Scan barcode
atsumeri's review against another edition
adventurous
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.25
rinyurg's review against another edition
5.0
I LOVED this book!
I love anything western, but this was western with a twist, and in such a good way. Even if you aren’t looking for a book set in a western setting, if you’re a fan of fantasy I would still highly recommend.
I loved the characters so much. Mary Good Crow? Would literally die for her. Josie? Would slay an entire army. Rell? I would buy her a few years worth of therapy and give her a hug. Maybe also get her an exorcism.
The magic and necromancy was such a fun and different feel than anything I’ve read in a long time. I cannot wait to see where the story goes in the next book.
I love anything western, but this was western with a twist, and in such a good way. Even if you aren’t looking for a book set in a western setting, if you’re a fan of fantasy I would still highly recommend.
I loved the characters so much. Mary Good Crow? Would literally die for her. Josie? Would slay an entire army. Rell? I would buy her a few years worth of therapy and give her a hug. Maybe also get her an exorcism.
The magic and necromancy was such a fun and different feel than anything I’ve read in a long time. I cannot wait to see where the story goes in the next book.
trufyre's review
adventurous
emotional
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.25
lib_britannia's review
adventurous
funny
hopeful
lighthearted
mysterious
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
jvilches's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
cricklewood's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
dark
emotional
hopeful
lighthearted
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.5
Setting/Worldbuilding: 8/10
Main characters: 9/10
Side characters: 9/10
Dialogue: 8/10
Plot: 9/10
Technique: 9/10
Prose: 9/10
Romance: N/A/10
Ending: 9/10
Overall enjoyment: 10/10
Total: 80/90 (4.44)
I’m almost tired of saying it now but YET AGAIN we have another absolutely amazing series from Rachel Aaron, who has long solidified herself as my favourite author by this point.
She knows how to plot, she knows how to create sympathetic characters, she knows how to worldbuild, she knows how to entertain and my golly she knows how to write magic. And by that I don’t just mean her writing is magically good; I mean that she has a particular way of weaving words into her magic that her magic systems feel nothing short of wondrous.
The thing about Rachel is that she obviously writes with very well-used tropes in her head in a way that lends a certain identifiable flavour in her works that pulls her fans together no matter what genre she decides to dabble in. Here we have her writing an alternate history Western fantasy with music-based magic (what now?) but as Rachel fans we see all the elements that make her works what they are: scheming villainous power-hungry parents, found family vibes, epic (in scale and feel) worldbuilding, a distinctly lighter tone in writing, soul possession, serious creationist theories, strong, sympathetic characters and a whacky magic system.
The Last Stand of Mary Good Crow fits into her repertoire so seamlessly you might almost forget that it was in a whole different genre altogether. I can see a lot of people being put off by the contents of this work though. There is a lot of casual and socially accepted racism at the time that, combined with the slightly irreverent tone of her writing, may see a little disrespectful to some. And for a historical western, her prose has a distinctly modern and fresh feel that may strike history purists as anachronistic.
But if you’re a Rachel Aaron fan, I would recommend you check this out. And meanwhile, I’ll hang around with Rel, Josie and Mary Good Crow and be part of their adventure a little longer.
Main characters: 9/10
Side characters: 9/10
Dialogue: 8/10
Plot: 9/10
Technique: 9/10
Prose: 9/10
Romance: N/A/10
Ending: 9/10
Overall enjoyment: 10/10
Total: 80/90 (4.44)
I’m almost tired of saying it now but YET AGAIN we have another absolutely amazing series from Rachel Aaron, who has long solidified herself as my favourite author by this point.
She knows how to plot, she knows how to create sympathetic characters, she knows how to worldbuild, she knows how to entertain and my golly she knows how to write magic. And by that I don’t just mean her writing is magically good; I mean that she has a particular way of weaving words into her magic that her magic systems feel nothing short of wondrous.
The thing about Rachel is that she obviously writes with very well-used tropes in her head in a way that lends a certain identifiable flavour in her works that pulls her fans together no matter what genre she decides to dabble in. Here we have her writing an alternate history Western fantasy with music-based magic (what now?) but as Rachel fans we see all the elements that make her works what they are: scheming villainous power-hungry parents, found family vibes, epic (in scale and feel) worldbuilding, a distinctly lighter tone in writing, soul possession, serious creationist theories, strong, sympathetic characters and a whacky magic system.
