maddidunham's review
challenging
dark
emotional
hopeful
inspiring
reflective
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.75
lindaunconventionalbookworms's review
5.0
Good Luck With That follows Marley and Georgia - and partly Emerson, as they grow up, become adults, and struggle with life, and their weigh - after meeting at fat-camp the summer they turned 18.
There is so much heartache in this novel, and so many insecurities I could completely relate to.
Full review to come.
There is so much heartache in this novel, and so many insecurities I could completely relate to.
Full review to come.
lindsay28's review against another edition
4.0
Hits right in the gut...never knew the struggle of truly obese people...
kittykornerlibrarian's review
3.0
I liked it... parts of it were painful to read, but I liked it. I think a lot of women deal with weight and body image issues and that seemed realistic to me. I really can't put down a Kristan Higgins book once I get started on one. I liked Marley and Georgia and appreciated their struggles and was glad to see them come to terms with their issues. I can't really love the tony small town in Westchester setting; I don't like shiny little small towns. So I liked the people and not the place, I guess.
emilyppearson's review
emotional
hopeful
inspiring
reflective
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
cs_the_librarian's review
emotional
hopeful
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? N/A
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
3.0
kbranfield's review against another edition
4.0
4.5 stars.
Good Luck with That by Kristan Higgins is a poignant yet uplifting novel of friendship, love and healing.
Georgia Sloane, Marley DeFelice and Emerson Duval met one another at a weightloss camp when they were teens. Now in their mid-thirties, they remain close friends and when Emerson passes away, her last request is that Marley and Georgia complete the list of activities they compiled their last year at the camp. Despite their discomfort with some of the items on the activities, they agree they need to honor their friend's wish. Once they have completed the list, will Georgia and Marley have made progress in coming to terms with how being overweight has affected many aspects of their lives?
Georgia is a former lawyer turned nursery school teacher whose marriage failed due to her unresolved issues with her weight. Throughout her childhood, both her mother and brother frequently disparaged her appearance which still continues to some degree in the present. Cowed by their remarks and dismissive attitude, Georgia has never confronted them on their verbal and emotional abuse. Despite her recent weight loss following a family emergency, Georgia's perception of herself remains skewed and she cannot "see" herself as anything other than overweight and unworthy. When her ex-husband Rafe Santiago re-enters her life due to his niece becoming one of her students, Georgia is finally forced to confront how her body issues and lack of self-worth led to the self-destructive end of her marriage to a man who at one time worshiped her.
Marley has made peace with the fact that she will never be skinny. She lives a very healthy lifestyle and she has a positive relationship with food. Her family is warm, loving and gregarious but the loss of Marley's twin sister has left an indelible mark on her and the rest of the brood. Despite her happy and upbeat personality, Marley does not have much of a romantic history. In fact, for the past five years, she has been pining after a man whose treatment of her is absolutely abysmal. Yet, Marley is willing to settle for him because no one else has taken an interest in her. During the course of the book, Marley traverses the emotional minefield of dealing with the loss of her twin while at the same time realizing she deserves more than being some man's occasional booty call.
Emerson's part of the storyline is revealed through a series of diary entries. Not gonna lie, these passages are incredibly difficult to read because her self-loathing just pours off the pages. Emerson's relationship with food is incredibly toxic and her relationship with a co-worker is just tragic. Her food addiction leads her to become morbidly obese and this shame results in her distancing herself from Georgia and Sloane. In the end, Emerson's last request to Marley and Georgia has a much deeper meaning than just crossing items off of a list.
Good Luck with That is an incredibly heartfelt and emotional novel that inspires both laughter and tears. Georgia and Marley's close friendship is quite endearing and their love and support for each other is unconditional. Kristan Higgins deftly handles tough subject matter in a forthright manner and provides an insightful and thought provoking novel that realistically portrays women's struggles with weight, self-acceptance and body image. An extremely well-written and meaningful novel that made me laugh, cry and give serious consideration to the issues Marley, Georgia and Emerson have struggled with throughout their lives.
Read about Ms. Higgins' personal struggles with body image HERE.
