jonmhansen's review
3.0
Not as successful as Last Son of Krypton, but a still reasonable Silver Age Superman story (with all the accompanying Silver Age wackiness).
gorillotaur's review against another edition
3.0
Podcast review: http://lashart.podbean.com/e/elliot-s-maggin-superman-miracle-monday/
(Swedish)
(Swedish)
barryhaworth's review
2.0
I recently reread the other Superman book by this author, and having been given this one as a gift I followed it up with the sequel. Like the former book, though, this one didn't work for me. Perhaps I am not sufficiently immersed in the sorts of stories that get told in comic books, but a story about how Superman is tempted by the devil doesn't really work for me.
robintelldrake's review
4.0
The degree to which these two little novels (Last Son of Krypton, Miracle Monday) have shaped my idea of how a novel works is a long-standing, embarrassing little secret of mine. Personally, despite the pop-culture nature of the very idea of a Superman novel, I have always felt Maggin accomplished some powerful and noteworthy storytelling here. This is Superman at his most godlike, but it’s also a deeper, more thoroughgoing examination of his lifetime and psyche than I’ve ever seen attempted anywhere else. Lex Luthor, too, becomes a character with his own past and preoccupations, and dozens of projects underway at all times few of which have anything to do with Superman. The ensemble cast around them is drawn on familiar characters from the comics, each done in similarly loving closeup, plus a pile of others from the author’s own head. Maggin is a deft writer of dialogue, with a light comedic tone most of the time.
But structurally, these books are pretty intricate, with the main action often deliberately buried in a flurry of unrelated or tangentially related incidents (Maggin is also a great maker of lists, which may be a stylistic tic or may just be the inevitable result of larding on so much byplay while the plot goes sneaking along underneath). It’s not hard to read them a couple times before you’re strictly clear on which characters were actually Luthor in disguise all along, for example, because Maggin is quite content to let disguises of that sort go unmasked for many chapters in a row. When a new character or scene is introduced, its importance to the story can take quite a while to emerge, but you do need to pay attention if you want to catch it when the reveal comes.
Well worth your time whether you’re particularly interested in the comics or not.
But structurally, these books are pretty intricate, with the main action often deliberately buried in a flurry of unrelated or tangentially related incidents (Maggin is also a great maker of lists, which may be a stylistic tic or may just be the inevitable result of larding on so much byplay while the plot goes sneaking along underneath). It’s not hard to read them a couple times before you’re strictly clear on which characters were actually Luthor in disguise all along, for example, because Maggin is quite content to let disguises of that sort go unmasked for many chapters in a row. When a new character or scene is introduced, its importance to the story can take quite a while to emerge, but you do need to pay attention if you want to catch it when the reveal comes.
Well worth your time whether you’re particularly interested in the comics or not.
birdmanseven's review
2.0
I came across this book by reading a footnote in the DC Comics Presents Annual featuring the character Kristin Wells. While I love that character this book creeped me out as a kid. I got the chance to discuss Kristin Wells/Superwoman with the author, Elliot S! Maggin in this episode of the All the Books Show podcast: I take a deep dive into Shazam on this episode of the All the Books Show podcast. https://soundcloud.com/allthebooks/episode-189-shazam-spotlight-with-elliot-s-maggin
ekansthepokemon's review against another edition
3.0
This book isn't bad, but it's slow, and parts of it don't even make sense/are just ridiculous. I don't even understand the climax, it makes no sense. It still does a good job of building out Superman's world though.
More...