Scan barcode
talonsontypewriters's review against another edition
adventurous
lighthearted
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.0
Content Warnings
Graphic: Misogyny, Racism, and Sexism
Moderate: Animal death, Death, Gore, Violence, Xenophobia, Blood, Death of parent, Colonisation, Injury/Injury detail, and Classism
Minor: Slavery, Suicide, and Murder
shay_talksbooks's review against another edition
adventurous
funny
lighthearted
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Loveable characters? Yes
4.25
Close Encounter's Book Club October pick
This was a wonderful melting pot of Regency London meets magical realism, and I thoroughly enjoyed it. We follow Zacharias, England's first black Sorcerer Royal, as he navigates his new role, the dwindling supply of English magic, and the views of the rest of the Royal Society for Unnatural Philosopher's. Along the way he meets Prunella, a witch with exceptional talent in a world where women are not deemed capable of such feats.
There was a lot of exploration of racism, sexism and classism, touching on slavery at times too. There were moments that the frequency of racist & sexist views/comments seemed a little heavy-handed, but it felt very plausible for the period the book was set. I honestly think the setting wouldn't have felt as 'believable' or 'authentic' if it wasn't included.
I enjoyed the story, loved meeting all of the side characters (perhaps even enjoyed them more than the main characters at times), loved Prunella & Mak Genggang, and I'm intrigued to see where the second book in the duology takes us.
The only negatives I had: I would've loved some more world-building (on the magical side) and lot of the plot/twists were a little predictable.
This was a wonderful melting pot of Regency London meets magical realism, and I thoroughly enjoyed it. We follow Zacharias, England's first black Sorcerer Royal, as he navigates his new role, the dwindling supply of English magic, and the views of the rest of the Royal Society for Unnatural Philosopher's. Along the way he meets Prunella, a witch with exceptional talent in a world where women are not deemed capable of such feats.
There was a lot of exploration of racism, sexism and classism, touching on slavery at times too. There were moments that the frequency of racist & sexist views/comments seemed a little heavy-handed, but it felt very plausible for the period the book was set. I honestly think the setting wouldn't have felt as 'believable' or 'authentic' if it wasn't included.
I enjoyed the story, loved meeting all of the side characters (perhaps even enjoyed them more than the main characters at times), loved Prunella & Mak Genggang, and I'm intrigued to see where the second book in the duology takes us.
The only negatives I had: I would've loved some more world-building (on the magical side) and lot of the plot/twists were a little predictable.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Racial slurs, Racism, and Sexism
Minor: Slavery
drjoannehill's review against another edition
adventurous
funny
lighthearted
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.5
Now we have dissected this at our book club I can give some more thoughts!
I enjoyed this lighhearted fantasy which channelled Jane Austen, Georgette Heyer, and Susanna Clarke's Johnathan Strange and Mr Norrell. At times it felt like Strange and Norrell fan fic, and it wasn't as complex, but it was certainly more diverse regarding the characters and their backgrounds. It was also compared to Harry Potter which I can see.
We meet Zacharias, who as a boy was purchased (or stolen) off a slave ship and brought up to learn about English magic. He becomes the Sorcerer Royal in mysterious circumstances which are later revealed. He is invited to give a speech about magic (or the dangers of it) at a girls school where young ladies are taught to suppress their magic, meets Prunella who is a bit of a Hermione character, and thus begin their adventures to tackle the belief that women shouldn't do magic, via stopping a diplomatic breakdown between Britain and an island nation in south east Asia, and a scheming mermaid.
The idea that women should not do magic because it is dangerous for them is laid on a bit thick, but it is not out of character for the time. I thought it a clever book at times, with plenty to say about colonialism, sexism, and classism, and lots of cute magical ideas. Also like the Emily Wilde Encyclopedia series.
Very fast paced - the story jumps in and the world building happens along the way, or not at all, barely any taking time to explain something - you have to guess and go along with it. I found I didn't mind this. Would definitely read the sequel (I think there's quite a bit left to finish off).
I enjoyed this lighhearted fantasy which channelled Jane Austen, Georgette Heyer, and Susanna Clarke's Johnathan Strange and Mr Norrell. At times it felt like Strange and Norrell fan fic, and it wasn't as complex, but it was certainly more diverse regarding the characters and their backgrounds. It was also compared to Harry Potter which I can see.
