Reviews

The Panther by Nelson DeMille

darth_vader's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

I amazed at the author’s understanding of the local stories and history and how he ties in facts about local legends and customs in to the story. Makes a fictional novel seem so real. Thanks for the adventure.

pateutz's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

I'm sorry, Nelson/John, i love both of you but i reached 40% and this was just not it

audreylovesreading's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous emotional funny informative mysterious reflective tense fast-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

5.0

patriciapereira13's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous funny informative tense slow-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? It's complicated
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.0

brig_berthold's review against another edition

Go to review page

DNF
I'm over the American exceptionalism coupled with the anti-Muslim trope. I couldn't stomach this beyond when they first landed in Yemen.

topdragon's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

The 6th in this series is a bit of a departure for the main character, John Corey, former NY cop and current federal anti-terrorist task force agent, and his wife, FBI agent Kate Mayfield. We're used to New York based action against terrorists and other bad guys intent upon harm to American soil, but this time John, Kate and a small team take the fight to the source...Yemen, one of the most dangerous places in the Middle East. And we are also treated to the presence of Paul Brenner, the main character from [b:The General's Daughter|98427|The General's Daughter|Nelson DeMille|http://d.gr-assets.com/books/1334443536s/98427.jpg|1832579] and [b:Up Country|33820|Up Country|Nelson DeMille|http://d.gr-assets.com/books/1344270389s/33820.jpg|3343186] where he is serving a security tour in Yemen. Nice to see these two characters joining up and watch their rivalry give way to mutual respect.

These novels, to me, are all about the character of John Corey. His witty, sarcastic, often juvenile, and mostly politically incorrect observations of life around him are on full display here. He has a healthy disrespect for authority and a sort of bemused detachment on what is happening around him. But once he latches on to a problem, he is relentless in solving the situation. He's a great character and I am pleased that DeMille has kept him true to his nature throughout this series instead of kowtowing to the reviewers who turn up their nose at John's personality and swear off future DeMille novels because of it. I love seeing a well-developed flawed character and DeMille is a master at bringing us such an obnoxious main character that somehow remains endearing.

This is a lengthy book and it definitely took its time in getting to any action. Lots and lots of build-up and I admit to longing for something to finally "happen". But after completing the novel and looking back, I realize how necessary that build-up was. We do learn a lot about Yemen and its people and society as well as on-the-ground tactics for fighting terrorists. It occurred to me that this depiction was far more realistic than what readers often get with such novels: a slow waiting game filled with observation of the enemy rather than a Mission Impossible style movie where we move from one action sequence to the next.

And in the final 1/4 th of the book, it all came together. Events from the previous two John Corry novels, [b:Wild Fire|1849|Wild Fire (John Corey, #4)|Nelson DeMille|http://d.gr-assets.com/books/1298411784s/1849.jpg|2834249] and [b:The Lion|7164343|The Lion (John Corey, #5)|Nelson DeMille|http://d.gr-assets.com/books/1259186800s/7164343.jpg|7521142] also play prominent roles in what happens in this one. The ending is satisfying but does not wrap things up completely. Good. I look forward to more entries in this fine series.

brookefradd's review against another edition

Go to review page

Love the characters, but the plot was lacking.

kathydavie's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Sixth in the John Corey thriller series and revolving around a former NYPD detective-turned-FBI-contract-agent. John and Kate go to Yemen!

I suggest reading at least Wild Fire, 4 before starting this one, as there are so many references that lead back to it and there are critical decisions based upon actions in that story.

My Take
I'm starting to sense a pattern here. And I really don't know why it took so long…duh…it all revolves around terrorists. I know, duhhh *grin*. Another pattern is that bad guys always seems to slip that trap. Should be interesting to see what happens in book 7.

John is more than his usual snarky self and doesn't seem to deduce as much in this one. He does have it when it counts though, and his reasoning keeps several people alive.
"A well-balanced detective has a chip on both shoulders…"

This whole "need to know" crap is just that, crap. Why not tell them the whole plan so they can be prepared? Sacrificing all those people… How is the government or the CIA any different from the terrorists? I like John's point that the cops tell each other (at least compared to the Feds) everything you need to know, 'cause, hey, you need to know. That cocktail party at the embassy brings it home. Here they're all on the same side, and no one knows what the right or the left hand is doing.

God, Kate can be amazingly naive. As for John not telling her? Puh-lease, she'd'a never believed him. I do suspect Kate may pay more attention to John's pronouncements about safety when they get back, for this is definitely an Operation Clean Sweep.
"…lies are like cockroaches — if you see one, there are more."

Part of Buck's awareness is explaining how Yemen is a shifting mess of alliances where you won't know who's got your back from minute to minute. And Corey reckons it's a lot like 26 Federal Plaza.

