Reviews

Hollow Fields, Vol. 3 by Madeleine Rosca

reddjena's review

Go to review page

5.0

We finally learned what the personal project was and Bleak's backstory as well as what the Windmill is all about. I was quite satisfied with the conclusion to this story even though there were several loose threads. And the colored art continued to be gorgeous!

kailey_luminouslibro's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

A good conclusion to the series! I was surprised by the mysteries and thoroughly entertained through the whole story. Definitely a fun read!

bhavani's review

Go to review page

4.0

A fun graphic novel set in an interesting world. If I found physical copies, I'd be sure to add them to my collection. There are spoilers in the review below.

While reading Volume 2, I had a few questions and they are as follows.

1) What is Miss Weaver's personal experiment? Is it to somehow transfer their consciousness into the bodies of Hollow Fields' students and ensure their immortality?
Answer: Yes

2) Who is Doctor Bleak and why is he in the form of a mechanical cube?
Answer: This one took me by surprise. Never expected him to be her supposedly dead husband. She's evil for sure. Based on rough calculations, over 80 years, they'd have turned at least 4,160 children into test subjects. But he's such a patronizing jerk in the flashback scenes that a small part of me thought it's justified for him to spend the rest of his life as a sentient, mechanical cube.

3) Why is it always raining around Hollow Fields and does it have anything to do with Miss Weaver's experiment?
Answer: Never got the answer to this one. Maybe it's just the weather in the area around Hollow Fields?

4) How are the engineers still alive using clockwork mechanics after all this time?
Answer: All the engineers, except one, didn't survive using clockwork engines. Theirs were steam engines. But I'm not sure how. Did they replace their organs and circulatory systems with engines and mechanical components? Is that why they couldn't digest food anymore? Why didn't they have sensations? Did they replace their nerves with wiring? But if so, wouldn't they have to replace their brain as well? How is it that they could still rot? I don't have the answer to these questions.
More...