Reviews

Darkthaw: A Winterkill Novel, by Kate A. Boorman

lazygal's review

1.0

I was convinced I'd read this book before, right down to the confusion of French and English speakers in the settlement. After checking, I hadn't read the previous book so I DNF'd because it's clearly a world I've already read about and to be honest, these characters just didn't make me care enough about them or their journey to continue in that world.

ARC provided by publisher.

megdconway's review

medium-paced

3.25

ladyofbooks's review

5.0

Oh, don't mind me I'm just sitting here waiting to get my hands on book three as I cry my eyes out over character deaths.

TW: graphic violence, brief torture scenes, descriptive sickness, starvation, list things as I think recall it

thereadingweasel's review

3.0

This book was a roller-coaster of emotions. I really enjoyed her writing and the imagery that all lined up with Winterkill. This book was certainly an enjoyable faster read for me. Cannot wait to read Heartfire.

lilyelfgreen's review against another edition

4.0

velmi důstojný druhý díl. i když je to takový ten typický výpravný příběh (hrdinové se musí dostat z jednoho místa na druhé, ale na cestě na ně neustále číhají nějaké nástrahy), pořád se něco děje a čtenář se nenudí.

folklaureate's review

1.0

Nope. I tried through the first novel. I cannot try anymore. DNF 30%

hylian_narwhal's review

3.0

True rating; 3.25 stars

I was hoping that things introduced in [b:Winterkill|20702025|Winterkill (Winterkill, #1)|Kate A. Boorman|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1397612858l/20702025._SY75_.jpg|24991002] would start to develop outward into a more complex plot, but again I was disappointed.

It's not a bad story, I just thought it could have given a bit more.

witchyficbindery's review

3.0

Winterkill, the first in this series, was one of my favorite books of 2014! I loved the "Village" vibes it gave off and even enjoyed the uncertainty of the setting. Darkthaw picks up right where Winterkill left off, with Em and Kane planning their future and being generally confused about most things. This was a sequel I have really been looking forward to and I hoped to feel the same about book two as I did about book one. Unfortunately, this one didn't quite do it for me.

I'm not sure what changed before books one and two, but I felt like I had a hard time connecting to Emmeline this time around. I know that people are probably inherently selfish, but she made some decisions in the first half of the book that I had a hard time accepting. I did really enjoy Matisa, however! She was a fantastic character who honestly didn't seem to have a flaw whatsoever. Kane remained one of my favorite characters also and I really felt for him as he tried to find his path in life.

I did really enjoy the new world that opened up in this installment. Emmeline and Kane decide to leave their settlement when they learn that there's much more out there than they'd originally known. The introduction of other settlers really upped the tension and mystery and continued this series as extremely unique. I feel like I was able to place the location a little better this go round - I'm guessing somewhere in Eastern Canada.

My main issue with this book was the writing. The author has used a really strange dialect which, on the one hand, makes it unique, but also makes it really laborious to get through at times. The story was also quite slow, which is why this book took me sooooo much longer to get through than the first. I feel like book one had a very quick series of events that progressed easily, while this one was a lot of traveling, horseback riding, and talking.

Darkthaw definitely had its ups and downs. I really appreciated the original story and the new characters, but the writing and unsympathetic main character made it less great than Winterkill. I'd recommend this to someone looking for a very unique dystopian who's read everything else!

moththem's review

4.0

I was worried I wouldn't enjoy this book as much as the first in this series, but god was I wrong. I loved the added tension that this story had and getting to see the world expand to be so much more than once was thought. The character development was brilliant and Boorman really impressed me with how multidimensional they all were. I really came to love Isi and Tom especially, which is something I didn't expect after they were relatively small characters in the first book. The emotional depth was brilliant and I enjoyed the inner monologue of Em. I also enjoyed seeing the relationship between Em and Kane develop further, and though the ending did sadden me a lot.

I really loved this and needless to say I'm going to order the final book right now!