Agent Al-Rasul reckons American-born Muslims go over to the terrorists because they hate the U.S. a touch more than they hate themselves or their corrupt Muslim governments. He also points out that Islam began as a military conquest with a period of enlightenment. Now Islam is heading backwards. Wouldn't it be cheaper for us to come up with oil alternatives? Leave the terrorists with their homelands and just ignore them? They could have what they want, all by themselves. And we could have what we want, and it'd be safer for the planet. Do we really need more money than God?

All we need are a few more leaders like The Panther…'cause Zuhair makes some excellent points about his abilities. Altair isn't too thrilled either, and he has good points to make as well. It's all greed with these people. Yeah, I'm including the Americans in this as well as the terrorists, who can claim all they like that it's for their religion, but it's always been about power and greed for both sides.

Made me a little nuts with all the let's not go - let's go back-and-forth.

I gotta admit, I do agree with The Panther that I do think people who immigrate to America should come to love it. It's a great place to live. If you don't like it, go home. Nobody's forcing you to stay.

Small tidbits of historical and biblical events are dropped in.

It sounds like the Yemeni government is the Keystone Kops personified. Wouldn't it be nice if leaders paid more attention to their people than their own ambitions? Sounds like it could apply to any country, doesn't it? Then there's Brenner's take on the Yemeni, and it sure sounds like most of Africa. The people are loyal to family and tribe first.

Ooh, another telling point. Brenner's comment has John thinking about fortress-prisons throughout history…that most of them are museums or attractions now. In civilized countries. And, yes, I do have an American-biased definition of civilized. It's one in which people are free to disagree, to walk or drive where they please, to take the jobs they desire, to dress as they please, to worship as they please, to appreciate ancient cultures, ahem…

Yeah, I'm curious too. How does Al Qaeda attract middle-class boys? What is wrong with our system that they would want to subject themselves to those conditions? DeMille/Chet does point out that many Muslim-Americans return to their countries and do good as well. Good point from John on why physical torture ain't the way.

John is complaining that Hakim is listening to the interrogation and he'll learn the direction the Americans want to go, but isn't that the idea? Lots of lawyer jokes as everyone tries to deal with the stupidity coming out of Washington. Some scary forewarnings in this.

I l-o-v-e those Predators…! Woohoo.

As much as The Panther hates Americans, he sure thinks like one. Or, rather, he thinks like an American politician. Sending everyone else out to die while he hangs back to see which way things go. Shoving blame off onto others. Betraying his own.

Jesus, after that scene, Altair says they're civilized…in what universe?

Maybe if the Yemeni Army knew what their lives would be like under Al Qaeda they'd be more interested in actually doing their jobs. I also think they should have swapped: Sheikh Musa for the president.

Hey, the modest bathing suits are more practical than I expected, lol.

Sounds like being PC can kill ya' as those idiots in Washington figured out when their new rules allowed a tiny boat to damage a warship.

Interesting comment by Zamo that "guys like these are hard to the core. They live, eat, and breathe war". Forget about this story's context. What other stories or events from history might you have read that depict men like this? Romantic suspense? Black Ops? Knights? Sounds like going back to the roots of civilization when hard men were needed. So what's changed for us now that such men in western countries are more the topic of a romance novel? And how could that be introduced into the Mideast…hmmm…

It breaks my heart when I think of what a flourishing civilization the Middle East was a few thousand years ago.

The Story
Seems someone wants to get rid of John and sending him with his wife back to Yemen may do that. John is to reprise his role on the Cole Response Team (ERT) while Kate will become the new legate, a legal attachée. The fate of their careers is a little extortion to push it through.

The Panther has his own goals and is rooted in his own ego.

The Characters
Detective John Corey is stubborn and recalcitrant as part of his innate nature. Retired on a disability from the NYPD, he accepted a contract with the Anti-Terrorist Task Force (ATTF) in New York. His wife, Special Agent Kate Mayfield, is a lawyer and part of the task force. I sure wish we'd learn more about what she thinks about John, other than her asides… Kate's father is retired FBI and her parents live in Minnesota. Robin is John's ex, a high-priced criminal defense lawyer.

Buckminster Fuller is with State Department Intelligence and the instructor for cultural awareness. John "Zamo" Zamoiski is an army sniper who will travel with them to Aden. Chet Morgan is the fifth man, their CIA contact. And he's whacked.

Yemen is…
…a Middle Eastern country with Sana'a as its capital. Alil Abdullah Saleh is Yemen's dictator-president. Hussein al-Houthi is a tribal leader who wants to recreate a fundamentalist state and is active in the north; Al Qaeda has taken the south and east, although they share the south with separatist rebels; the west is infested with pirates; and, sandwiched in between all this are the tribal warlords of whom Sheikh Musa, who runs the area around Marib and sells service and products to whoever pays, is one. Yasir is one of his men and very Yemeni. None of whom you can trust for a moment.

