caidyn's review
3.0
What can I say? Some of these were really good, some of them were pretty sucky. Since this is an anthology with different people adapting the stories and also different people doing the art, there's a lot of diversity to it. Most of them are changed and modernized in some way. Some of the art is really realistic, some really cartoon-like. The stories I liked were ones that stuck closely to the original story, had semi-realistic art, and also were generally stories I really enjoyed by Poe in the first place. So, basically, I loved The Raven and The Tell-Tale Heart. I skipped over The Murders in the Rue Morgue because I hated that short story.
More...