lrc52's review against another edition
2.0
lovers of gone, girl; girl on the train; and shutter island will love this book. i didn't. it was just another "mystery" that was flat for me. the lack of complexity of the characters in these type books equals a story that is formulaic. thrill-seeking rather than thrilling. seeming normal people aren't normal at all. crazy shit happens. the crazy can be explained the craziness of the character. the ending is always ambiguous, meant to leave the reader wondering if it really happened the way the (unreliable) narrator retells it or not at all that way. blah.
readhikerepeat's review against another edition
5.0
Lyrically written (I say this because music is a big part of the story), Fuller has written a book that is absolutely impossible to put down. Every time you think you can tuck it in for the night, she drops a bombshell in the form of a short and simple sentence that leaves you with no other choice than to keep reading. Not only that, every time you think you’ve figured the story out, you realize you’re probably wrong and are compelled to keep reading. That said, this isn’t your typical mystery or suspense novel, but rather a stunning work of fiction that lends an air of mystery to it.
For the full review, please visit The Book Wheel.
For the full review, please visit The Book Wheel.
readingwithhippos's review against another edition
4.0
This is one of those books that on paper shouldn’t be any good at all, but in execution is sad and lovely and quietly powerful. I feel like it should come with a warning, though, as based on the pastoral-looking cover, I didn’t realize it was going to be as devastating as it was.
Eight-year-old Peggy journeys with her father to a remote cabin in the woods. He tells her that a cataclysmic event has ended the world outside their forest, and they are the only ones left. We know from the beginning that isn’t true, because the novel includes sections set years in the future, when Peggy has returned to her old home with her mother in London, and the world has very much continued on without her. Why her father told her this and the impact his lie will have on her life are slowly, almost painstakingly, revealed.
Because yes, I’ll admit the book is slow, in a way. It reads quickly, but the revelations are doled out piecemeal. It’s like following a trail of breadcrumbs—perhaps an apt comparison, considering it’s a book about a girl literally lost in the woods. And the closer you get to the end, the more you start to shrink away from the truth you know you’ll find, because it won’t be anything good. Stories of parents kidnapping and lying to their own children rarely end with everyone hugging it out. But Claire Fuller is a skilled technician—she knows her story well and the right way to tell it for maximum impact.
This was my choice for book club this month, and if I may pat myself on the back, I think it was a pretty good one. Not everyone will like it—style wise and content wise, it’s bound to rub some readers the wrong way. But it will provide plenty of fodder for discussion, which is what I usually look for in a book club pick.
Eight-year-old Peggy journeys with her father to a remote cabin in the woods. He tells her that a cataclysmic event has ended the world outside their forest, and they are the only ones left. We know from the beginning that isn’t true, because the novel includes sections set years in the future, when Peggy has returned to her old home with her mother in London, and the world has very much continued on without her. Why her father told her this and the impact his lie will have on her life are slowly, almost painstakingly, revealed.
Because yes, I’ll admit the book is slow, in a way. It reads quickly, but the revelations are doled out piecemeal. It’s like following a trail of breadcrumbs—perhaps an apt comparison, considering it’s a book about a girl literally lost in the woods. And the closer you get to the end, the more you start to shrink away from the truth you know you’ll find, because it won’t be anything good. Stories of parents kidnapping and lying to their own children rarely end with everyone hugging it out. But Claire Fuller is a skilled technician—she knows her story well and the right way to tell it for maximum impact.
This was my choice for book club this month, and if I may pat myself on the back, I think it was a pretty good one. Not everyone will like it—style wise and content wise, it’s bound to rub some readers the wrong way. But it will provide plenty of fodder for discussion, which is what I usually look for in a book club pick.
nerdyrev's review against another edition
5.0
Our Endless Numbered Days by Claire Fuller is the second book down my Tin House rabbit hole and the first of two-girl living with a crazy guy out in the forest books. I am also reading The Wolf Road by Beth Lewis and will review it soon. Our Endless Numbered Days is another book that will mess with your mind.
Peggy aka Punzel begins life with her father James, who makes her pack a rucksack to prepare for emergencies and is a survivalist, and her mother, who plays the piano while Peggy's father gets a bit stranger.
One day, when Peggy is 7, her father tells her to pack her rucksack because they are going to live in the woods. James tells Punzel that her mother is dead as is the rest of the world. In order to survive, they must live in this secluded cabin and learn to live off of the land.
The story begins innocently as Punzel (short for Rapunzel) relies on her father and begins learning everything from him to survive. He also does special things for her, such as building weighted piano keys so Punzel can practice the piano. They sleep in the same bed and rely on one another.
Years begin to pass and James' behavior starts getting stranger and stranger. He starts calling Punzel her mother's name and cries out that her mother left him. The more strange her father becomes, the further Punzel begins to travel away from the cabin until one day she finds a pair of shoes in the woods and a man connected to those shoes. For 10 years, her father has been lying to her. What will Punzel do?
The book itself is entirely told through Punzel's eyes and jumps between two points in time. The main narrative progresses as Punzel gets older, but the book also jumps to 10 years later where Peggy is reunited with her mother and her younger brother who happens to be 10 years old. We learn what happened out in the forest, what happened to James, and what life was like for those 10 years.
The great thing about this story is that Peggy aka Punzel becomes an unreliable narrator, simply because she is in a state of arrested development. We will also learn other things which will make her unreliable, but it would be a huge spoiler if I shared them on this blog. As stated in another review, I am a sucker for an unreliable narrator.
