amrix11's review against another edition
4.0
i great sequel to the first, i believe Ben's writing has improved...
By the time you get to the second book you finally have an okay connection with the characters and are able to relate in a way. Most of this book is about the long journey south, further and further away from Rome. it seems hopeless until the last few pages that Romulus will ever see Rome again. Good battle scenes in this book but i wish they were more in depth, I realize there were several battle scenes and if they were all in depth the book would be way too long, but still...
Other things I didn't like about this book:
-The lack of suspense and hooks
-The descriptions of everything
-The painfully long recap
-And the time jumps
I found it way to easy to just set aside for a week or two because nothing was grabbing my interest and compelling me to read on. The story and plot is not bad, its just not fast paced i suppose.
I also did not like how Ben just described events I really wanted to watch unfold (like battle scenes!). It was like reading a text book at times as he just 'told' you what happened form a birds eye view, you didn't 'live' through it with the character.
Time jumps really annoy me too, I understand that its almost impossible to live through a whole mans life in three books without time jumps (although Iggulden did it well!) but turning the page and seeing 'nine months later' or 'three years later' so many times consecutively annoys me.
Its definitely good enough to continue the series, as I have stated too already, now that a character connection has _finally_ been made, I am enjoying the series. definitely worth a read if Ancient Rome is your thing.
By the time you get to the second book you finally have an okay connection with the characters and are able to relate in a way. Most of this book is about the long journey south, further and further away from Rome. it seems hopeless until the last few pages that Romulus will ever see Rome again. Good battle scenes in this book but i wish they were more in depth, I realize there were several battle scenes and if they were all in depth the book would be way too long, but still...
Other things I didn't like about this book:
-The lack of suspense and hooks
-The descriptions of everything
-The painfully long recap
-And the time jumps
I found it way to easy to just set aside for a week or two because nothing was grabbing my interest and compelling me to read on. The story and plot is not bad, its just not fast paced i suppose.
I also did not like how Ben just described events I really wanted to watch unfold (like battle scenes!). It was like reading a text book at times as he just 'told' you what happened form a birds eye view, you didn't 'live' through it with the character.
Time jumps really annoy me too, I understand that its almost impossible to live through a whole mans life in three books without time jumps (although Iggulden did it well!) but turning the page and seeing 'nine months later' or 'three years later' so many times consecutively annoys me.
Its definitely good enough to continue the series, as I have stated too already, now that a character connection has _finally_ been made, I am enjoying the series. definitely worth a read if Ancient Rome is your thing.
disastrouspenguin's review
3.0
Same pros and cons as the first book: okay writing interspersed with interesting action scenes and factual tidbits awkwardly crammed in sporadically, feeling either a bit inadvertently non-sequitur or as an out-of-place lecture.
Still, I'll read the third and final book and the series - I am curious where the author will land his characters in the end.
Still, I'll read the third and final book and the series - I am curious where the author will land his characters in the end.
innashtakser's review
4.0
Nice easy read. Tons of action. Some anti-slavery sentiment. Overall - enjoyed it. What did I miss though? A real feel of time and place. Somehow it was not there and the lack was disguised by the never stopping action. A feel of how the people in the book really differ from the ones I meet in the grocery store. The differences seem rather artificial (blood thirstiness is really not enough).
speesh's review
4.0
This is an excellent read. At least on a par with Harry Sidebottom's 'Warrior of Rome' books.'The Silver Eagle', is number two in Ben Kane's 'Forgotten Legion' series.
The Forgotten Legion are one of the Roman Legions defeated after the battle of Carrhae. They are then captured and taken east by the victors, the Parthians. In the east, they are kept together and kept fighting, but under (name) control against their eastern enemies, ending with a huge battle in the far east against an Indian army, in the footsteps of Alexander the Great.
