abigcoffeedragon's review against another edition
5.0
Now THIS one really got me into the story. More Lovecraftian elements and more detective noir and more everything that makes things work. So much a bigger and better addition to the series.
spazenport's review
5.0
Depending on the day, my favorite story from the Lovecraft Mythos is Shadow Over Innsmouth. The dark tale of a city cursed by it's fortune in more ways than one makes for a great setting for some pulpy adventure (as myself and other authors have noted). Unlike those other authors, and even myself, the adventure here is nonstop pulpy goodness that only Byron Craft could have put together. On the trail of a murderer and kidnapper from that doomed city, the Arkham Detective takes grit to a new level as he interrogates the town and puts his best detective shoe forward, stumbling upon spies, trapped locals, and, of course, a dark ritual or two.
More...