Reviews

El Simbolo Perdido by Dan Brown

healtopalm's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

A quick-paced listen that fit the bill while I was knitting on the beach.

morguebooks's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous challenging dark informative mysterious tense medium-paced

4.0

simonrtaylor's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

The world’s unluckiest professor, Robert Langdon, is dragged into another game of cat-and-mouse, aided by a glamorous assistant yet again.

His highly revered mentor Peter Solomon (whose previous credits include being Jacques Sauniere in The Da Vinci Code) is kidnapped by a religious psychopath calling himself Mal’akh (previously known as Silas in The Da Vinci Code). Langdon must decipher the Lost Mysteries (previously the Holy Grail) in a race against time, with the help of the victim’s female relative Katherine Solomon (Sophie Neveu, The Da Vinci Code) and veteran wise guy Warren Bellamy (Sir Leigh Teabing, The Da Vinci Code). Opposing his progress is legal eagle Director Inueto Sato (Captain Benzu Fache, The Da Vinci Code) and a bunch of Masons (Priory of Sion, The [you guessed it] Da Vinci Code).

Now, although there are arguably a couple of tiny parallels between The Lost Symbol and some other phenomenally successful novel with exactly the same characters and plot by the same author, the question is: Is it good? The answer is: yes.

Granted, it lacks originality like the desert lacks rain, but Brown readers know exactly what they’re getting when they pick up his novels. Where The Da Vinci Code was a vehicle to explore the murky past of Christianity, The Lost Symbol was both written and read as a way to examine the enigmatic rituals and heritage of the Masons. The plot – weak as tea without a teabag – is merely a backdrop to enable this examination to be presented in an entertaining way.

The snippets, facts and ominous questions posed by the characters is incredibly interesting reading, and at times challenges the reader’s world view. Although the book has come in for some criticism for being “textbook” or overly factual, to those who find the subject matter intriguing, it’s layer upon layer of intrigue. Where Langdon is an expert, Brown obviously isn’t. His understanding of the Masons is naïve and interpretations of Biblical expository are flawed. Despite his disclaimer that everything described is “real”, the reader should expect questions, not answers, from Brown and bear in mind that Brown’s work is fiction, with far more conjecture and hypothesis than is implied. Langdon’s air of expertise and wisdom is, of course, pretend.

Having said that, the plot dives right in and holds interest from the outset. Brown uses short chapters to break the action up, which at times feels like superfluous partitioning of a single scene, however in the main it runs smoothly. There is a significant development for Langdon’s character towards the end which is absolutely unexpected and relatively well handled afterwards, though neither Langdon, Katherine or Peter Solomon appear to be impacted by the gruelling evening they’ve had.

In terms of the resolution, the final “twist” for the villainous Mal’akh is terribly predictable and his personal denouement is bizarrely rushed and insignificant given how much Brown has built up his part through the whole escapade. His final moments, and their aftermath, should have been developed further. Sato – a less pivotal character – has a much stronger entrance, exit and overall presence and is actually one of The Lost Symbol’s hidden gems. The identification of the so-called Ancient Mysteries was also a let-down, being far more predictable and less ingenious than the clues which led up to it. The decryption of the Pyramid and solving of the various levels of enigma to reach that point were diversely intelligent, making the final solution weak, contrived and inconsequential. The ramifications of the “mysteries” had been so widely explored as a general recurring theme throughout the entire novel that there was nothing new or shocking in their discovery. If Brown had kept those cards to his chest until the final reveal, perhaps it would have been more significant. Overall, the ending dragged on far longer than was required. Long after the plot was concluded, a philosophical discussion continued for chapters beyond, adding nothing except boredom.

The Lost Symbol is an enjoying and intriguing story, touching on unusual themes. It keeps good pace for much of the novel and scratches the surface of some genuine enigmas. The plot and characterisations are moderate, and the ending is weak. All in, Langdon’s night probably just lasted longer than either he or the reader particularly hoped it would.

julietteplace's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

it was not bad but so unnecessary. out of the first 3, this one is definitely the worst.

maria_pulver's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

I'm not entirely sure what to say about this book. When I've read [b:The Da Vinci Code|968|The Da Vinci Code (Robert Langdon, #2)|Dan Brown|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1303252999s/968.jpg|2982101] I really enjoyed the book. There was a fascinating story, a good mystery twist and a quick pace that kept me entrapped. True, the book was not an outstanding masterpiece, but still it was a very good reading material.
This one, however, made me feel like a boring repetition. I did finish it, but didn't enjoy it and felt somewhat cheated.

karenreads1000s's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

I was surprised Mr. Brown had Langdon not believe in Enlightenment and the power of the mind given he is an intellectual and professor. Full of conspiracy theory, but an entertaining read.

wolfdyke's review against another edition

Go to review page

1.0

I don't expect hard-hitting literature full of stunning prose from Dan Brown, but I at least expect something enjoyable. Angels & Demons and The Da Vinci Code may not be amazingly written, but they're fun and engaging. The Lost Symbol bored me to no end.
Despite having a personal investment in this mystery compared to the previous two (his own close friend been kidnapped and tortured), Robert Langdon is far more passive in The Lost Symbol. For the first significant chunk, he's just getting dragged from place to place by other people. This happens in the other two as well, to be clear, but he typically becomes more proactive sooner. In addition, in my opinion at least, he was dumbed down a noticeable amount. It took far longer than it did in the previous two novels for Langdon to decipher each clue, and for every one he would get it wrong the first time and needed heavy hints from someone else to get it right.
The villain twist was clear from very early, making the villain chapters incredibly boring. I can't promise that I didn't skip some of them, as once you guess the stupid twist they're basically pointless.
The entire reasoning behind the CIA's involvement is idiotic and the ending in general is dissatisfying and hard to follow. I literally just read this book but I don't think I could give you a coherent summary of the climax.

lmalda's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

The book was great. For the most part had me on the edge of my seat. The whole book was leading up to this great secret. When the secret was finally told it was more of a letdown. But would still recommend.

heatherday916's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Once again, I found myself thoroughly engrossed in Dan Brown's writing. While I'm not a regular reader of suspense/thriller novels (primarily because I find I can't put them down and get no sleep until I finish them!), I really enjoy the quick pace with which this novel progressed. This book truly satisfied my imagination, with it's rapid scene changes and plot twists. I also enjoyed the added layers of mystery he added with the question of Director Sato and whether she should be trusted, as well as the potential significance of the mystery keyword-rich file on the CIA mainframe (I got a true chuckle out of that one).

I also truly enjoyed the exploration of Noetic Science - I was fascinated to learn that a true branch of science is working to, essentially, quantify aspects of faith.

Angels & Demons remains my favorite of Dan Brown's books, but The Lost Symbol has bumped The DaVinci Code for the #2 spot.

alya201's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

إن العيش دون إدراك معنى العالم هو أشبه بالتجول في مكتبة عظيمة من دون لمس الكتب.