hotsake's review against another edition
5.0
The first nearly perfect Nero Wolfe novel. This novel is also notable for being the first appearance of Lily Rowan who is always a welcome addition to any story she graces.
jbleyle63's review against another edition
5.0
Re-reading this series in publication order so Stout's setting choice to get the cloistered Nero Wolfe out of his Manhattan brownstone in back to back novels, following [book:Too Many Cooks|77627], really stands out. Wolfe and Archie get in a car accident on the way to a local fair to exhibit some of Wolfe's prized orchids in upstate New York and wind up involved in murder case featuring a champion bull as the possible weapon. The plotting and witty rapport between Archie and Wolfe are top notch but this novel also features the debut of recurring series character Lily Rowan making this one of the standouts in the entire series. After all, a woman who captures the romantic interests of Archie Goodwin has to be an enchanting character indeed!
wmcduff's review against another edition
4.0
It's Nero Wolfe. As detective romps go, Rex Stout is a master, and the probable first appearance of Lily Rowan is nice.
antij's review against another edition
dark
lighthearted
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.0
slferg's review against another edition
5.0
Good books. This one introduces Lily Rowan - a perfect foil for Archie Goodwin, I think. Neither of them seems to know what to make of the other at first.....
dllh's review against another edition
3.0
Pretty standard Stout -- an enjoyable and quick read, but nothing earth-shattering.
bev_reads_mysteries's review
4.0
In Some Buried Caesar Nero Wolfe makes another of his rare trips outside his comfortable brownstone. This time he and Archie Goodwin are headed to a rural exposition north of Manhattan to show Wolfe's prize orchids. On the way the car misbehaves (as Wolfe always suspected it might) and they crash into a tree. Wolfe, Goodwin, and--most importantly--the orchids are undamaged, but they find themselves in need of assistance and set off through an apparently empty field in search of a house with a phone. They haven't gone far before a rather emphatic man with a gun warns them of danger from while accusing them of having evil intentions toward a large, angry bull.
I heard Wolfe's voice, not loud, at the back of my head, "... Do you know the technique of bulls? Did you ever see a bull fight?"
I moved my lips enough to get it out: "No, sir."
Wolfe grunted. "... How fast can you run?"
"I can beat that bull to that fence. ... But you can't."
Archie manages to successfully run from the bull, vault the fence, and cause enough distraction that Wolfe, who is no distance runner nor pole vaulter, can clamber atop a large boulder. Wolfe is then rescued by car by Caroline Pratt, the daughter of the bull's owner, and then Wolfe and Archie are taken to the Pratt home to recover from their ordeal. While enjoying some refreshments and considering their options for making it to the hotel in time to claim their rooms for the night, they also meet Pratt's nephew Jimmy and Lily Rowan, a pretty and world-wise blonde who looks to be more than a match for Archie in the wise-crack department.
There are also some tense moments when members of the Guernsey League show up to protest Pratt's intention to turn the bull into barbecue in an advertising stunt for his restaurant chain. Not that they have anything against barbecue--but that bull just happens to be a champion by the name of Hickory Caesar Grindon and they resent such a fine animal (who should be siring more fine animals) being used for a publicity campaign. Clyde and Nancy Osgood, the children of Pratt's neighbor and long-time rival Frederick, also show up and Clyde says that Pratt's real reason for barbecuing the bull is to somehow dishonor his father. He bets Pratt $10,000 that he will not barbecue Caesar before a week has passed. Pratt reluctantly accepts the bet (after making sure that Frederick Osgood will guarantee payment), but he is concerned that Clyde will do something to the bull in order to win the bet. Wolfe trades Archie's services as a bull-watcher for the comfort of Pratt's home--much preferable to any hotel room in Wolfe's estimation. But things get tricky when Clyde's body is found in the pasture late that night, apparently gored to death by the bull.
Frederick Osgood refuses to believe that his son who knew cattle would have put himself in such a dangerous position. He hires Wolfe to get to the bottom of things, which is good because Wolfe has been convinced it was murder all along. Wolfe just didn't want to get involved and wind up spending any extra time away from the comforts of his own home. But it looks like Wolfe may, for once, be outwitted when the most vial evidence of all goes up in smoke. He'll have to do even quicker thinking than usual to apprehend the murderer...and get Archie released from a jail cell.
