liisp_cvr2cvr's review against another edition
4.0
This was a 'done and dusted in a day' book for me. It was captivating, intriguing and had so much human condition element, I truly enjoyed it. A lot of ethical questions surface, a lot of what if's and I think the author did a great job and tackling this sensitive story from all ends. Really enjoyed it.
msandvik0505's review against another edition
3.0
I didn't enjoy this book as much as some of Gaskell's others but I still found it entertaining. I liked reading about Mickey the youngest sister the most.
bibliopaat's review against another edition
2.0
Can I put this in the sci-fi section? Because come on - brain transplant? The book is exploring the areas that are really alien to most people. I don't think it was a good medium to showcase the struggle of people who get donor organs.
At least the lovestory was kind of cute. At times. The best part of the book was Elliot. But he was maybe too perfect? Can it be possible?
At least the lovestory was kind of cute. At times. The best part of the book was Elliot. But he was maybe too perfect? Can it be possible?
cathy5boys's review against another edition
3.0
Chick lit. A snipet of time in the lives of three sisters, told sequentially in each of the sister's voices.
erikadawnh's review
4.0
This is the first book I’ve finished all year (hooray to college) and it was exactly what I was looking for. Fun, simple, quick read. It has a little bit of everything from sex, love, heartbreak, laughs and tears. Would highly recommend if you need a pick me up. Definitely has one of those happily ever after endings.
jchan's review
3.0
To be honest, I tried this book because I could not find my usual authors; but boy was I pleasantly surprised! She, Myself & I is such a good easy read, and very tough to put down. I am not sure my grades will thank me for it.
Paige, Sophie and Mickey are so lovable really, even if the middle sister came across as a whiny wife and sister. I loved the first section on Paige most, and I think that was what really kept me reading: her character, her bossy yet loving side, her insecurities with guys, and the way she deal with her husband-turned-gay and next guy. The way Paige ran and hid away from Zack, and then continued feeling insecure throughout is such a real emotion.
I mean, Nora Roberts and Sophie Kinesella are great authors but their books are a little hard to identify with. Whitney Gaskell did great on that score. A really lovely read.
Paige, Sophie and Mickey are so lovable really, even if the middle sister came across as a whiny wife and sister. I loved the first section on Paige most, and I think that was what really kept me reading: her character, her bossy yet loving side, her insecurities with guys, and the way she deal with her husband-turned-gay and next guy. The way Paige ran and hid away from Zack, and then continued feeling insecure throughout is such a real emotion.
I mean, Nora Roberts and Sophie Kinesella are great authors but their books are a little hard to identify with. Whitney Gaskell did great on that score. A really lovely read.
mikolee's review
2.0
Summer chick lit focused on three adult sisters and their love lives. Each woman a bit scarred by their parents tumultuous divorce when they were children. Each one stunned as their parents get back together. Not very well written or I insightful and very predictable. But a quick read nevertheless.
More...