Scan barcode
sweetsxrrxw's review against another edition
hopeful
lighthearted
reflective
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.25
since during last ramadan i decided to read love from a to z, i thought it would be a good idea to read its second part this year!
but there's a few reasons why i did not like it as much as the first book and one of them is the pacing of the conflict. it just lasted for like 80% of the book and it could have easily been fixed if they just talked to each other... miscommunication is truly something, lmao. however, i guess i can kind of understand why they couldn't. and that's the point where i get to talk about the subplot, aka one of my favorite things in the book.
although it was sad that a and z didn't get to spend many cute moments together, i think that it is totally normal for couples and marriages to go through times where they are not at the same place, either mentally, physically and spiritually. obviously, both their struggles were equally valid and relatable.
zayneb has been under a lot of stress because of some allegations about her going on at college and bc she doesn't have a place where to live.
adam is struggling to find a job and starts wondering if he should not have dropped out of college. he feels guilty and he know zayneb's family won't accept him if he can't "stand on his two feet".
amidst these different stressful situations adam's dad intervenes and proposes they should both make umrah. adam thinks it's a great idea, a good oportunity to literally pray for a job. but zayneb is not feeling really in the mood for that journey so she basically goes to umrah for adam and not herself.
however this journey helps both of them to realize things about themselves and by the end of their umrah they feel like they have changed and maybe life is smiling at them.
not only it was interesting to read about them, their introspection and realizations but it was really nice to read about the setting. i feel like it's a great book to learn more about the umrah, even if you're muslim. for example, i am a muslim myself but i had no idea of some things such as the distance between safa and marwa or the order of the things you have to do.
going back to some things i did not really like,one of them was the ending with sarina. okay maybe she was jealous of zayneb or maybe she felt she was better for being nice or whatever. but pairing her up with yasin, the haram police, after she said she wanted a religious guy was not it. i think she definitely deserved better.
then there's the resolution of the miscommunication. i feel like the conflict lasted way too long to fix it in less than one page. i get the adam and zayneb love each other. a lot. but i feel like they should have talked about the situation better and be completely open with each other. im guessing it partly happened off camera but idk, the make up stage just felt super rushed :/
but yeah, despite that, this was cute and realistic and it hit so close to my faith. i truly enjoyed reading it and i recommend it, specially if you're muslim <3
ps: i need to get this out, im sorry, lmao. i excluded it from the main review bc it's not something involving the plot or writing, but the audiobook. i was listening to it while reading, in order to focus better. and the narrators were amazing, of course! now i can't imagine the MCs' voices sounding any other way. i noticed they hired a brown and an asian narrator which is cool. but... i just wish they knew how to speak arabic lmfao.
like im sorry but everytime there was an expression in arabic, specially the girl, struggled to pronounce the words and ngl it kinda hurt to listen, lmao. like, the "labbaik allahuma labbaik" dhikr always makes me tear up. but in this audiobook it was just awful to listen to, im sorry
but there's a few reasons why i did not like it as much as the first book and one of them is the pacing of the conflict. it just lasted for like 80% of the book and it could have easily been fixed if they just talked to each other... miscommunication is truly something, lmao. however, i guess i can kind of understand why they couldn't. and that's the point where i get to talk about the subplot, aka one of my favorite things in the book.
although it was sad that a and z didn't get to spend many cute moments together, i think that it is totally normal for couples and marriages to go through times where they are not at the same place, either mentally, physically and spiritually. obviously, both their struggles were equally valid and relatable.
zayneb has been under a lot of stress because of some allegations about her going on at college and bc she doesn't have a place where to live.
adam is struggling to find a job and starts wondering if he should not have dropped out of college. he feels guilty and he know zayneb's family won't accept him if he can't "stand on his two feet".
amidst these different stressful situations adam's dad intervenes and proposes they should both make umrah. adam thinks it's a great idea, a good oportunity to literally pray for a job. but zayneb is not feeling really in the mood for that journey so she basically goes to umrah for adam and not herself.
however this journey helps both of them to realize things about themselves and by the end of their umrah they feel like they have changed and maybe life is smiling at them.
not only it was interesting to read about them, their introspection and realizations but it was really nice to read about the setting. i feel like it's a great book to learn more about the umrah, even if you're muslim. for example, i am a muslim myself but i had no idea of some things such as the distance between safa and marwa or the order of the things you have to do.
going back to some things i did not really like,
then there's the resolution of the miscommunication. i feel like the conflict lasted way too long to fix it in less than one page. i get the adam and zayneb love each other. a lot. but i feel like they should have talked about the situation better and be completely open with each other. im guessing it partly happened off camera but idk, the make up stage just felt super rushed :/
but yeah, despite that, this was cute and realistic and it hit so close to my faith. i truly enjoyed reading it and i recommend it, specially if you're muslim <3
ps: i need to get this out, im sorry, lmao. i excluded it from the main review bc it's not something involving the plot or writing, but the audiobook. i was listening to it while reading, in order to focus better. and the narrators were amazing, of course! now i can't imagine the MCs' voices sounding any other way. i noticed they hired a brown and an asian narrator which is cool. but... i just wish they knew how to speak arabic lmfao.
like im sorry but everytime there was an expression in arabic, specially the girl, struggled to pronounce the words and ngl it kinda hurt to listen, lmao. like, the "labbaik allahuma labbaik" dhikr always makes me tear up. but in this audiobook it was just awful to listen to, im sorry
Content Warnings
Graphic: Vomit and Medical content
Moderate: Chronic illness, Death, Xenophobia, Islamophobia, and Death of parent
Minor: Antisemitism