The Last Stand of Mary Good Crow fits into her repertoire so seamlessly you might almost forget that it was in a whole different genre altogether. I can see a lot of people being put off by the contents of this work though. There is a lot of casual and socially accepted racism at the time that, combined with the slightly irreverent tone of her writing, may see a little disrespectful to some. And for a historical western, her prose has a distinctly modern and fresh feel that may strike history purists as anachronistic.
But if you’re a Rachel Aaron fan, I would recommend you check this out. And meanwhile, I’ll hang around with Rel, Josie and Mary Good Crow and be part of their adventure a little longer.
the_wanlorn's review
adventurous
lighthearted
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
There was absolutely no Lord of the Rings in this, contrary to what it was sold as. But it was still pretty good. I enjoyed the cave bits. Love caving bits in books.
bloggingwithdragons's review against another edition
4.0
As I’ve said time and time again, author Rachel Aaron is one of my favorites. She’s on my very short list of authors that I pre-order books for and is always the one I turn to when I need a fun read, as her books never fail to serve as pick-me-up. Despite how much I love the author’s work, I was a little hesitant to pick up The Last Stand of Mary Good Crow as westerns really aren’t my thing. But I needn’t have worried, as like all of Aaron’s books, The Last Stand of Mary Good Crow is a unique and fun ride with lovable characters and interesting world building.
I really enjoyed that The Last Stand of Mary Good Crow follows three female characters with very different lifestyles, who wind up in the mining town of Medicine Rocks. Mary Good Crow herself can hear the magic crystals growing in the caves and serves as tour guide into the dangerous mines, though it’s quite risky for her as not only a woman, but also as a half Native American in the late 1800s. Mary is hired on by Josephine “Josie” Price, the sheltered but whip smart heir to a mining fortune, and a notorious gun-for-hire known as Rel, who is also Josie’s childhood friend. There is more to each of these characters than meets the eye, but they manage to form a fast friendship in the face of the dangers of the mine and the challenges of the time period they live in.
Living in the west during the crystal—not gold—rush in a mining town is anything but safe for any woman. It’s especially dangerous for Mary, as racism against Native Americans is at an all time high. Not able to pass for white, and raised by French nuns (the French also aren’t cared for much), Mary lives in the caves, with only the sound of the crystals for companionship, until Josie and Rel come along. Even venturing into town and trying to buy food is enough to get the poor girl shot at it. Josie, despite appearing to be living the high life that comes with money, is very sympathetic to both Mary, and her friend Rel.
The friendship between these three unlikely characters is really endearing to me. Though Mary wants to save the crystals from being strip-mined and destroyed, she still honors her agreement with Josie. And though Rel has more motivation to help his childhood friend than meets the eye, he still manages to keep them all safe. Likewise, Josie Price, who wants to make a fortune off of the crystals, thinks of the pain it will cause her new crystal-loving friend Mary. I immediately was very interested in Josie, who seems very unlike other heiresses to fortunes. And it turns out, there’s a reason for that, which I won’t spoil here, but I wondered at how easily the woman was able to pull off everything she does.
I was really afraid I’d be bored reading a Western, but The Last Stand of Mary Good Crow is continually exciting what with its mysteries surrounding the backgrounds and abilities of the characters combined with the strange magic of the crystals and the dangerous and otherworldly caves they reside in, as well as the appearances of historical figures like General Custer. It doesn’t hurt that I can’t help but find the crystals and their magical properties very interesting. In this world, crystals, not gold or silver or cash, are the most lucrative item in existence, and for good reason. People are just discovering all of the possibilities of these items—ingesting them to speak with the dead, to shoot faster or to gain other super powers, or surgically implanting them as rods to save lives, and forging them into stronger weapons.
