thisbookishcat's review against another edition
3.5
Overall I thought this book was phenomenally better than all of his other books so far; this is the sort of writing my family has spoken so highly of. The intrigue, espionage, real intense happenings.
However, a few things still bothered me which I'll focus on now, so spoilers.
Secondly, as a Canadian, I cannot agree with the notion that a Canadian Prime Minister would work with the United States to bring the two nations together. Given the history of both nations, especially around the time of this novel when martial law was in place in Quebec and the US was offering to step in but was swiftly told to back off, I don't ever see this happening. That part of the ending really dropped this from being a solid 4 stars for me.
Overall, this book was far better and I only have high hopes for the rest of his books.
However, a few things still bothered me which I'll focus on now, so spoilers.
Spoiler
Firstly, I was happy that there was less misogynistic tenancies than there were in previous books, however even the military women in this novel were written as frail and in need of a man, in need of saving. Not cool. I would expect a navy woman to be able to handle her own and to not be tolerant of this sort of behaviour.Secondly, as a Canadian, I cannot agree with the notion that a Canadian Prime Minister would work with the United States to bring the two nations together. Given the history of both nations, especially around the time of this novel when martial law was in place in Quebec and the US was offering to step in but was swiftly told to back off, I don't ever see this happening. That part of the ending really dropped this from being a solid 4 stars for me.
Overall, this book was far better and I only have high hopes for the rest of his books.
pia_11_08's review against another edition
adventurous
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? N/A
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.5
taque's review against another edition
2.0
What do a St. Lawrence River boat crash and a Hudson River train crash have in common? Dirk Pitt. That and the fact that several governments are all interested in a historical artifact relating to both diasters. Throw in some high-tech diving and gunfights, take Giordino and Gunn along for the ride, and you have Night Probe.
Cussler had almost hit his stride with this book. It was better written than his next, Iceberg, and he brought the reader into the story. The downside was the last third of the book again, where Cussler seems to struggle. A moment of brutality and some ending scenarios that just did not seem believable, even for the characters and plot.
Cussler had almost hit his stride with this book. It was better written than his next, Iceberg, and he brought the reader into the story. The downside was the last third of the book again, where Cussler seems to struggle. A moment of brutality and some ending scenarios that just did not seem believable, even for the characters and plot.
thomcat's review against another edition
4.0
The fifth published Dirk Pitt novel was pretty good, and may be a tough standard for the other novels to live up to. Underwater action, adventure, seduction, and of course classic cars - but this novel adds history to the mix quite effectively. I just wish it were more electronically available...
I have read that this is one of the best early Dirk Pitt novels - apparently [b:Treasure|85737|Treasure (Dirk Pitt, #9)|Clive Cussler|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1314486012l/85737._SY75_.jpg|3041094] is the dividing point. I did enjoy it quite a bit, especially the underwater scenes. I also read that Brian Shaw was essentially James Bond, but I didn't get that vibe. Well, okay, full marks in the seduction game, but otherwise no. Gly is a suitable villain, though a bit mad. I understand he returns in a later novel.
So what didn't I like? I remember 1981, and the threat of a separatist Quebec was as much in the news as the Cold war. The ending felt very a-historical. This is only the 2nd Dirk Pitt I've read, so maybe this is always a thing, but I'm not sure how this world continues. Also, the action at the end was a little hard to follow. Minor quibbles, indeed. Will be interesting to see how the others match up to this.
I have read that this is one of the best early Dirk Pitt novels - apparently [b:Treasure|85737|Treasure (Dirk Pitt, #9)|Clive Cussler|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1314486012l/85737._SY75_.jpg|3041094] is the dividing point. I did enjoy it quite a bit, especially the underwater scenes. I also read that Brian Shaw was essentially James Bond, but I didn't get that vibe. Well, okay, full marks in the seduction game, but otherwise no. Gly is a suitable villain, though a bit mad. I understand he returns in a later novel.
So what didn't I like? I remember 1981, and the threat of a separatist Quebec was as much in the news as the Cold war. The ending felt very a-historical. This is only the 2nd Dirk Pitt I've read, so maybe this is always a thing, but I'm not sure how this world continues. Also, the action at the end was a little hard to follow. Minor quibbles, indeed. Will be interesting to see how the others match up to this.
bodebeabay's review against another edition
4.0
[b:Night Probe!|818372|Night Probe! (Dirk Pitt, #6)|Clive Cussler|https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1388278191s/818372.jpg|1689755] by [a:Clive Cussler|18411|Clive Cussler|https://images.gr-assets.com/authors/1225620641p2/18411.jpg]
Genres; Action/Adventure, Crime, Mystery, Suspense
4 Stars
Published April 1st 1982 by Bantam Book
I admit it. I oftentimes buy my books at flea markets and yard sells. What is awesome is when the wife is dumping her husbands book collection. Talk about a gold mine for an avid addicted reader and a lover of suspense, action and 'secret agent' types. This particular yard sell endeavor yielded me a BOX FULL of paperback and (got to love it) Hardback! copies of Clive Cussler books and other gems.
Another big plus, in the very near future I was to meet my present husband, and when he saw my collection of these books, it was 'Insta-Love'.
I sometimes wonder if he just wanted me for my books. Lmbo.
This one was full of action and suspense. Mystery & Intrigue.
A super fun read.
I Loved it.
Genres; Action/Adventure, Crime, Mystery, Suspense
4 Stars
Published April 1st 1982 by Bantam Book
I admit it. I oftentimes buy my books at flea markets and yard sells. What is awesome is when the wife is dumping her husbands book collection. Talk about a gold mine for an avid addicted reader and a lover of suspense, action and 'secret agent' types. This particular yard sell endeavor yielded me a BOX FULL of paperback and (got to love it) Hardback! copies of Clive Cussler books and other gems.
Another big plus, in the very near future I was to meet my present husband, and when he saw my collection of these books, it was 'Insta-Love'.
I sometimes wonder if he just wanted me for my books. Lmbo.
This one was full of action and suspense. Mystery & Intrigue.
A super fun read.
I Loved it.
unphilosophize's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
informative
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
fat_girl_fiction's review against another edition
4.0
Night Probe by Clive Cussler
I'm a massive fan of Clive Cussler and all his works, especially Dirk Pitt, Kurt Austin and the new Isaac Bell stories. As expected, Night Probe is a great addition to the collection. It's classic Cussler, spans over years and is full of action and adventure.
I'm a massive fan of Clive Cussler and all his works, especially Dirk Pitt, Kurt Austin and the new Isaac Bell stories. As expected, Night Probe is a great addition to the collection. It's classic Cussler, spans over years and is full of action and adventure.
dsneediii's review against another edition
4.0
This was another great story in the Dirk Pitt series. I liked the whole premise of the U.S. floundering with money issues and a shortage of oil, and a document that may well be the solution to the problems. Overall this was a great action/ adventure book and is a must read for Clive Cussler fans.