We meet Zacharias, who as a boy was purchased (or stolen) off a slave ship and brought up to learn about English magic. He becomes the Sorcerer Royal in mysterious circumstances which are later revealed. He is invited to give a speech about magic (or the dangers of it) at a girls school where young ladies are taught to suppress their magic, meets Prunella who is a bit of a Hermione character, and thus begin their adventures to tackle the belief that women shouldn't do magic, via stopping a diplomatic breakdown between Britain and an island nation in south east Asia, and a scheming mermaid.
The idea that women should not do magic because it is dangerous for them is laid on a bit thick, but it is not out of character for the time. I thought it a clever book at times, with plenty to say about colonialism, sexism, and classism, and lots of cute magical ideas. Also like the Emily Wilde Encyclopedia series.
Very fast paced - the story jumps in and the world building happens along the way, or not at all, barely any taking time to explain something - you have to guess and go along with it. I found I didn't mind this. Would definitely read the sequel (I think there's quite a bit left to finish off).
Content Warnings
Moderate: Death, Racism, and Sexism
Minor: Slavery and Colonisation
cmbohn's review against another edition
adventurous
funny
lighthearted
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.75
Content Warnings
Graphic: Racial slurs, Racism, and Sexism
Moderate: Classism
Minor: Slavery, Pregnancy, Colonisation, and War
rosyapple's review against another edition
adventurous
lighthearted
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
fun times
comparison to norrel and strange is apt but this is faster paced and funnier
pageturner
comparison to norrel and strange is apt but this is faster paced and funnier
pageturner
Content Warnings
Moderate: Racism and Violence
Minor: Slavery and Blood
ijustreallyliketrees's review against another edition
challenging
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.0
Content Warnings
Graphic: Misogyny, Racism, and Sexism
Moderate: Slavery
Minor: Death and Racial slurs
softwindflower's review against another edition
adventurous
funny
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
2.5
Content Warnings
Graphic: Racism and Sexism
Moderate: Death
Minor: Slavery
nannahnannah's review against another edition
4.0
Ah, darn. I was hoping this was YA. The whole time reading, I was cheering that finally there was a YA book with serious, fantastic writing that enhanced the reading experience -- not just serving as a functional to get from beginning to end. Though I’m disappointed that it’s adult … this book and its writing exists, so I can’t be too upset.
Representation:
- the protagonist is black
- the love interest is not white as well (Indian? They said black at one point, but I’m wondering if it’s “in the context of the time”)
The border between England and Fairyland has become less permeable, and magic is disappearing. Zacharias Wythe, once a slave and now in the esteemed position of Sorcerer Royal, is dedicated to finding out the reason for this problem. Along the way he meets Prunella Gentleman, a spirited young woman driven from a girls’ school with an unusual talent for magic. Even though serious magic is forbidden for women (as it’s unfit for their “delicate constitutions”), together they meet with Fairy Queens and vampire sorceresses and fight the outdated, racist Society that wants Zacharias to hand in his Sorcerer Royal staff -- to keep magic in England.
Okay, I’ll admit I thought at first, “Why do all these books that deal with somewhat traditional magic systems (wands, spells, charms, etc.) have to take place in England? Why is this another one of those boring novels, and do I really want to spend time on this?”. But I give it a chance, because that writing is delicious. I also realized there are so many intricate layers to this story; everything is incredibly well thought through, and no, it’s not just “another story about magic in England”.
Zacharias Wythe is a black sorcerer, once a slave and now in a position of power at a time when the English people … (well, a lot more vocally than now) aren’t comfortable with something like this happening. Zacharias also became Sorcerer Royal in an unusual way, fueling the rest of his peers’ uneasiness and suspicions.
The layers continue to grow, with unexpected nuance and care, with the introduction of our second main character, Prunella Gentleman. She’s a spitfire and a perfect balance to Zacharias’s seriousness and somewhat melancholic nature. She’s also a character I would’ve loved to write. She’s so much fun -- and a lot of trouble. She also brings with her a contrast to Zacharias in that she’s a woman of color being presented as a lady of noble birth (which has a lovely & hilarious spin at the end! I love that every detail has been accounted for).
