ramonamead's review against another edition
2.0
The premise is interesting but I found it totally meh.
jc_wb's review against another edition
adventurous
inspiring
lighthearted
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
Second time reading this. I still love it! I was re-reading it before considering donating it, but I think it's one to keep.
Having read the other reviews, I think it's unfair to call it a superhero comic and then claim it's rubbish.
It's about a woman dealing with her life and a creepy guy at her office who wants her job, with the added complication of having powers and a responsibility to use them for good. I like that she has "IBS" as a cover story and that sometimes she really can't be bothered so goes crime fighting in sweatpants. Who hasn't got up for work one day and thought "urgh, I can't be arsed to deal with all the faff of professional clothes. I just want to be comfortable"?
To me, it's more a story of juggling all the parts of your life than a 'superhero' story.
Having read the other reviews, I think it's unfair to call it a superhero comic and then claim it's rubbish.
It's about a woman dealing with her life and a creepy guy at her office who wants her job, with the added complication of having powers and a responsibility to use them for good. I like that she has "IBS" as a cover story and that sometimes she really can't be bothered so goes crime fighting in sweatpants. Who hasn't got up for work one day and thought "urgh, I can't be arsed to deal with all the faff of professional clothes. I just want to be comfortable"?
To me, it's more a story of juggling all the parts of your life than a 'superhero' story.
chrisvigilante's review against another edition
4.0
This was a really fun graphic novel. Borrowed it from a friend and I definitely see why they like it so much. Amy is a superhero. Her regular life isn't so super and having to run off in the middle of important meetings and events cause all kinds of problems for her. Usually problems. Especially at work where she has to deal with the coworker from hell. I hated that guy. I love3d see9ing Starling stand up for herself as a hero and as a business woman in this graphic novel. She did not mess around and still almost gets derailed in a workplace. It really makes you think.
Loved the romance Arc in the story. Don't love Amy being hung up on a guy from her past or even contemplating going after a guy who has a girlfriend. I do like that there was a love what comes out of that plotline by the end. Women supporting women instead of competing is always great.
Starlings parents might actually be the worst. How can they be so oblivious? Starling shouldn't have to do all she does for her brother. If the parents were more attentive he would not have ended up where he is at the point of this comic.
Matt would be an awesome sidekick. He should really get a mask, though. Otherwise, everyone is going to know who Starling is in no time. Honestly really liked his character. That surprised me.
Great Graphic novel.
Loved the romance Arc in the story. Don't love Amy being hung up on a guy from her past or even contemplating going after a guy who has a girlfriend. I do like that there was a love what comes out of that plotline by the end. Women supporting women instead of competing is always great.
Starlings parents might actually be the worst. How can they be so oblivious? Starling shouldn't have to do all she does for her brother. If the parents were more attentive he would not have ended up where he is at the point of this comic.
Matt would be an awesome sidekick. He should really get a mask, though. Otherwise, everyone is going to know who Starling is in no time. Honestly really liked his character. That surprised me.
Great Graphic novel.
doulicia's review against another edition
1.0
I feel very mean writing this, but this just felt amateurish. Everyone's a stereotype and the protagonist's lack of a backbone was really frustrating.
rhodered's review
4.0
Totally enjoyable. I think some critics were way-the-f overthinking things. I love the reality of the office politics, the idiocy of the superhero organization (no pay and a 12 year old boy designs women's outfits to show maximum boob), the reality of juggling real life with superhero life and how the world tries to shame you that one time you wear sweatpants and no makeup outside (a uniquely feminine shame- male superheroes don't put on mascara before they save the day).
And ok yeah there's stuff about being single in the city, being a loving sister, and meeting the guy of your dreams. Can't beat that.
And ok yeah there's stuff about being single in the city, being a loving sister, and meeting the guy of your dreams. Can't beat that.
More...