thepolybrary's review against another edition
5.0
~*Follow all my reviews over on my blog, The Bent Bookworm!*~
I was excited to read Last of the Name, being of partial descent from Irish immigrants myself. It’s not a topic I’ve often seen covered for this age group, and I was thrilled to see it done so well.
Last of the Name is a middle-grade book about the arrival of Irish immigrants to the United States during the time of the Civil War. 12-year-old Danny has lost everyone dear to him except for his sister Kathleen, either to war, famine (by hunger or in attempts to steal enough food for their family to survive), or the crossing to America. He rebels at dressing as a girl to be a maid alongside Kathleen, but since it seems their only hope of staying together and surviving in the bitter, angry stew that was New York City in 1863, he goes along with his sister’s plan.
Despite his complaining, it’s clear Danny dearly loves his sister and will do anything for her. As the city grows more and more hateful, both towards free blacks and the Irish (coming to steal jobs, naturally), it becomes almost as dangerous for them as it was at home – except here, people appreciate Danny’s voice and his dancing feet, which maybe – just maybe – might be the key to their survival in New York City. But when the draft is initiated and the Irish immigrants of the city bear the brunt of it (so much for random!), the whole city looks to go up in flames.
I’m not going to lie, I teared up several times reading this story – and I’m not even sure why! It just felt so poignantly REAL. Danny was adorable and I loved Kathleen’s fire and backbone.
As is historically accurate, Danny and Kathleen’s Catholic faith does play a part in the story – but never in a proselytizing way. The story really shows how much conflict was in the United States at this time, not only around color, but around religion, politics, even denominations. It’s rather disheartening to see that we’ve never really moved on, the names of the different factions have just changed. Despite all that, the story is one of beauty and hope and I’ll be adding it to my own library.
5/5 stars. Highly recommend, and it REALLY needs much more attention than it’s getting!
Many thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for an ARC in exchange for an honest review!
Blog | Twitter | Bloglovin | Instagram |
“Always remember who ye are,” Granny says. “Descended of the great bards of old. Honord by princes near and far they were. Sought out for music and for counsel. Keepers of history. Writers of songs.”
I was excited to read Last of the Name, being of partial descent from Irish immigrants myself. It’s not a topic I’ve often seen covered for this age group, and I was thrilled to see it done so well.
Last of the Name is a middle-grade book about the arrival of Irish immigrants to the United States during the time of the Civil War. 12-year-old Danny has lost everyone dear to him except for his sister Kathleen, either to war, famine (by hunger or in attempts to steal enough food for their family to survive), or the crossing to America. He rebels at dressing as a girl to be a maid alongside Kathleen, but since it seems their only hope of staying together and surviving in the bitter, angry stew that was New York City in 1863, he goes along with his sister’s plan.
Kathleen is the sort of believer who believes more the less evidence there is. She could be on her knees for days on end. I’m going to die of hunger while she prays to save me from a bountiful future…If only there was a patron saint of those afflicted by tyrannical sisters there’d be hope for me.
Despite his complaining, it’s clear Danny dearly loves his sister and will do anything for her. As the city grows more and more hateful, both towards free blacks and the Irish (coming to steal jobs, naturally), it becomes almost as dangerous for them as it was at home – except here, people appreciate Danny’s voice and his dancing feet, which maybe – just maybe – might be the key to their survival in New York City. But when the draft is initiated and the Irish immigrants of the city bear the brunt of it (so much for random!), the whole city looks to go up in flames.
I’m not going to lie, I teared up several times reading this story – and I’m not even sure why! It just felt so poignantly REAL. Danny was adorable and I loved Kathleen’s fire and backbone.
“You Irish,” says another [man], just as stern. “It’s your own out there doing the lynching and the burning. What do you have to fear from your own?”
“You fat old men!” Kathleen shrieks. “What do you know of fear, you with your broad shoulders and your full plates! We have to fear what every woman fears her whole life long. Ye heartless men! When have you ever been small or hungry? Would you send a German child out on the streets this night? Aren’t we Catholic like you? Don’t we sit side by side in church?”
As is historically accurate, Danny and Kathleen’s Catholic faith does play a part in the story – but never in a proselytizing way. The story really shows how much conflict was in the United States at this time, not only around color, but around religion, politics, even denominations. It’s rather disheartening to see that we’ve never really moved on, the names of the different factions have just changed. Despite all that, the story is one of beauty and hope and I’ll be adding it to my own library.
5/5 stars. Highly recommend, and it REALLY needs much more attention than it’s getting!
Many thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for an ARC in exchange for an honest review!
Blog | Twitter | Bloglovin | Instagram |
chocolateparis's review against another edition
5.0
So enjoyable to read, such an interesting background, as well....
raoionna's review against another edition
3.0
Poignant ~ Wrenching ~ Surprising
tl; dr: Irish teen arrives in New York City in the middle of the Civil War to see a country broken and to feel prejudice.
The middle school level book was a well-written story about the Irish during the Civil War. Danny and his sister Kathleen feel the prejudice of the era against Catholics and Irish and survive (barely) to have a happy ending. The prose is well-written and the story is compelling (stressful at times). I found details, like the types of food they ate or the surrounds in NYC were well-done. Ideal for any middle schooler whose family has a similar heritage.
Thanks to NetGallery for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
tl; dr: Irish teen arrives in New York City in the middle of the Civil War to see a country broken and to feel prejudice.
The middle school level book was a well-written story about the Irish during the Civil War. Danny and his sister Kathleen feel the prejudice of the era against Catholics and Irish and survive (barely) to have a happy ending. The prose is well-written and the story is compelling (stressful at times). I found details, like the types of food they ate or the surrounds in NYC were well-done. Ideal for any middle schooler whose family has a similar heritage.
Thanks to NetGallery for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
cweichel's review against another edition
4.0
Daniel and his older sister, Kathleen, immigrate to New York during the time of the civil war. The destitute pair manage to find work in a fine house, but Daniel has to be disguised as a girl. In a bargain with one of their neighbours, he gets to be himself for a few hours a week doing her shopping while she takes on his laundry duties. While he is out he discovers his singing and dancing can earn him some money. Then he is noticed by someone planning on setting up a family theatre. He wishes he could take the man up on his offer, but knows Kathleen will have nothing to do with it. Everything changes when the New York City draft riots erupt.
adrianab's review against another edition
5.0
It is a great historical fiction about Irish immigrants, a touching story.
Thanks to Netgalley and the Publisher for this nice copy.
Thanks to Netgalley and the Publisher for this nice copy.
ejderwood's review
5.0
SO well written and honestly I learned so much about the Irish Revolt and the rest of this area in this period of history that I didn't know before. I knew there was a lot of prejudice about Irish people but I hadn't realised it was That bad.
Plus, I love the flipping of the usual 'girl disguises herself as a boy' trope.
Plus, I love the flipping of the usual 'girl disguises herself as a boy' trope.
More...