Reviews

Star Trek - The Key Collection: Volume 1 by Alberto Giolitti

birdmanseven's review

Go to review page

3.0

Points for the retro styling and for its place in Star Trek history. However, it wasn't particularly appealing and was much more Sci-fi than Star Trek ever was. I don't think I'll check out volume 2.

esperata's review

Go to review page

2.0

The new publisher makes no bones about the embarrassing faux-pas of the original Gold Key publications. Its clear the writers had never seen an episode of Star Trek when they wrote this. The language is wrong, the science is wrong, the colours are wrong and the actions don't fit the characters. It only really deals with Kirk and Spock. Scotty appears as a blond but Uhura doesn't appear at all.
However, it is a reprint of comics from a different age. An age before VCR - so I guess if you didn't see it live there was no chance to catch up.
More...