blacksentai's review against another edition
3.0
I like this volume a bit more than volume 1. I think less stories feel incomplete. Jealous Cliff still makes too many appearances, but it's not as severe as it was in volume one. I think the artist choices were stronger here as well. I'd recommend picking up volume 2 over volume 1.
thecommonswings's review against another edition
2.0
Same as before if not worse, with a couple of valiant exceptions. Bill Sienkiewicz is a genius but doesn’t so much phone his pages in as look like he drew them when driving. But Stan Sakai is *perfect* with a really sweet vignette, drawn perfectly. And Louise Simonson gets to write a story and oddly enough Betty doesn’t spend the whole thing looking like the old Jane comic strips, with her clothes falling off every other frame. It’s not a great book but thank god for Sakai who saves this. Still getting rid of it though
More...