These layers of interest and complexity grow even further when Zacharias mentions his concerns about the other oppressed peoples in England’s conservative society, like the labouring classes and the women (who are “afflicted” by magic because it affects their “frail constitutions”). Zacharias also studies the magics of other countries in his search to bring magic back to England -- and these countries & magical cultures actually come into play, bringing with them some of the most interesting characters of the book and wonderful lore. So no, not just your standard English magical story.
Regarding the women practicing magic issue, it does get pretty heavy handed sometimes, which may put some people off, but I love where some of this goes. Here’s a quote from page 57:
”’If a girl-child makes her dolls dance, her parents admire her cleverness, and say it is of no account, for little Susan will soon outgrow such amusements. If, when she is turned fifteen, she is discovered in charms to curl her hair or brighten her eyes, she is reproved for her vanity, and told she must stop, lest she is thought fast. But no effort is made to make her understand the seriousness of her breach, and she comes to womanhood believing there is no harm in indulging in minor magics, provided she does it discreetly. And what is the result? [...] magic was too strong a force for women’s frail bodies -- too potent a brew for their weak minds -- and so, especially at a time when everyone must be anxious to preserve what magical resource England still possessed, magic must be forbidden to women.’”
Pretty standard sexism. You might expect the female protagonist’s skills would counter all this and prove it wrong by the end, right? But like I said, there’s deeper things going on here. Because funnily enough, in this world, women don’t seem to have a problem with England’s lack of magic. And “cooks, maids, charwomen, herbwives, and the females of the lower classes” are allowed to practice magics because it benefits their betters! Not only that, but there are schools for women to use magic in order to better control and eventually learn how to suppress it altogether.
(This, of course, doesn’t really leave room for anyone outside the gender binary, which is unfortunately a mistake a lot of books make when exploring oppression in a magical system where there’s a contrast between men and women. But that’s a discussion for later …)
So, yeah, there’s a lot going on, and this is just the exposition. Which leads me to say that the story starts off incredibly slow. There’s a lot to cover about Fairyland and the magic system and Societies and familiars that by the time the action really begins, it’s kind of late in the book. It feels like, finally?! But at the same time I was never really bored beforehand. If you need the action to start right off the bat, this may not be a book you’ll enjoy, but if a prose similar to Jane Austen is something you love, give it a chance. It’s really beautiful writing. Plus it has one heck of an intriguing and unpredictable twist.
Representation:
- the protagonist is black
- the love interest is not white as well (Indian? They said black at one point, but I’m wondering if it’s “in the context of the time”)
The border between England and Fairyland has become less permeable, and magic is disappearing. Zacharias Wythe, once a slave and now in the esteemed position of Sorcerer Royal, is dedicated to finding out the reason for this problem. Along the way he meets Prunella Gentleman, a spirited young woman driven from a girls’ school with an unusual talent for magic. Even though serious magic is forbidden for women (as it’s unfit for their “delicate constitutions”), together they meet with Fairy Queens and vampire sorceresses and fight the outdated, racist Society that wants Zacharias to hand in his Sorcerer Royal staff -- to keep magic in England.
Okay, I’ll admit I thought at first, “Why do all these books that deal with somewhat traditional magic systems (wands, spells, charms, etc.) have to take place in England? Why is this another one of those boring novels, and do I really want to spend time on this?”. But I give it a chance, because that writing is delicious. I also realized there are so many intricate layers to this story; everything is incredibly well thought through, and no, it’s not just “another story about magic in England”.
Zacharias Wythe is a black sorcerer, once a slave and now in a position of power at a time when the English people … (well, a lot more vocally than now) aren’t comfortable with something like this happening. Zacharias also became Sorcerer Royal in an unusual way, fueling the rest of his peers’ uneasiness and suspicions.
The layers continue to grow, with unexpected nuance and care, with the introduction of our second main character, Prunella Gentleman. She’s a spitfire and a perfect balance to Zacharias’s seriousness and somewhat melancholic nature. She’s also a character I would’ve loved to write. She’s so much fun -- and a lot of trouble. She also brings with her a contrast to Zacharias in that she’s a woman of color being presented as a lady of noble birth (which has a lovely & hilarious spin at the end! I love that every detail has been accounted for).