Ms. Higgins discusses Good Luck with That HERE.
Good Luck with That by Kristan Higgins is a poignant yet uplifting novel of friendship, love and healing.
Georgia Sloane, Marley DeFelice and Emerson Duval met one another at a weightloss camp when they were teens. Now in their mid-thirties, they remain close friends and when Emerson passes away, her last request is that Marley and Georgia complete the list of activities they compiled their last year at the camp. Despite their discomfort with some of the items on the activities, they agree they need to honor their friend's wish. Once they have completed the list, will Georgia and Marley have made progress in coming to terms with how being overweight has affected many aspects of their lives?
Georgia is a former lawyer turned nursery school teacher whose marriage failed due to her unresolved issues with her weight. Throughout her childhood, both her mother and brother frequently disparaged her appearance which still continues to some degree in the present. Cowed by their remarks and dismissive attitude, Georgia has never confronted them on their verbal and emotional abuse. Despite her recent weight loss following a family emergency, Georgia's perception of herself remains skewed and she cannot "see" herself as anything other than overweight and unworthy. When her ex-husband Rafe Santiago re-enters her life due to his niece becoming one of her students, Georgia is finally forced to confront how her body issues and lack of self-worth led to the self-destructive end of her marriage to a man who at one time worshiped her.
Marley has made peace with the fact that she will never be skinny. She lives a very healthy lifestyle and she has a positive relationship with food. Her family is warm, loving and gregarious but the loss of Marley's twin sister has left an indelible mark on her and the rest of the brood. Despite her happy and upbeat personality, Marley does not have much of a romantic history. In fact, for the past five years, she has been pining after a man whose treatment of her is absolutely abysmal. Yet, Marley is willing to settle for him because no one else has taken an interest in her. During the course of the book, Marley traverses the emotional minefield of dealing with the loss of her twin while at the same time realizing she deserves more than being some man's occasional booty call.
Emerson's part of the storyline is revealed through a series of diary entries. Not gonna lie, these passages are incredibly difficult to read because her self-loathing just pours off the pages. Emerson's relationship with food is incredibly toxic and her relationship with a co-worker is just tragic. Her food addiction leads her to become morbidly obese and this shame results in her distancing herself from Georgia and Sloane. In the end, Emerson's last request to Marley and Georgia has a much deeper meaning than just crossing items off of a list.
Good Luck with That is an incredibly heartfelt and emotional novel that inspires both laughter and tears. Georgia and Marley's close friendship is quite endearing and their love and support for each other is unconditional. Kristan Higgins deftly handles tough subject matter in a forthright manner and provides an insightful and thought provoking novel that realistically portrays women's struggles with weight, self-acceptance and body image. An extremely well-written and meaningful novel that made me laugh, cry and give serious consideration to the issues Marley, Georgia and Emerson have struggled with throughout their lives.
Read about Ms. Higgins' personal struggles with body image HERE.
Ms. Higgins discusses Good Luck with That HERE.
jmcfaddy's review
4.0
It took me a little bit to get into this book, but once I did I really enjoyed it. The topic was certainly prevalent within today's society. With all of the eating disorders out there and the amount of obesity now it was a very relevant topic to address. This book I found was quite different from other books I have read by Ms. Higgins. I always look forward to many laugh out loud moments when I read her books and this book seemed to follow a much more serious trend. I did laugh a few times, however with the topic addressed, I can understand why it had a more serious flavour to it.
andrearbooks's review
4.0
Good Luck With That by Kristan Higgins was a book focused on the concepts of body image and self-love. It was an ARC I received. This book took on a very complex topic as it focuses on three friends who met as teens as a weight loss camp. The story begins with the death of one of the women due to her extreme obesity. With her death, she leaves behind a list for her two friends they wrote at that camp of things they would do once they were skinny. Through the list, the story explores the messages these women have heard about their weight, the way weight impacts their relationships, and the way this has impacted how these women feel about themselves. There are some hard and aggravating messages and characters in this one, but they are there to explore the depth of the issue. I enjoyed and found an emotional connection, particularly with the love stories, with this one more than I anticipated as I went through these women's journeys.