The National Security Bureau are…
…the ones in blue whose mission is to protect oil fields, oil field workers, tourists at historical sites, and patrol the main roads. You'll be charged for any service they say they'll render. Don't count on it. It's a branch of the PSO. Captain Dammaj is in charge of the mob on the road.

The Political Security Organization (PSO) is…
…an internal political security force. Commonly known throughout the Mideast as Mukhabarat (think KGB or Gestapo). Colonel Hakim is a major jerk with a brief to watch the embassy. Dr. Fahd "cares" for the prisoners at Ghumdan Fortress. Sammy is the interpreter. Rahim ibn Hayyam is the idiot of a prisoner. Yeah, I feel sorry for him too, but John's also right.

The publicly acknowledged bad guys
Bulus ibn al-Darwish, a.k.a., al-Numair, a.k.a., The Panther, a.k.a., al Amriki, a.k.a., Paul, is part of Al Qaeda and credited with lots of nastiness. In this story, The Panther is living in a maghara, a cave, with a woman. Hana is the sister who has disowned him while his mother, Sabria, is a housewife, and his father, Jurji, is a successful businessman in New Jersey. And I gotta say, they have a lot of chutzpah.

Nabeel al-Samad approaches Corey in New York and is one of The Panther's aides. Two officers from the defeated Army of Iraq: Behaddin Zuhair, a former captain, and Lieutenant Sayid al-Rashid, who will be his second-in-command on the Hunt Oil attack, are not impressed with The Panther. Altair al-Darwish is his most senior aide and will seek his own martyrdom; Jawad is another senior aide.

The Al Qaeda Supreme Council has put John and Kate's names on their assassination list.

The embassy in Sana'a
Paul Brenner is almost as snarky as John and having too much fun. He's also with the Diplomatic Security Service (DSS) working for the State Department to keep American Embassy personnel safe. Cynthia is his girlfriend and is Army, CID. I love the T-shirt Brenner is wearing when he meets John! "Federal Prisoner"…! Brenner has a nice background. I hope we eventually learn the reason for the early retirement. Mohammed is his driver. Howard Fensterman will be Kate's boss — the real legal attaché. Ed Peters is both the nondenominational preacher and the chief of DSS. Colonel Drew Kent is the Military Intelligence officer, U.S. Army. I suspect his thoughts on what's best for Yemen are probably right.

Edward James Hull is the ambassador who just left. Lucky dog. Barbara Bodine was the ambassadress when the U.S.S. Cole was bombed. Why would the U.S. send a woman to represent them when they know how Yemeni men feel about women?

Dr. Clare Nolan is the medic who travels with them to Aden. Mike Cassidy will drive Clare and John to Aden; he only has three weeks left.

Fort Apache in Aden
Well, actually, its proper name is the Sheraton Hotel. The DSS chief here is Doug Reynolds. Betsy Collins is there as the Supervisory Special Agent and Team Leader of ERT. Lyle Manning is the Supervisory Special Agent of the ten-man FBI SWAT Team. I thought FBI was supposed to be national while CIA was international? Captain "Mac" McAndrews is a Marine. Lance Corporals Brad Schiller and Wayne Peeples are guards at the Sheraton.

Wasim al-Rahib is the tour guide; Isa is the bus driver, Wasim's wife's cousin. Annette is the teenaged Belgian. Matt Longo is a young American John meets in Sana'a, exploring the country. Anisa is one of the women running the Hope in Your Hands shop. Tariq is the young Yemeni who sets the transponders.

ATTF, 26 Federal Plaza, New York City
FBI Special-Agent-in-Charge Tom Walsh is John's boss, who's more interested in loyalty to those above him than to those below. Frank is one of the guards at 26 Federal Plaza. Betty Alvarez gets the heads-up about a possible informant. Al-Rasul is one of John's co-workers and a good friend. Better than Walsh.

Ed Burke and Tony Savino are ex-cops as well, also working for the Feds. Ann Burke, Ed's wife, is still on the job while Marie is a stay-at-home mom.

Guest kidnappings. I don't understand places like this. Khat is a leaf that's chewed as a stimulant. A hijab is a head scarf that all women must wear.
"…Thursday is wet burqua night at the wadi. … Bring your laundry."

The Cover
The cover has a silver metallic background with a pouncing black panther between the author’s name and the title.

The title is John’s latest target, The Panther, one of the architects of the U.S.S. Cole’s bombing back in 2000.

mgh31's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous medium-paced

4.0

skepticcurmudgeon's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

Yeah it was fun but the bad guy seemed too much of a straw man and the big confrontation was over the top silly.