mamanrees's review against another edition
3.0
Honestly, I don't love tall tales. That said, this version is more enjoyable to read aloud than some others that I've tried.
ricksilva's review
4.0
Collection of retellings of American folktales by Magic Tree House author Mary Pope Osborne.
These are very definitely the author's own take on the legends of 19th Century America, but she includes extensive notes on the origins of each of the iconic characters, many of which were actually the inventions of specific 19th Century authors, that only later made their way into the realm of folklore.
The stories are presented in a flamboyant style that captures the flavor of tales told around a campfire, and the personalities of the heroes and heroines shine bright as their larger-than-life deeds are recounted.
There is plenty of humor, but the Author's best work is bringing out the more serious side of the stories, particularly in the tales of steel-driver John Henry and New York City firefighter Mose.
The incorporation of song lyrics (as performed by Pete Seeger, and later Bruce Springsteen) into the John Henry story felt a bit like the author was trying too hard, but I do have to admit that I was singing the song in my head as I read the story.
Michael McCurdy's wood-engraving illustrations are simply spectacular and a huge part of the charm of this book.
These are very definitely the author's own take on the legends of 19th Century America, but she includes extensive notes on the origins of each of the iconic characters, many of which were actually the inventions of specific 19th Century authors, that only later made their way into the realm of folklore.
The stories are presented in a flamboyant style that captures the flavor of tales told around a campfire, and the personalities of the heroes and heroines shine bright as their larger-than-life deeds are recounted.
There is plenty of humor, but the Author's best work is bringing out the more serious side of the stories, particularly in the tales of steel-driver John Henry and New York City firefighter Mose.
The incorporation of song lyrics (as performed by Pete Seeger, and later Bruce Springsteen) into the John Henry story felt a bit like the author was trying too hard, but I do have to admit that I was singing the song in my head as I read the story.
Michael McCurdy's wood-engraving illustrations are simply spectacular and a huge part of the charm of this book.
kslhersam's review against another edition
3.0
A friend recommended audio books read by Jim Weiss. I thought these tall tales were just okay, but I'm listening to another CD by him right now with fairy tales that is much better. This was so-so for me, but my 6 yr. old son did enjoy it.
More...