Scan barcode
brentmayberry's review against another edition
2.0
This book had a lot of nice tidbits about Barca's club officials, club politics, and key players under Pep Guardiola, but the text gets bogged down in repetition and unorganized writing. I had to push myself to finish this. I didn't mind that the book wasn't objective. The author never claimed to be unbiased, and that's okay. If you're not a fan of Barcelona, you probably wouldn't be reading this book in the first place.
adamz24's review against another edition
3.0
Good book featuring much knowledgeable analysis. But Barcelona is not the Greatest Team in the World or the Greatest Team of All Time.
Barcelona has invested everything in one style of play, requiring certain players capable of filling those roles. The aesthetic result is normally astonishingly beautiful and elegant in a way few things are in sports. But when other teams catch up and figure out how to play against you, you must then rely on the players being so damn good that tactical adjustment is not sufficient to avoid defeat.
This has been especially apparent this season, in Europe and in certain domestic matches. That Messi has had such a great season is reflective not only of his talent but also of how Barcelona have been forced to play recently. In both CL semifinal matches against Chelsea this year, and the April clasico, the reason why Barcelona will not win either La Liga or the CL this year was laid bare. If you don't let them play their way, they can't play, at least not like The Greatest Team in the World.
Guardiola's philosophy and Barcelona's philosophy has so overwhelmed the team's malleability that to beat them, you just need to be good enough to stop them from playing a flowing attacking game up front. Chelsea is an inferior team aesthetically, in terms of talent, etc. but never really looked like losing to Barcelona, because they held their ground and kept Barca from being Barca.
But the Greatest Team in the World ought to be good enough to work around that. At some point, playing short passes around and in the penalty area goes from looking dazzling to looking foolish. Real Madrid under Mourinho is a better club than Barcelona is right now, and that's just one example, because they are more malleable.
Footballing cultures and philosophies are great, but it often becomes extraordinarily hard to be the best when you get figured out and you can't then rely on individual talent to make sure you still win. Messi isn't always going to skip away from the defender that one crucial time and make that perfect last pass for the sure goal.
Barcelona is clearly, right now, one of the greatest football teams the world has ever seen, but its brand of tiki-taka may not have the necessary grit to justify claims to ultimate greatness, or indeed to get the results that matter the most on a consistent basis. This brand of tiki-taka, indeed, may be going the way of Dutch total football, which saw its ultimate fruit in the 1974 WC final. Cruyff's goal is one of the best ever, but the Germans did not luck into a win. Barcelona did not luck out of crucial results this season, either.
The greatest team of all time, or in the world, ought to be extremely pragmatic, no?
Barcelona has invested everything in one style of play, requiring certain players capable of filling those roles. The aesthetic result is normally astonishingly beautiful and elegant in a way few things are in sports. But when other teams catch up and figure out how to play against you, you must then rely on the players being so damn good that tactical adjustment is not sufficient to avoid defeat.
This has been especially apparent this season, in Europe and in certain domestic matches. That Messi has had such a great season is reflective not only of his talent but also of how Barcelona have been forced to play recently. In both CL semifinal matches against Chelsea this year, and the April clasico, the reason why Barcelona will not win either La Liga or the CL this year was laid bare. If you don't let them play their way, they can't play, at least not like The Greatest Team in the World.
Guardiola's philosophy and Barcelona's philosophy has so overwhelmed the team's malleability that to beat them, you just need to be good enough to stop them from playing a flowing attacking game up front. Chelsea is an inferior team aesthetically, in terms of talent, etc. but never really looked like losing to Barcelona, because they held their ground and kept Barca from being Barca.
But the Greatest Team in the World ought to be good enough to work around that. At some point, playing short passes around and in the penalty area goes from looking dazzling to looking foolish. Real Madrid under Mourinho is a better club than Barcelona is right now, and that's just one example, because they are more malleable.
Footballing cultures and philosophies are great, but it often becomes extraordinarily hard to be the best when you get figured out and you can't then rely on individual talent to make sure you still win. Messi isn't always going to skip away from the defender that one crucial time and make that perfect last pass for the sure goal.
Barcelona is clearly, right now, one of the greatest football teams the world has ever seen, but its brand of tiki-taka may not have the necessary grit to justify claims to ultimate greatness, or indeed to get the results that matter the most on a consistent basis. This brand of tiki-taka, indeed, may be going the way of Dutch total football, which saw its ultimate fruit in the 1974 WC final. Cruyff's goal is one of the best ever, but the Germans did not luck into a win. Barcelona did not luck out of crucial results this season, either.
The greatest team of all time, or in the world, ought to be extremely pragmatic, no?
whizalen's review against another edition
4.0
If you'd enjoy a thousand and one hyperbolic descriptions of Iniestas goal to win the 2010 World Cup then this book is for you.
acousticdefacto's review against another edition
informative
inspiring
lighthearted
reflective
medium-paced
3.0
charliepritchard1996's review against another edition
5.0
As Sid Lowe has said, nobody knows FC Barcelona like Graham Hunter. This book provides unparalleled insight into the greatest club side ever. What Guardiola achieved was down to so many fundamental components, and Hunter analyses all of these key elements with aplomb.
Some chapters in particular are truly brilliant. I found the chapters which focused exclusively on the key players of the Barca starting XI the most intriguing. ‘The Odd Couple’ depicts the relationship between Carles Puyol and Gerard Pique and how this unlikely duo marshalled Barca’s back four to trophy success after trophy success.
Other strong chapters focus on Xavi Hernandez and Andres Iniesta in particular and expertly charter their early lives and early careers as Barca players to provide context and explain their respective places in Barca folklore.
A thoroughly enjoyable, revealing and intriguing read for any football fan, dare I say it even for a devout Madridista!
Some chapters in particular are truly brilliant. I found the chapters which focused exclusively on the key players of the Barca starting XI the most intriguing. ‘The Odd Couple’ depicts the relationship between Carles Puyol and Gerard Pique and how this unlikely duo marshalled Barca’s back four to trophy success after trophy success.
Other strong chapters focus on Xavi Hernandez and Andres Iniesta in particular and expertly charter their early lives and early careers as Barca players to provide context and explain their respective places in Barca folklore.
A thoroughly enjoyable, revealing and intriguing read for any football fan, dare I say it even for a devout Madridista!
anunande's review against another edition
Graham Hunter’s Barca: The Making Of The Greatest Team In The World is about how this world-beater team evolved and became so successful. In the process, we also get insights into Barcelona’s history, about former presidents and vice-presidents and what led to the birth of the idea the current Barca philosophy is based around. The focus is on the members of the current team, Pep Guardiola (a fascinating chapter on his Barca journey as a player and then a coach) and of course Johan Cruyff, without whom none of this would have been possible.
The full review here:
https://www.footballparadise.com/barca-the-making-of-the-greatest-team-in-the-world-by-graham-hunter-a-book-review
The full review here:
https://www.footballparadise.com/barca-the-making-of-the-greatest-team-in-the-world-by-graham-hunter-a-book-review
More...