metaphorosis's review
2.0
Metaphorosis Reviews
2 stars
Jim Grimson is a troubled young boy with a difficult home life. Eventually finding himself in group therapy, he's encouraged to imagine himself as a character in Philip Jose Farmer's World of Tiers series. Immersing himself in the experience, he develops a seeming ability to inhabit the character Red Orc at various stages in his life.
Trying to track down their friend and Lord Jadawin-Wolff, Kickaha and Anana find themselves in a changing, chaotic world, along with its creator, Urthona, Earth's Lord, Red Orc, and one of Red Orc's thugs. They must adapt quickly, while searching for an escape.
Apparently, Tiersian therapy was a real thing that Farmer learned about. I'm sure it must have intrigued him, and I can see the appeal of incorporating into his World of Tiers series as a sort of recursive meta-fiction. Unfortunately, what was likely fun for Farmer has considerably less appeal for readers.
The writing is surprisingly clunky. Perhaps because he has to deal more with the real world, and less with fantastic coincidence and exaggerated personalities, the protagonist seems crudely constructed and only mildly interesting. While there are clear parallels between Jim's home life and Red Orc's upbringing, Farmer strips them of all subtlety, pointing them out and underlining them at every turn.
It's nice for once to see things from the villain's viewpoint, but Farmer never goes very far beneath the surface. 'Red Orc has a hard childhood, so he becomes a bad man' is about as far is it goes. The rest of the book is a series of episodes in Red Orc's life, loosely tied together by the Jim Grimson story. I found it hard to be interested in either.
All in all, likely a fun project for the author, but dull for the rest of us.
I received a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
2 stars
Jim Grimson is a troubled young boy with a difficult home life. Eventually finding himself in group therapy, he's encouraged to imagine himself as a character in Philip Jose Farmer's World of Tiers series. Immersing himself in the experience, he develops a seeming ability to inhabit the character Red Orc at various stages in his life.
Trying to track down their friend and Lord Jadawin-Wolff, Kickaha and Anana find themselves in a changing, chaotic world, along with its creator, Urthona, Earth's Lord, Red Orc, and one of Red Orc's thugs. They must adapt quickly, while searching for an escape.
Apparently, Tiersian therapy was a real thing that Farmer learned about. I'm sure it must have intrigued him, and I can see the appeal of incorporating into his World of Tiers series as a sort of recursive meta-fiction. Unfortunately, what was likely fun for Farmer has considerably less appeal for readers.
The writing is surprisingly clunky. Perhaps because he has to deal more with the real world, and less with fantastic coincidence and exaggerated personalities, the protagonist seems crudely constructed and only mildly interesting. While there are clear parallels between Jim's home life and Red Orc's upbringing, Farmer strips them of all subtlety, pointing them out and underlining them at every turn.
It's nice for once to see things from the villain's viewpoint, but Farmer never goes very far beneath the surface. 'Red Orc has a hard childhood, so he becomes a bad man' is about as far is it goes. The rest of the book is a series of episodes in Red Orc's life, loosely tied together by the Jim Grimson story. I found it hard to be interested in either.
All in all, likely a fun project for the author, but dull for the rest of us.
I received a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
pussreboots's review
1.0
I have no patience for books that are thinly disguised infomercials. The last such abomination I read in this category was Demons Don't Dream by Piers Anthony. Red Orc's Rage was slightly better than Demons but that isn't saying much.
The dedication to, and the Afterword by Dr. A. James Giannini, explains the reason behind this dog's breakfast of a book. Giannini has been using Farmer's Tiers books as therapy since the late 1970s. It's basically a form of role playing. He calls the process "Tiersian therapy" and Farmer got wind of his work.
Rather than smiling politely and moving on, Farmer decided to write a book about a fictional troubled teen who is of course a fan of the Tiers series to begin with so is the perfect candidate for the therapy when he's put in a mental hospital. Of course for him, the journey is real and he gets to have all of his long desired adventures in Farmer's creation.
This wretched thing reads like bad fan fiction. The novel is a complete waste of time. It lacks the edginess of earlier Farmer and it doesn't make up for it with maturity.
The dedication to, and the Afterword by Dr. A. James Giannini, explains the reason behind this dog's breakfast of a book. Giannini has been using Farmer's Tiers books as therapy since the late 1970s. It's basically a form of role playing. He calls the process "Tiersian therapy" and Farmer got wind of his work.
Rather than smiling politely and moving on, Farmer decided to write a book about a fictional troubled teen who is of course a fan of the Tiers series to begin with so is the perfect candidate for the therapy when he's put in a mental hospital. Of course for him, the journey is real and he gets to have all of his long desired adventures in Farmer's creation.
This wretched thing reads like bad fan fiction. The novel is a complete waste of time. It lacks the edginess of earlier Farmer and it doesn't make up for it with maturity.
More...