The design and UX isn't done, Rob and Abbie, okkurrrr! 😌
hal2499's review against another edition
emotional
funny
hopeful
lighthearted
mysterious
sad
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.75
 Magic, Lies, and Deadly Pies is about the main character Daisy, and how she can put magic into the pies she makes. Her family has always had some type of magic. Specifically the women. She puts magic feelings into her pies so if she wants someone to feel calm or happy she can mix it in like how you would say it was made with love. The thing with her though is that she can kill men with her pies. When someone needs to kill a man she has special areas where they have to check off first. The ladies that use this service have to be told by someone else that has already used the service and the men have to be someone that is very bad like they are violent in some type of way to the woman. When she starts getting blackmailed by someone to kill women though all things get flipped upside down.
There is a cute romance in this book and the stakes are high but not terribly.
(Also there are pie recipes at the end of the book!!!)Â
There is a cute romance in this book and the stakes are high but not terribly.
(Also there are pie recipes at the end of the book!!!)Â
Content Warnings
Moderate: Drug abuse, Emotional abuse, and Domestic abuse
leandrathetbrzero's review against another edition
funny
mysterious
reflective
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
 Magic, Murder, and So Much Sugar #PiesBeforeGuys
↓ Similar Reading Experiences ↓
1. Baking Bad (on my TBR!)
2. A Study in Scarlet Women
3. Still Lives
Daisy Ellery’s magical pies have the ability to make one tell the truth, feel confident or hopeful or calm…and for a particular few, one slice can kill. Unlike the Ellery women before her, Daisy uses her magic to free women from their abusive partners by making and delivering murder pies. She has lived a nomadic lifestyle with her pitbull, Zoe, for most of her adult life, but she finally begins to settle in Turnbridge, MA. There, she has loyal customers, a found family, and love in the air. One thing she also has, however, is a blackmailer. This person knows about Daisy’s murder pies and, in exchange for silence, she might be forced to serve up murder pies to three innocent women. Can Daisy unmask her blackmailer before she has to use her magic for true evil?
I am obsessed with this new cozy mystery series! And I cannot wait for a Pies Before Guys sequel. Listening to this title on audiobook through Hoopla, I instantly fell in love with Daisy as a vigilante badass with a 1950s wardrobe. I have purchased a physical copy since completing this gem. The cast of characters surrounding our heroine is just as vivid and endearing. I felt emotionally invested in their growing and fluctuating relationships. This is a fascinating mystery because it focuses on uncovering a blackmailer in order to prevent the death of innocents. Daisy has killed many abusive, violent men before, but she has protocols and rules that must be strictly adhered to before any of this takes place. I appreciated the system, and I honestly found it to be a sound one. She was a gray character with sense no matter where your own morals stand, and I believe that’s what a true gray character should be. This was a cozy with crucial messages and themes I 100% could get behind: domestic violence awareness, feminism, and women supporting women. Popp balances these important topics with some subplotted romance, an adorable dog and community, and a most captivating mystery.
As the series moves forward – hopefully to many, MANY more books – I hope Popp delves deeper into examples beyond domestic violence performed by straight cis men toward straight cis women. With the amount of diversity and care she has put into this first book, I have full faith in her and her characters to face these challenges head-on.Â
↓ Similar Reading Experiences ↓
1. Baking Bad (on my TBR!)
2. A Study in Scarlet Women
3. Still Lives
Daisy Ellery’s magical pies have the ability to make one tell the truth, feel confident or hopeful or calm…and for a particular few, one slice can kill. Unlike the Ellery women before her, Daisy uses her magic to free women from their abusive partners by making and delivering murder pies. She has lived a nomadic lifestyle with her pitbull, Zoe, for most of her adult life, but she finally begins to settle in Turnbridge, MA. There, she has loyal customers, a found family, and love in the air. One thing she also has, however, is a blackmailer. This person knows about Daisy’s murder pies and, in exchange for silence, she might be forced to serve up murder pies to three innocent women. Can Daisy unmask her blackmailer before she has to use her magic for true evil?
I am obsessed with this new cozy mystery series! And I cannot wait for a Pies Before Guys sequel. Listening to this title on audiobook through Hoopla, I instantly fell in love with Daisy as a vigilante badass with a 1950s wardrobe. I have purchased a physical copy since completing this gem. The cast of characters surrounding our heroine is just as vivid and endearing. I felt emotionally invested in their growing and fluctuating relationships. This is a fascinating mystery because it focuses on uncovering a blackmailer in order to prevent the death of innocents. Daisy has killed many abusive, violent men before, but she has protocols and rules that must be strictly adhered to before any of this takes place. I appreciated the system, and I honestly found it to be a sound one. She was a gray character with sense no matter where your own morals stand, and I believe that’s what a true gray character should be. This was a cozy with crucial messages and themes I 100% could get behind: domestic violence awareness, feminism, and women supporting women. Popp balances these important topics with some subplotted romance, an adorable dog and community, and a most captivating mystery.
As the series moves forward – hopefully to many, MANY more books – I hope Popp delves deeper into examples beyond domestic violence performed by straight cis men toward straight cis women. With the amount of diversity and care she has put into this first book, I have full faith in her and her characters to face these challenges head-on.Â
Content Warnings
Minor: Death of parent, Drug abuse, Domestic abuse, Sexism, Stalking, and Misogyny
More...