Throughout this story and the previous book (presumably number three as well), we follow a brother and sister, made slaves, sold, captured, forced to fight, forced to...well, plenty of other things. They are separated, the sister is kept in Rome, the brother, Romulus, is forced into the 'Forgotten Legion.' The story follows them and the people who become their close friends, companions, spiritual advisors, enemies, rivals, tormentors and worse. The novel is centred around the two and their adventures both trying to stay alive at a crucial period in Roman history (the rise of Julius Caesar, the end of the Republic, the time of Rome as an empire, driven by Emperors and Caesars, modelled in various degrees of success, on Julius Caesar) and their search for each other and for revenge.
If you know, or can remember anything of this period of Roman history from your school-days, then there seem to be some clues as to what might well happen in the third (and possibly final) volume of The Forgotten Legion series. But, I could be mistaken of course.
You don't necessarily need to have read the previous book, The Forgotten Legion, but it would only increase your enjoyment of The Silver Eagle. There's a good pace kept up throughout the book, which is obviously written from a thorough understanding of and a deep interest in, the period it is set.
If there is one thing though, that I was a little doubtful about. He has a habit of ending each chapter on a cliff-hanger; 'will they, won't they get out of this one!' Whilst never having read any Charles Dickens (seen enough tv series and films to cover that particular base), I understand he used to do it because his stories were published in weekly, or monthly, periodicals and each chapter or section finished on a cliff-hanger in order to get the reader sufficiently worked-up to purchase the next edition. Here, Ben Kane is merely shifting from one strand of the story to another and back. Whilst it is exciting to read of battles against overwhelming odds blended into the story, it does get a little wearing and in danger of becoming a forced cliche by doing it at the end of each chapter. It eases up in the later sections and the story is the better for it.
Other than that minor irritation, I can thoroughly recommend 'The Silver Eagle' and look forward to the next excuse to order a whole load of new books from Amazon.
The Forgotten Legion are one of the Roman Legions defeated after the battle of Carrhae. They are then captured and taken east by the victors, the Parthians. In the east, they are kept together and kept fighting, but under (name) control against their eastern enemies, ending with a huge battle in the far east against an Indian army, in the footsteps of Alexander the Great.
Throughout this story and the previous book (presumably number three as well), we follow a brother and sister, made slaves, sold, captured, forced to fight, forced to...well, plenty of other things. They are separated, the sister is kept in Rome, the brother, Romulus, is forced into the 'Forgotten Legion.' The story follows them and the people who become their close friends, companions, spiritual advisors, enemies, rivals, tormentors and worse. The novel is centred around the two and their adventures both trying to stay alive at a crucial period in Roman history (the rise of Julius Caesar, the end of the Republic, the time of Rome as an empire, driven by Emperors and Caesars, modelled in various degrees of success, on Julius Caesar) and their search for each other and for revenge.
If you know, or can remember anything of this period of Roman history from your school-days, then there seem to be some clues as to what might well happen in the third (and possibly final) volume of The Forgotten Legion series. But, I could be mistaken of course.
You don't necessarily need to have read the previous book, The Forgotten Legion, but it would only increase your enjoyment of The Silver Eagle. There's a good pace kept up throughout the book, which is obviously written from a thorough understanding of and a deep interest in, the period it is set.
If there is one thing though, that I was a little doubtful about. He has a habit of ending each chapter on a cliff-hanger; 'will they, won't they get out of this one!' Whilst never having read any Charles Dickens (seen enough tv series and films to cover that particular base), I understand he used to do it because his stories were published in weekly, or monthly, periodicals and each chapter or section finished on a cliff-hanger in order to get the reader sufficiently worked-up to purchase the next edition. Here, Ben Kane is merely shifting from one strand of the story to another and back. Whilst it is exciting to read of battles against overwhelming odds blended into the story, it does get a little wearing and in danger of becoming a forced cliche by doing it at the end of each chapter. It eases up in the later sections and the story is the better for it.
Other than that minor irritation, I can thoroughly recommend 'The Silver Eagle' and look forward to the next excuse to order a whole load of new books from Amazon.
More...