Scan barcode
reickel's review against another edition
4.0
The first half is a slog, 3 stars, and the latter half is pretty exciting, 4.5 stars. Put em all together and you get a deserved 4. This volume definitely has a different feel, with Constantine connecting Swamp Thing to plenty of other magical DC characters as a matter of course, not in one-off exceptions.
thefool0's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
dark
hopeful
mysterious
reflective
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.75
robbiesbookshelf's review against another edition
challenging
dark
reflective
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
cryo_guy's review against another edition
4.0
I was honestly expecting a little bit more buttttt it was good. Good ol' Swampy is good. And there's a real arc that builds up. It has all the stuff you want in Swamp Thing and adds some nice depth to characters/elements already introduced. Excited to finish the Moore run.
Constantine is a jerk. Don't get shirty with me about it!
Constantine is a jerk. Don't get shirty with me about it!
groblinthegoblin624's review
3.75
Very interested in the first half, but by the time the overarching apocalypse plot started to get going I gradually checked out of the story. Good writing, but not my favorite volume
cesspool_princess's review against another edition
4.0
In the context of Moore's run, this is like dead middle of the road. There were some very epic and satisfying moments but also there were some things I had serious problems with.
Lets start with the gun violence arc. This was good but after the whole last volume felt a little tacked on / like a rehash on the themes Moore already covered. So I felt this was just a little less effective than the other ones in this vein. Like it was still good I just think it is outshined. Esp coming right after the plantation one (similar narrative of like horrors of the past literally coming back to haunt the present except there it was zombies and here it is ghosts).
Ok now we get into my rly big problem w this volume. The Brujeria being the shadowy group behind all of this felt sooo fucking dumb to me, like it was such a let down. Here we are bringing together this story about hatred, violence, alienation etc in the U.S and the ppl behind it are a group of Indigenous South Americans living deep in the Amazon rainforest???? bro......
I'm going to quote another review here bc they said it rly well: "I'm not sure how conscious Alan Moore was at the time of the ironies of his writing this plot, in which galactic doom is to be brought about by a black-magic cult in South America (and what's more indigenous South America), during a decade when US interference in Latin America was particularly visible. It does, at this distance, seem odd for an anti-establishment rebel like Moore to have been its writer (albeit at a stage when he was still trying to make a career in big brand comics, which he would soon abandon) and using a wily former punk, lefty anti-hero - a character quite capable of spotting insidious political symbolism in-universe - to resolve it."
Yeah this shit took me out.
Anyway this is followed by the big cross over event, the crisis of a million earths or whatever. This is Swamp Thing at its most superhero comic book and ofc I was annoyed with that but then there ended up being some v epic moments here. All the mystics and psychics joining together and then some of them just bursting into flames from the psychic pressure was fascinating. The factionalization of hell was also fascinating to see. But the big moment was the ending, the big darkness easily destroying some of the most powerful beings in universe because they have faulty ideologies, only for Swamp Thing to bring his wisdom and solve the problem. The joining of the dark and light and the sheer physical scale of it was stunning.
Ultimately for me, this had some of the lowest lows in the run but also some of the most epic / most satisfying moments to balance it out.
Lets start with the gun violence arc. This was good but after the whole last volume felt a little tacked on / like a rehash on the themes Moore already covered. So I felt this was just a little less effective than the other ones in this vein. Like it was still good I just think it is outshined. Esp coming right after the plantation one (similar narrative of like horrors of the past literally coming back to haunt the present except there it was zombies and here it is ghosts).
Ok now we get into my rly big problem w this volume. The Brujeria being the shadowy group behind all of this felt sooo fucking dumb to me, like it was such a let down. Here we are bringing together this story about hatred, violence, alienation etc in the U.S and the ppl behind it are a group of Indigenous South Americans living deep in the Amazon rainforest???? bro......
I'm going to quote another review here bc they said it rly well: "I'm not sure how conscious Alan Moore was at the time of the ironies of his writing this plot, in which galactic doom is to be brought about by a black-magic cult in South America (and what's more indigenous South America), during a decade when US interference in Latin America was particularly visible. It does, at this distance, seem odd for an anti-establishment rebel like Moore to have been its writer (albeit at a stage when he was still trying to make a career in big brand comics, which he would soon abandon) and using a wily former punk, lefty anti-hero - a character quite capable of spotting insidious political symbolism in-universe - to resolve it."
Yeah this shit took me out.
Anyway this is followed by the big cross over event, the crisis of a million earths or whatever. This is Swamp Thing at its most superhero comic book and ofc I was annoyed with that but then there ended up being some v epic moments here. All the mystics and psychics joining together and then some of them just bursting into flames from the psychic pressure was fascinating. The factionalization of hell was also fascinating to see. But the big moment was the ending, the big darkness easily destroying some of the most powerful beings in universe because they have faulty ideologies, only for Swamp Thing to bring his wisdom and solve the problem. The joining of the dark and light and the sheer physical scale of it was stunning.
Ultimately for me, this had some of the lowest lows in the run but also some of the most epic / most satisfying moments to balance it out.
lcush98's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
emotional
mysterious
relaxing
sad
slow-paced
4.25
bigoldan's review against another edition
challenging
inspiring
mysterious
reflective
medium-paced
3.75
jammasterjamie's review against another edition
4.0
Another really great volume - I shorted it a star because of the Crisis on Infinite Earths crossover stuff making it kind of confusing and leaving some parts of the story feeling disjointed. No fault of Moore's, of course, and it doesn't hurt the superb storytelling overall, but it did take me out of it for a couple of pages without really explaining why, so that wasn't great. That said, it did set up a fantastic end to the volume, so at the end of the day it's all good.
ostrava's review against another edition
4.0
The first volume of the Swamp Thing I'm not giving the full five stars. It's not awful but by far my least favorite. Maybe it's on me though, I could have given it a chance, but I'm a bit distracted at the moment and couldn't give this one my full attention.
The stuff that works is excellent. But it doesn't reach the highs of the second and the third volume. I'm hopeful about the new stuff with Abby though...
The stuff that works is excellent. But it doesn't reach the highs of the second and the third volume. I'm hopeful about the new stuff with Abby though...