sfletcher26's review against another edition
2.0
The power of nostalgia is an amazing thing but it can also lead to selective amnesia. I remember reading Rogue Trooper in 2000AD as a kid and it being one of the best stories in the comic.
A reread however shows it to be good though a little derivative at times.
Part of the problem with the book however comes from the serial nature of the original story in that it spends too much time each episode repeating previously provided information.
The standout stories are however the two Alan Moore inclusions. Moore takes the environment and canon built by Finley-May moving it on to make it so much more, proving that he is one of if not the best writer of his generation.
A reread however shows it to be good though a little derivative at times.
Part of the problem with the book however comes from the serial nature of the original story in that it spends too much time each episode repeating previously provided information.
The standout stories are however the two Alan Moore inclusions. Moore takes the environment and canon built by Finley-May moving it on to make it so much more, proving that he is one of if not the best writer of his generation.
wetdryvac's review against another edition
3.0
I liked some of the components, but overall, definitely not my thing. The cover art style though - I could do with more of that in the world.
devinr's review against another edition
4.0
Oh, there is a REALLY big part of me that wants to give this five stars. It is so close to five stars. But not quite.
standardman's review against another edition
4.0
Old school writing but some astounding art but some of 2000 AD’s greats.
hammard's review
1.0
I genuinely found this a chore to get through. Essentially it is Kubertesque war stories given a slight science fiction covering. It improves a little bit for the last couple of tales, written by Alan Moore but I found little to interest me.
More...