True to Stout form the plot is nicely convoluted and the cast of characters are varied and interesting. A fine mystery and it is also notable as the first appearance of Lily Rowan, Archie's long-time girlfriend. The sparks fly between these two right from the start as they trade wise-cracks, Lily alternately gives him looks that "peel him like a potato" and demands that he kiss her, and he gives her fanciful stories of his escapades with crime and the ladies. Lily may not get much mention in future novels, but she shines in this one and it is shame that we don't see more of her throughout the series. Archie's interactions with both his boss and Lily make this a thoroughly enjoyable read.
First posted on my blog My Reader's Block. Please request permission before reposting. Thanks.
I heard Wolfe's voice, not loud, at the back of my head, "... Do you know the technique of bulls? Did you ever see a bull fight?"
I moved my lips enough to get it out: "No, sir."
Wolfe grunted. "... How fast can you run?"
"I can beat that bull to that fence. ... But you can't."
Archie manages to successfully run from the bull, vault the fence, and cause enough distraction that Wolfe, who is no distance runner nor pole vaulter, can clamber atop a large boulder. Wolfe is then rescued by car by Caroline Pratt, the daughter of the bull's owner, and then Wolfe and Archie are taken to the Pratt home to recover from their ordeal. While enjoying some refreshments and considering their options for making it to the hotel in time to claim their rooms for the night, they also meet Pratt's nephew Jimmy and Lily Rowan, a pretty and world-wise blonde who looks to be more than a match for Archie in the wise-crack department.
There are also some tense moments when members of the Guernsey League show up to protest Pratt's intention to turn the bull into barbecue in an advertising stunt for his restaurant chain. Not that they have anything against barbecue--but that bull just happens to be a champion by the name of Hickory Caesar Grindon and they resent such a fine animal (who should be siring more fine animals) being used for a publicity campaign. Clyde and Nancy Osgood, the children of Pratt's neighbor and long-time rival Frederick, also show up and Clyde says that Pratt's real reason for barbecuing the bull is to somehow dishonor his father. He bets Pratt $10,000 that he will not barbecue Caesar before a week has passed. Pratt reluctantly accepts the bet (after making sure that Frederick Osgood will guarantee payment), but he is concerned that Clyde will do something to the bull in order to win the bet. Wolfe trades Archie's services as a bull-watcher for the comfort of Pratt's home--much preferable to any hotel room in Wolfe's estimation. But things get tricky when Clyde's body is found in the pasture late that night, apparently gored to death by the bull.
Frederick Osgood refuses to believe that his son who knew cattle would have put himself in such a dangerous position. He hires Wolfe to get to the bottom of things, which is good because Wolfe has been convinced it was murder all along. Wolfe just didn't want to get involved and wind up spending any extra time away from the comforts of his own home. But it looks like Wolfe may, for once, be outwitted when the most vial evidence of all goes up in smoke. He'll have to do even quicker thinking than usual to apprehend the murderer...and get Archie released from a jail cell.
True to Stout form the plot is nicely convoluted and the cast of characters are varied and interesting. A fine mystery and it is also notable as the first appearance of Lily Rowan, Archie's long-time girlfriend. The sparks fly between these two right from the start as they trade wise-cracks, Lily alternately gives him looks that "peel him like a potato" and demands that he kiss her, and he gives her fanciful stories of his escapades with crime and the ladies. Lily may not get much mention in future novels, but she shines in this one and it is shame that we don't see more of her throughout the series. Archie's interactions with both his boss and Lily make this a thoroughly enjoyable read.
First posted on my blog My Reader's Block. Please request permission before reposting. Thanks.
fabluous_magic_sandwich's review against another edition
funny
lighthearted
mysterious
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
4.75
gawronma's review against another edition
2.0
This was read for the Indianapolis Bouchercon. As much as understand this book is a classic, I did not enjoy it. Stout was a good writer, however, my taste is more towards the British golden age writers. I doubt, it I would ever read another Nero Wolf book.