meganmaurice's review against another edition
3.0
3.5 Stars
There was lots of really important information in this book and I’m glad I read it. For me though, it tended more towards the “Lean In” style of feminism and less towards the “dismantle the entire patriarchal system” which frustrated me at times.
There was lots of really important information in this book and I’m glad I read it. For me though, it tended more towards the “Lean In” style of feminism and less towards the “dismantle the entire patriarchal system” which frustrated me at times.
joyllywood's review against another edition
4.0
An important book. I skimmed at times but she is very honest and right on.
jaclyn_sixminutesforme's review
4.0
This was a slow start for me, but once the content moved into Spicer's career experiences I was gripped! Important exposure of issues women face in the workplace.
babyleo's review
3.0
I did this as an audiobook and the beginning has a lot of clunky jokes which probably flow better when read to yourself instead of read aloud, but you get through them and it settles into more of a story. Having Spicer read it herself means she gets to include her own inflections and express her humour as she intended which is good because as slightly jarring as it was to hear, I fear it would have been worse having someone else try and do it.
One thing I noticed early on is that Spicer doesn’t seem to know who her audience is. She makes jokes about using encyclopaedias before the internet and explains obvious references in a slightly condescending manner like she is addressing children or teenagers, ignorant teenagers at that, whom I doubt are her main readership. I don’t doubt most of her readership are people over 30 who have enough sense to know that people used encyclopaedias before the internet without needing the patronising explanation. This happens a fair bit as she explains things that while even at my age I might not have been alive to experience, I still understand.
There are themes much like Fight Like A Girl as Spicer takes us on a journey through the decades as a women, a teenager and a girl, exposed to sexism, abuse, and disrespect in her life and workplace. Her own sarcasm and opinions adding some nice flare as she mocks the industry and those in it with humour and disdain.
I waited through the first half of the book, which was not uninteresting, but not entirely engaging either waiting for The Moment. I thought that suing for discrimination was going to be a more defining moment, the “good girl turns bad” moment. In the end it comes and goes a little lacklustre and after I was expecting it to be the climax that shifted this story into a fight for equality and the moment Tracey said “no more!”, it kind of wasn’t.
I think we got more about her moving house then we did about her confrontation with her network. I understand non-disclosure agreements and terms of settlements, but I still think this could have been explored a little more, considering it was such a huge event, something I had been expecting to be a climax of this book.
However, if you set aside that my expectations were skewed or I read too much into it, the book is still interesting and not unimportant. There is feminism and anger at the patriarchy but no real solutions. Unlike Clementine Ford who tells us how to burn down the establishment, Spicer keeps pointing out the inequality but doesn’t help us find a solution.
As a look at her life and her career it is interesting and shows you the behind the scenes and bones of her career. She strips away the flare and the lights of the television industry and she shows off her amazing achievements. I think this should be what is taken from the book, a great career from a great woman.
A longer version of this review was published on my blog Lost in a Good Book
One thing I noticed early on is that Spicer doesn’t seem to know who her audience is. She makes jokes about using encyclopaedias before the internet and explains obvious references in a slightly condescending manner like she is addressing children or teenagers, ignorant teenagers at that, whom I doubt are her main readership. I don’t doubt most of her readership are people over 30 who have enough sense to know that people used encyclopaedias before the internet without needing the patronising explanation. This happens a fair bit as she explains things that while even at my age I might not have been alive to experience, I still understand.
There are themes much like Fight Like A Girl as Spicer takes us on a journey through the decades as a women, a teenager and a girl, exposed to sexism, abuse, and disrespect in her life and workplace. Her own sarcasm and opinions adding some nice flare as she mocks the industry and those in it with humour and disdain.
I waited through the first half of the book, which was not uninteresting, but not entirely engaging either waiting for The Moment. I thought that suing for discrimination was going to be a more defining moment, the “good girl turns bad” moment. In the end it comes and goes a little lacklustre and after I was expecting it to be the climax that shifted this story into a fight for equality and the moment Tracey said “no more!”, it kind of wasn’t.
I think we got more about her moving house then we did about her confrontation with her network. I understand non-disclosure agreements and terms of settlements, but I still think this could have been explored a little more, considering it was such a huge event, something I had been expecting to be a climax of this book.
However, if you set aside that my expectations were skewed or I read too much into it, the book is still interesting and not unimportant. There is feminism and anger at the patriarchy but no real solutions. Unlike Clementine Ford who tells us how to burn down the establishment, Spicer keeps pointing out the inequality but doesn’t help us find a solution.
As a look at her life and her career it is interesting and shows you the behind the scenes and bones of her career. She strips away the flare and the lights of the television industry and she shows off her amazing achievements. I think this should be what is taken from the book, a great career from a great woman.
A longer version of this review was published on my blog Lost in a Good Book
bookstorian's review
3.0
I'm really finding my stride when it comes to reading autobiographies. In fact I think this is my 3rd or 4th this year!
After finding this book club read and my local library a month ago I took a little while to pick it it, but, once I did I completely devoured it.
I was really inspired by Tracey's fighting spirit and her unique and, at times, raw voice that she gave to her struggles including her past and experiences of being a female in a male world.
A highly educative work by one of Queensland treasures!
After finding this book club read and my local library a month ago I took a little while to pick it it, but, once I did I completely devoured it.
I was really inspired by Tracey's fighting spirit and her unique and, at times, raw voice that she gave to her struggles including her past and experiences of being a female in a male world.
A highly educative work by one of Queensland treasures!
essjay1's review against another edition
4.0
Good memoir, with lots of stories about Australian media and her work with aid groups.
meganori's review
informative
inspiring
slow-paced
3.5
Interesting look at sexism in Australian media
doddyaboutbooks's review
5.0
This is just so good - Spicer's writing is both raw and wickedly funny. Her commentary on the Australian media landscape is absolutely scathing. This book is a wonderful piece of feminism.
somuchsong's review
3.0
This was enjoyable enough, though the humour fell a bit flat for me at times and the shouty caps were very overused. A quick and interesting read.
More...