess' memories slip easily into her present day narrative, just as one might slip into a daydream while folding laundry. I liked the role Jess's father, plays in the story.
The Bottom Line: Don't read this for the whodunit side of the story. Read it for the considered exploration of 'the myth of social heroism' and the difficult relationships that factor into it.
amn028's review against another edition
4.0
An interesting story which starts with a mystery but quickly turns into so much more. There are several layers to the story, which work seamlessly together. The story flips back and forth through the years to fill in the blanks and deepens the mysteries. It was interesting to watch as the main character starts questioning everything in relation to the freezer find and how it affects her life. I loved the ending. It was authentic to the story.
marshaskrypuch's review against another edition
4.0
This is not a thriller but I guess it's been marketed that way to get more readers. It's a family drama, and a darned good one. There are two dead girls in the freezer, but this novel isn't a whodunit but more of a whydoneit. Jen Sookfong Lee builds a cast of very human characters, each having flaws and pretty much everyone longing for an elusive happiness and these individual pursuits combo into a deadly result. If you're looking for a breathtaking pageturner a la Gillian Flynn, this isn't it. But if you want to read a finely crafted novel about people who will seem so real to you that you'll forget you're reading a book, then pick this one up.
Thank you, Netgalley, for the opportunity to read The Conjoined.
Thank you, Netgalley, for the opportunity to read The Conjoined.
mollyfy's review against another edition
dark
mysterious
reflective
sad
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
2.5
juicygreenmom's review against another edition
dark
emotional
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.75