There is also a web of lies that float throughout this entire book. People withhold information to each other, like crazy. Not only James telling Punzel that everyone is dead, but there are other lies that float throughout. The great thing is the author doesn't blatantly fill in the blanks for the readers. One must put the pieces together and figure out what the truth is.
I am calling this book one of those books that I absolutely loved, but others may not. It does have some harsh scenes that might not sit well with others. Some may also be frustrated by the need to fill in blanks. I loved it though and cannot wait for Fuller's second book coming out in December.
I gave this one 5 stars!
Peggy aka Punzel begins life with her father James, who makes her pack a rucksack to prepare for emergencies and is a survivalist, and her mother, who plays the piano while Peggy's father gets a bit stranger.
One day, when Peggy is 7, her father tells her to pack her rucksack because they are going to live in the woods. James tells Punzel that her mother is dead as is the rest of the world. In order to survive, they must live in this secluded cabin and learn to live off of the land.
The story begins innocently as Punzel (short for Rapunzel) relies on her father and begins learning everything from him to survive. He also does special things for her, such as building weighted piano keys so Punzel can practice the piano. They sleep in the same bed and rely on one another.
Years begin to pass and James' behavior starts getting stranger and stranger. He starts calling Punzel her mother's name and cries out that her mother left him. The more strange her father becomes, the further Punzel begins to travel away from the cabin until one day she finds a pair of shoes in the woods and a man connected to those shoes. For 10 years, her father has been lying to her. What will Punzel do?
The book itself is entirely told through Punzel's eyes and jumps between two points in time. The main narrative progresses as Punzel gets older, but the book also jumps to 10 years later where Peggy is reunited with her mother and her younger brother who happens to be 10 years old. We learn what happened out in the forest, what happened to James, and what life was like for those 10 years.
The great thing about this story is that Peggy aka Punzel becomes an unreliable narrator, simply because she is in a state of arrested development. We will also learn other things which will make her unreliable, but it would be a huge spoiler if I shared them on this blog. As stated in another review, I am a sucker for an unreliable narrator.
There is also a web of lies that float throughout this entire book. People withhold information to each other, like crazy. Not only James telling Punzel that everyone is dead, but there are other lies that float throughout. The great thing is the author doesn't blatantly fill in the blanks for the readers. One must put the pieces together and figure out what the truth is.
I am calling this book one of those books that I absolutely loved, but others may not. It does have some harsh scenes that might not sit well with others. Some may also be frustrated by the need to fill in blanks. I loved it though and cannot wait for Fuller's second book coming out in December.
I gave this one 5 stars!
ipb1's review against another edition
2.0
Another novel overtaken by the need to insert some pointless twist and [failed] shock value into a narrative that simply didn't need it.
geoffry's review against another edition
2.0
De cover alleen al verdient een extra ster, maar zwaar teleurgesteld in het verhaal. De (weinige) stukken over Peggy's terugkeer boeiden me meer dan haar ontvoering zelf.
the_evergrowing_library's review against another edition
3.0
We have a weird juxtaposition of tones in this one.
The tale of a child whisked away by a frankly deranged father to live in the woods under the false belief that the rest of the world is dead is quite clearly a maudlin affair. That being said there was some wonderful writing and it was beautifully described.
Plot wise it was a slow burn of a story that was far from action packed but I found myself wrapped up in it and wanting to see where it went.
Narrative from a child perspective is always an interesting read as there’s so much there in the sheer lack of understanding and willingness to believe in what they are told. That plays a big part in this book for sure.
Definitely an end loaded read, but one that is quick to get through.
This is my second Fuller read and both have been quite starkly different but also shared a level of sadness that I think was conveyed really well within the narrative.
Our days will be endless.
The tale of a child whisked away by a frankly deranged father to live in the woods under the false belief that the rest of the world is dead is quite clearly a maudlin affair. That being said there was some wonderful writing and it was beautifully described.
Plot wise it was a slow burn of a story that was far from action packed but I found myself wrapped up in it and wanting to see where it went.
Narrative from a child perspective is always an interesting read as there’s so much there in the sheer lack of understanding and willingness to believe in what they are told. That plays a big part in this book for sure.
Definitely an end loaded read, but one that is quick to get through.
This is my second Fuller read and both have been quite starkly different but also shared a level of sadness that I think was conveyed really well within the narrative.
Our days will be endless.
amandale's review against another edition
3.0
On the other side there is only emptiness, an awful place that has eaten everything except our own little kingdom.
justdavid3113's review against another edition
5.0
I rarely give a book 5 stars. For me it has to be a book that holds you, touches you and stays with you. I did not want to stop reading this book, Peggy's narrative never felt tired and I will remember this story for a long time.
With so few characters it would be easy for the writer to bore the readers with too much information on them. But Fuller's choice to tell this story from Peggy's point of view is genius. What you get is the thoughts of a kid that never quite gets to grow up in a conventional way. One who takes as truth whatever she is told. There is a brutal honesty, a real sense of lost innocence and naked humanity here.
This book is fantastic and I will be telling everyone about it. Everyone.
With so few characters it would be easy for the writer to bore the readers with too much information on them. But Fuller's choice to tell this story from Peggy's point of view is genius. What you get is the thoughts of a kid that never quite gets to grow up in a conventional way. One who takes as truth whatever she is told. There is a brutal honesty, a real sense of lost innocence and naked humanity here.
This book is fantastic and I will be telling everyone about it. Everyone.