These layers of interest and complexity grow even further when Zacharias mentions his concerns about the other oppressed peoples in England’s conservative society, like the labouring classes and the women (who are “afflicted” by magic because it affects their “frail constitutions”). Zacharias also studies the magics of other countries in his search to bring magic back to England -- and these countries & magical cultures actually come into play, bringing with them some of the most interesting characters of the book and wonderful lore. So no, not just your standard English magical story.
Regarding the women practicing magic issue, it does get pretty heavy handed sometimes, which may put some people off, but I love where some of this goes. Here’s a quote from page 57:
”’If a girl-child makes her dolls dance, her parents admire her cleverness, and say it is of no account, for little Susan will soon outgrow such amusements. If, when she is turned fifteen, she is discovered in charms to curl her hair or brighten her eyes, she is reproved for her vanity, and told she must stop, lest she is thought fast. But no effort is made to make her understand the seriousness of her breach, and she comes to womanhood believing there is no harm in indulging in minor magics, provided she does it discreetly. And what is the result? [...] magic was too strong a force for women’s frail bodies -- too potent a brew for their weak minds -- and so, especially at a time when everyone must be anxious to preserve what magical resource England still possessed, magic must be forbidden to women.’”
Pretty standard sexism. You might expect the female protagonist’s skills would counter all this and prove it wrong by the end, right? But like I said, there’s deeper things going on here. Because funnily enough, in this world, women don’t seem to have a problem with England’s lack of magic. And “cooks, maids, charwomen, herbwives, and the females of the lower classes” are allowed to practice magics because it benefits their betters! Not only that, but there are schools for women to use magic in order to better control and eventually learn how to suppress it altogether.
(This, of course, doesn’t really leave room for anyone outside the gender binary, which is unfortunately a mistake a lot of books make when exploring oppression in a magical system where there’s a contrast between men and women. But that’s a discussion for later …)
So, yeah, there’s a lot going on, and this is just the exposition. Which leads me to say that the story starts off incredibly slow. There’s a lot to cover about Fairyland and the magic system and Societies and familiars that by the time the action really begins, it’s kind of late in the book. It feels like, finally?! But at the same time I was never really bored beforehand. If you need the action to start right off the bat, this may not be a book you’ll enjoy, but if a prose similar to Jane Austen is something you love, give it a chance. It’s really beautiful writing. Plus it has one heck of an intriguing and unpredictable twist.
Content Warnings
Moderate: Racism and Sexism
Minor: Slavery
also: ideas of male/female sorcery that’s very limited to the binary/is trans-exclusivetinyjude's review against another edition
adventurous
lighthearted
mysterious
relaxing
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
3.5
This was a strong debut, although compared to Zen Cho's later writing that I had the pleasure of reading, was a bit weak. We see a rich intersection between feminism, colonialism and racism in this book, which contrasts with most of these type of fantasy novels usually with a white predominant cast.
Nonetheless, I would have enjoyed more worldbuilding, a faster pace at the beginning and more development for the love story between the main protagonists (as it felt a bit too rushed). I liked the way menstruation was treated in the story, as well as Prunella's power. I would have loved to see more of the familiars and the fairy world. I liked the complicated relationship between Zacharias and Stephen, although I was left disappointed at the fact that Zacharias didn't question him at the end why he didn't also free his parents as well.
Nonetheless, I would have enjoyed more worldbuilding, a faster pace at the beginning and more development for the love story between the main protagonists (as it felt a bit too rushed). I liked the way menstruation was treated in the story, as well as Prunella's power. I would have loved to see more of the familiars and the fairy world. I liked the complicated relationship between Zacharias and Stephen, although I was left disappointed at the fact that Zacharias didn't question him at the end why he didn't also free his parents as well.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Misogyny, Racism, Sexism, Xenophobia, and Colonisation
Moderate: Genocide, Hate crime, Slavery, Cannibalism, Death of parent, Pregnancy, and Classism
Minor: Violence and War
buttermellow's review against another edition
challenging
mysterious
reflective
sad
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.0
Content Warnings
Graphic: Misogyny and Racism
Moderate: Ableism, Slavery, Xenophobia, Colonisation, and Classism
Minor: Death