To the horror of the military stationed at Medicine Rock, the Lakota have been spotted with crystal enhanced arrows and other types of weapons, adding a military fervor in the background of everything else going on in The Last Stand of Mary Good Crow. Though reading through the viewpoint of Lucas, a higher up in the military, was by far the least interesting out of all the perspectives to me, the character is poised to detail the growing tension and hysteria in the armed forces. If the military weren’t stressed enough by their inability to meet their crystal quota and by the fall of General Custer and his forces at Little Bighorn to the Lakota, there’s rumors that the Native Americans have a way of growing crystal, rather than ripping it through the walls and irreparably damaging it like Americans. Throughout the entirety of The Last Stand of Mary Good Crow runs the themes of greed, bigotry, environmental concerns, and manifest destiny.
Plus, there might just be more to the singing of the crystals that Mary hears. And the caves where the crystals grow are anything but typical. There’s an area known as the Dark, which makes it impossible to see or hear anything, and it moves. The rest of the caves seem to never open to the same area twice, and there’s mysterious entities both haunting the caves, sometimes even sabotaging miners hunting for a profit, as well as bandits lurking to steal what others try to haul back to the surface. It’s an entirely different universe in the caves down there, and utterly cool to me that Mary Good Crow has managed to become so at home in such a dark and dangerous place.
In every way, the world of The Last Stand of Mary Good Crow is so fascinating and unique, very much like all of the other worlds in author Rachel Aaron’s works. Honestly, I feel pretty silly that I even worried that anything this author had written might not appeal to me, or could ever be boring. I will be purchasing any follow ups to The Last Stand of Mary Good Crow on day one for sure. If you like westerns, alternate history, fantasy, or very unique world-building and magical systems, as well as complex characters, I would highly recommend this novel to you.
“Medicine Rocks is no place for honest men, and speaking frankly, miss, I don’t think you should stay here either. I know this is your inheritance, but between the redskins taking scalps and the bandits taking everything else, this town’s a death sentence waiting to happen. I’m not presuming to tell you your business, but we’d be more than happy to take you back with us to Helena if you want.”
I really enjoyed that The Last Stand of Mary Good Crow follows three female characters with very different lifestyles, who wind up in the mining town of Medicine Rocks. Mary Good Crow herself can hear the magic crystals growing in the caves and serves as tour guide into the dangerous mines, though it’s quite risky for her as not only a woman, but also as a half Native American in the late 1800s. Mary is hired on by Josephine “Josie” Price, the sheltered but whip smart heir to a mining fortune, and a notorious gun-for-hire known as Rel, who is also Josie’s childhood friend
Spoiler
and a woman in disguise. I was quite confused by the character's gender identity at first, as the pronouns for this character just kept switching without any explanations, depending on who was narrating.Living in the west during the crystal—not gold—rush in a mining town is anything but safe for any woman. It’s especially dangerous for Mary, as racism against Native Americans is at an all time high. Not able to pass for white, and raised by French nuns (the French also aren’t cared for much), Mary lives in the caves, with only the sound of the crystals for companionship, until Josie and Rel come along. Even venturing into town and trying to buy food is enough to get the poor girl shot at it. Josie, despite appearing to be living the high life that comes with money, is very sympathetic to both Mary, and her friend Rel.
The friendship between these three unlikely characters is really endearing to me. Though Mary wants to save the crystals from being strip-mined and destroyed, she still honors her agreement with Josie. And though Rel has more motivation to help his childhood friend than meets the eye, he still manages to keep them all safe. Likewise, Josie Price, who wants to make a fortune off of the crystals, thinks of the pain it will cause her new crystal-loving friend Mary. I immediately was very interested in Josie, who seems very unlike other heiresses to fortunes. And it turns out, there’s a reason for that, which I won’t spoil here, but I wondered at how easily the woman was able to pull off everything she does.
I was really afraid I’d be bored reading a Western, but The Last Stand of Mary Good Crow is continually exciting what with its mysteries surrounding the backgrounds and abilities of the characters combined with the strange magic of the crystals and the dangerous and otherworldly caves they reside in, as well as the appearances of historical figures like General Custer. It doesn’t hurt that I can’t help but find the crystals and their magical properties very interesting. In this world, crystals, not gold or silver or cash, are the most lucrative item in existence, and for good reason. People are just discovering all of the possibilities of these items—ingesting them to speak with the dead, to shoot faster or to gain other super powers, or surgically implanting them as rods to save lives, and forging them into stronger weapons.
