annashuk's review
2.0
Finally finished this. Don't really know why it took me so long.
This graphic novel will be useful for refreshing your memories of prequel without having to re-watch them, because this is exactly what happens in movies, short scene after short scene.
What bothered me: art style - while background looked great, I didn't like the way some of the characters where drawn;
and also, wasn't a big fan of the jumpy way the story was told. On one hand, it helps the narrative to move faster (but it didn't help me to finish it faster :/), but that constant switch between scenes, sometimes 3 times on one page, was too much in places.
What I liked: the fullness of it, you really just have to read this to refresh your memories of the events happening in prequels. And I needed a little reminder before I continue reading other canon comics.
Overall, not bad, but you probably won't find anything new here, if you're a fan.
This graphic novel will be useful for refreshing your memories of prequel without having to re-watch them, because this is exactly what happens in movies, short scene after short scene.
What bothered me: art style - while background looked great, I didn't like the way some of the characters where drawn;
and also, wasn't a big fan of the jumpy way the story was told. On one hand, it helps the narrative to move faster (but it didn't help me to finish it faster :/), but that constant switch between scenes, sometimes 3 times on one page, was too much in places.
What I liked: the fullness of it, you really just have to read this to refresh your memories of the events happening in prequels. And I needed a little reminder before I continue reading other canon comics.
Overall, not bad, but you probably won't find anything new here, if you're a fan.
joyfullyjacquie's review
5.0
I’m a huge fan of the art in this graphic novel and it’s a super fun compilation of all 3 of the prequel movies! I highly recommend this if you love Star Wars and need something different in your reading routine.
wanderlustlover's review
2.0
Spring 2020 (March Live Read);
Let's all be honest up front. There'll be nothing new in here for me, but I'm doing it anyway, both because I'm going to read every single new canon comic out so far, and to see if I need to icon Padmé pieces from this one, too.
This art....is not great so far. || Hers is not good, and Anakin's is spectacularly bad. || That was a thing I just did with my life, that was such an example of bad art. || Yes. >_> I still pulled like 25 screenshots off it, too.
Let's all be honest up front. There'll be nothing new in here for me, but I'm doing it anyway, both because I'm going to read every single new canon comic out so far, and to see if I need to icon Padmé pieces from this one, too.
This art....is not great so far. || Hers is not good, and Anakin's is spectacularly bad. || That was a thing I just did with my life, that was such an example of bad art. || Yes. >_> I still pulled like 25 screenshots off it, too.
jbrooxd's review
4.0
No surprises in the stories - follows the movies closely though not word for word. The art is the draw, though. I loved it.
More...