ostrava's review against another edition
5.0
Cassidy and Jesse's friendship needs to be protected at all costs.
The Allfather was a cool character.
Lots of action in this chapter.
The Allfather was a cool character.
Lots of action in this chapter.
some_okie_dude27's review against another edition
5.0
Religion tends to be an easy touch point for satirists, so much so that it becomes dull rather quickly. We get it, religion has some rather silly concepts behind it, so much so that it almost makes fun of itself. With that in mind, I avoided Preacher for a while, fearing it would be another 'fuck religion' polemic disguised as a story (a la His Dark Materials), and while there are the 'fuck religion' moments layered in Preacher from time to time, Ennis never gets too lost in his message and allows his focus to be clear. Religious satire died with Preacher for me, as few others could ever get quite get as madcap, as strange, nor as deviously imaginative as Ennis' opus on religion was, and still very much is.
I sometimes like to jokingly describe Preacher to friends as if Hunter S. Thompson decided to try his hand at writing a comic (without being Transmetropolitan), yet that comparison to too faint for this series. Ennis certainly shares Thompson's love for the demented and the depraved, but the vision that he dishes out for Preacher is purely his own. Ennis' satire is cutting, yet toned down in comparison to some of his other series' (I'm lookin' at you, The Boys), certainly his crass humor can become bothersome at times, but the characterization and the drama of the series are excellent. Many of the characters that are introduced throughout Preacher screams iconoclasm, with so many of them being unforgettable from Jesse to Ruth to Cassidy to The Saint of Killers and Preacher's version of God (who's not a very nice God to put it plainly), Ennis' talent for crafting interesting and well developed characters can sometimes be underrated, with most people focusing on his crass humor and dark intensity that would become landmarks of the series. But many forget the oddly heartfelt story that is told throughout the series
I often point people to this series when people ask me what I find to be a golden standard for long form storytelling, there is never a moment in Preacher that feels like a misstep or a bit that's boring, it's a rare series where everything comes together so beautifully that I'll dare not ruin it for anyone. Despite the plot being very straightforward, much of the intrigue comes from the characters and their personalities, which are based on their history and psychologies, much like how real people form their personalities based on their life experiences. Ennis' keen awareness for characterization and conflicts arising from characters' motivations and desires is the crux of what makes Preacher compelling. Ennis does take his pot shots at religion, yet never tells you what to think and never condescends to the audience, as he can sometimes do. He allows himself to be utterly selfless with his pen and give us a good story, which is all what he could hope for nowadays.
Steve Dillon's art is whole other thing entirely, and while I'm not always fond of his style (his characters often look similar), I find that the way that he and Ennis worked together was almost magical, something Ennis would lament. Ennis and Dillion's creative partnership is one of the great partnerships in comics, with few others being comparable: Stan Lee and Steve Ditko, Ed Brubaker and Sean Phillips, Jeff Lemire and Andrea Sorrentino. Dillon almost pitch perfectly captures the depravity, as well as the heart that lies within Preacher's story. Their influences are clear, from Hellblazer (which was the book that they cut their teeth on State side with Vertigo), to Leone's spaghetti westerns to The Bible, but they bring their influences together in order to make something truly unique and original.
This is a series that I love because of how creatively ugly it is. It is so vile, so tasteless, and so utterly insane that it's hard not to appreciate it. One of the reasons that I found that the AMC show failed is because it didn't share the original comic's sense of vulgarity. It's like if NBC decided to try and make an adaptation of Transmetropolitan, it's vulgarity is a part of the series' charm. Then again I suppose it's fitting, to make something that's so depraved and unpleasant, one would have to tap into something that's also extremely depraved and unpleasant. There's simply nothing else like Preacher.
Preacher is truly a once in a life time series, and Preacher is one of those series' that reminds me why I love comics. While Ennis may focus too much on the sales numbers, I find that Preacher is his magnum opus in terms of artistic merit. Is it high art? No, I don't think so, yet I often look back to a particular satirical fantasist when I'm asked such questions:
"Susan hated literature, she'd much prefer to read a good book."
I sometimes like to jokingly describe Preacher to friends as if Hunter S. Thompson decided to try his hand at writing a comic (without being Transmetropolitan), yet that comparison to too faint for this series. Ennis certainly shares Thompson's love for the demented and the depraved, but the vision that he dishes out for Preacher is purely his own. Ennis' satire is cutting, yet toned down in comparison to some of his other series' (I'm lookin' at you, The Boys), certainly his crass humor can become bothersome at times, but the characterization and the drama of the series are excellent. Many of the characters that are introduced throughout Preacher screams iconoclasm, with so many of them being unforgettable from Jesse to Ruth to Cassidy to The Saint of Killers and Preacher's version of God (who's not a very nice God to put it plainly), Ennis' talent for crafting interesting and well developed characters can sometimes be underrated, with most people focusing on his crass humor and dark intensity that would become landmarks of the series. But many forget the oddly heartfelt story that is told throughout the series
I often point people to this series when people ask me what I find to be a golden standard for long form storytelling, there is never a moment in Preacher that feels like a misstep or a bit that's boring, it's a rare series where everything comes together so beautifully that I'll dare not ruin it for anyone. Despite the plot being very straightforward, much of the intrigue comes from the characters and their personalities, which are based on their history and psychologies, much like how real people form their personalities based on their life experiences. Ennis' keen awareness for characterization and conflicts arising from characters' motivations and desires is the crux of what makes Preacher compelling. Ennis does take his pot shots at religion, yet never tells you what to think and never condescends to the audience, as he can sometimes do. He allows himself to be utterly selfless with his pen and give us a good story, which is all what he could hope for nowadays.