To the horror of the military stationed at Medicine Rock, the Lakota have been spotted with crystal enhanced arrows and other types of weapons, adding a military fervor in the background of everything else going on in The Last Stand of Mary Good Crow. Though reading through the viewpoint of Lucas, a higher up in the military, was by far the least interesting out of all the perspectives to me, the character is poised to detail the growing tension and hysteria in the armed forces. If the military weren’t stressed enough by their inability to meet their crystal quota and by the fall of General Custer and his forces at Little Bighorn to the Lakota, there’s rumors that the Native Americans have a way of growing crystal, rather than ripping it through the walls and irreparably damaging it like Americans. Throughout the entirety of The Last Stand of Mary Good Crow runs the themes of greed, bigotry, environmental concerns, and manifest destiny.
“Imagine discovering the most valuable new resource of the century and then ruining the whole thing through your own incompetence?”
“Never underestimate the potency of ignorance mixed with greed,” Rel said, walking through the crack folks had hammered through the rear of the ruined cavern to keep the crystal search going.
Plus, there might just be more to the singing of the crystals that Mary hears. And the caves where the crystals grow are anything but typical. There’s an area known as the Dark, which makes it impossible to see or hear anything, and it moves. The rest of the caves seem to never open to the same area twice, and there’s mysterious entities both haunting the caves, sometimes even sabotaging miners hunting for a profit, as well as bandits lurking to steal what others try to haul back to the surface. It’s an entirely different universe in the caves down there, and utterly cool to me that Mary Good Crow has managed to become so at home in such a dark and dangerous place.
In every way, the world of The Last Stand of Mary Good Crow is so fascinating and unique, very much like all of the other worlds in author Rachel Aaron’s works. Honestly, I feel pretty silly that I even worried that anything this author had written might not appeal to me, or could ever be boring. I will be purchasing any follow ups to The Last Stand of Mary Good Crow on day one for sure. If you like westerns, alternate history, fantasy, or very unique world-building and magical systems, as well as complex characters, I would highly recommend this novel to you.
Connect with Me:
bloggingwithdragons.com
My Book Review Policy
| instagram | tumblr | twitter |pinterest | facebook | email |
jdhobbes's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
emotional
mysterious
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.5
bory's review against another edition
5.0
I love everything about this book. I've been struggling with a fantasy reading slump ever since I read Legacy of Steel earlier this year, and The Last Stand of Mary Good Crow has put back a little "oomph" back into my reading mojo.
The magic system is weird, and unique-ish. In some ways, it reminded me of Sanderson's mist born, in that ingesting crystal gives you powers, though what they are and how they work is not nearly as well-defined as in Mistborn. A drawback of the soft magic system approach.
The Western Frontier setting is not my favorite, honestly, but it works here. In what other context would a rush to mine crystal work?
The characters are well-written, compelling, and relatable. Mary and Josie, in particular, are great both for their strengths and their weaknesses. Even Rel, whom I think is the most unlikable of the three principle protagonists, I found myself understanding and sympathizing with, even if in her circumstances I would have taken different actions.
If there's one thing I take issue with is that the book ends, kind of, not on one but on multiple cliffhangers. Talk about your metaphorical blue balls. I can't wait for the next installment.
The magic system is weird, and unique-ish. In some ways, it reminded me of Sanderson's mist born, in that ingesting crystal gives you powers, though what they are and how they work is not nearly as well-defined as in Mistborn. A drawback of the soft magic system approach.
The Western Frontier setting is not my favorite, honestly, but it works here. In what other context would a rush to mine crystal work?
The characters are well-written, compelling, and relatable. Mary and Josie, in particular, are great both for their strengths and their weaknesses. Even Rel, whom I think is the most unlikable of the three principle protagonists, I found myself understanding and sympathizing with, even if in her circumstances I would have taken different actions.
If there's one thing I take issue with is that the book ends, kind of, not on one but on multiple cliffhangers. Talk about your metaphorical blue balls. I can't wait for the next installment.