Steve Dillon's art is whole other thing entirely, and while I'm not always fond of his style (his characters often look similar), I find that the way that he and Ennis worked together was almost magical, something Ennis would lament. Ennis and Dillion's creative partnership is one of the great partnerships in comics, with few others being comparable: Stan Lee and Steve Ditko, Ed Brubaker and Sean Phillips, Jeff Lemire and Andrea Sorrentino. Dillon almost pitch perfectly captures the depravity, as well as the heart that lies within Preacher's story. Their influences are clear, from Hellblazer (which was the book that they cut their teeth on State side with Vertigo), to Leone's spaghetti westerns to The Bible, but they bring their influences together in order to make something truly unique and original.
This is a series that I love because of how creatively ugly it is. It is so vile, so tasteless, and so utterly insane that it's hard not to appreciate it. One of the reasons that I found that the AMC show failed is because it didn't share the original comic's sense of vulgarity. It's like if NBC decided to try and make an adaptation of Transmetropolitan, it's vulgarity is a part of the series' charm. Then again I suppose it's fitting, to make something that's so depraved and unpleasant, one would have to tap into something that's also extremely depraved and unpleasant. There's simply nothing else like Preacher.
Preacher is truly a once in a life time series, and Preacher is one of those series' that reminds me why I love comics. While Ennis may focus too much on the sales numbers, I find that Preacher is his magnum opus in terms of artistic merit. Is it high art? No, I don't think so, yet I often look back to a particular satirical fantasist when I'm asked such questions:
"Susan hated literature, she'd much prefer to read a good book."
peter_xxx's review against another edition
4.0
In this volume Cass is kidnapped by a militant religious order and Jesse goes out to rescue him. The saint of killers is tracking Jesse to get his revenge and also ends up in the same place. What follows is off course a bloodbath. We also learn more of Cassidy's past in this volume.
This is still a very good book where gore, horror and dark humor are used to explore some themes like religion, devotion vs self-interest, old school morals in a modern world and the male reflex to shelter women from hurt.
Very good.
This is still a very good book where gore, horror and dark humor are used to explore some themes like religion, devotion vs self-interest, old school morals in a modern world and the male reflex to shelter women from hurt.
Very good.
lookhome's review against another edition
3.0
Kind of a let down after the first two volumes.
I'm still intrigued but some of the mystery is gone and not in a good way.
Don't get me wrong. I still couldn't put it down.
I'm just less aware of why or if I want to continue.
I was hoping for a Sandman story arc filled with interconnected and far flung, long gestating ideas. Instead there's a little bit of sense of groping in the dark.
Still good but not as well developped as expected.
I'm still intrigued but some of the mystery is gone and not in a good way.
Don't get me wrong. I still couldn't put it down.
I'm just less aware of why or if I want to continue.
I was hoping for a Sandman story arc filled with interconnected and far flung, long gestating ideas. Instead there's a little bit of sense of groping in the dark.
Still good but not as well developped as expected.
ria_mhrj's review against another edition
4.0
Another intriguing volume, very curious to see where it goes next. And Tulip's gonna be MAAAAD.
wrath1776's review against another edition
5.0
The third volume of Preacher is exactly what you'd expect. It's absurd, violent, disgusting, and vile happenings carried by a unique story with characters with a lot of potential for depth.
I really liked the backstory for Cassidy and the look inside The Grail.
Overall 5/5 hogs because I love Preacher and this didn't disappoint.
I really liked the backstory for Cassidy and the look inside The Grail.
Overall 5/5 hogs because I love Preacher and this didn't disappoint.
adamz24's review against another edition
3.0
The Crusaders arc makes up the bulk of this collection, and it's fine. God has one absolutely hysterically funny panel, wherein He's an even bigger prick than in his previous appearance.
The other three issues are better. The first has more background on Jesse's dad, and the last two detail Cassidy's becoming a vampire and his immigration to the US, with emphasis on his relationship to NYC. These issues are lyrical and pretty at times, and that's almost always what gets me about Preacher, is how really human and even elegiac it can be despite the constant barrage of absurdly OTT violence and sex and foul language and blasphemy and all that good stuff.
The other three issues are better. The first has more background on Jesse's dad, and the last two detail Cassidy's becoming a vampire and his immigration to the US, with emphasis on his relationship to NYC. These issues are lyrical and pretty at times, and that's almost always what gets me about Preacher, is how really human and even elegiac it can be despite the constant barrage of absurdly OTT violence and sex and foul language and blasphemy and all that good stuff.