Reviews

Legend by Marie Lu

rizkamulya's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Still as impressed this time around.

mehsi's review against another edition

Go to review page

1.0

So, I had to read this for a Blind Date Challenge. This is our second book, the first one was also crap and we gave up on it. It seems that we didn't have any luck this time. This book also sucked.

Why did it suck? Let's start with the plot, it is a typical Dystopian story, and I felt it was a bit too generic. At times I had to make sure I wasn't reading some other Dystopian I had read, since often it felt like that. Maybe it is me and I have read too many Dystopian books, but it just felt like someone used RPG-maker and just added a few additions to make it slightly different from all the other generic RPG-maker games. It was just bland and boring. Maybe it also has to do with the age of the author when she wrote it, but I generally don't judge on that as I have read enough books by teenagers that were quite good.

The world-building was also a problem. Unlike with quite a lot of books, I didn't feel immersed in the world. I felt like I was floating along with people, watching things happening, but not sure where and how the world looked. Maybe because of the lack of details, or just because it didn't attract me, I don't know, I only know it didn't work for me.

Then we have one of the biggest problems that I had with the book. The characters. We have Day and June, and there POVs switch with every chapter. However, these 2 characters are so alike (and I will talk more about it soon) that at times I was confused who was talking. It didn't help that my ebook didn't have the little June or Day at top of the first page of the chapters. Though I think even then I might just not have known who chatted or would have looked back to make sure it was *insert character* chatting.
At times they were a bit different. June in the beginning was a bit of a spoiled princess. Acting all superior because she got top score and she doesn't mind to remember people about it or be all too thrilled when they remembered she had such a score. She also thought she could handle everything by her own, waving away any help.
Day was (at least in the beginning) an interesting character, but quite soon I just see the stupidity in him, and I also didn't like his attitude towards woman/girls. Seeing them only as a quick way to get kisses/attention. I don't like guys who act like this, typical player behaviour and something I don't want to see in a book, especially not of a main character.

Now about the whole looking alike. Even the main characters agree with me on the whole looking/being alike. The following is a quote from the book: "It's strange being here with you. I hardly know you. But...sometimes it feels like we're the same person born into two different worlds."
At times I had a hard time to differentiate between the two characters. At one moment I was just calling June Female-Day and Day I was calling Male-June. They thought alike, they were just as strong, and we also find out several other similarities that make me think they were just meant as one character but split up in 2.

All the other characters were just bleh. We got Thomas, the big bad military, various other side-characters. Most didn't interest me due to the lack of character development they got and they just came across as cardboards. I can't spoil much, so I guess I can't say much on why I hate Thomas. I knew something was up with him from the beginning, and I was totally right, that is all I will say. :)

The plot was over-the-top and super cheesy and lame. I mean come on, the plot is just hilarious. How can a prodigy with a score of 1500 and various connections to the whole thing not notice anything is wrong? At times I was just laughing at the silly lines that the characters said. Day's real name and why he picked Day as his streetname. Oh dear, that had me laughing so hard at the cheesiness.

Oh one thing I forgot. The change that June makes. From elite bitch to something that thinks and is kind of nice. However I felt the change was too big and too magical to be real. Especially considering most of the change really happened near the end.

All in all, I had hoped for something better. Lots of people seemed to love it and I have had friends who recommended me this book. It just seems it was not meant to be and I am happy I am done with this book. Would I recommend it? No. Not unless you are looking for a cheesy, generic book. If you are looking for Dystopian try something else.

Review first posted at http://twirlingbookprincess.com/

dipalimish's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

I love it. Love it. Love it. I think my year is now finally on a good reading start.
I heard a lot of praise about this book and read somewhere that it is even better than hunger games and as I already have read hunger games I thought I have to compare them. And I can say that it is better. In the back it is written(at least on my book ) that it is a retelling of Les miserable and this year i read a lot of retelling so why not this one. And this one was good. I was literally jumping by the end of the book and I just loved it. I think June a brilliant and her character development thought this book was great. And Day, well I kinda a reminds me of William Herondale (Infernal Devices) and a bit of Aladdin(don't know why). I loved the mystery. It made me more excited about the end. The only thing I hated is that my delivery for this book was late and also in the wrong cover so that part made me just furious other than that I was just great. I am really excited about prodigy. Yay.

meyy's review

Go to review page

adventurous dark sad tense fast-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? It's complicated
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.5

tallyvauthor's review

Go to review page

4.0

Did I like it: 4★
Does it fit the genre: 5★
Does it do what it's trying to do: 4★
Storyline: 3★
Writing style: 3.5★
Characters: 5★
Plot Twists: 4★
Pacing: 3★

Total: 3.9★

Breakdown:
I enjoyed this book! I really loved all of the characters. They were easy to empathize with, especially when telling their tragic backstories. Now, usually I'm immune to these things but there was something about the Chicken Scene that made me sick to my stomach.

I thought that the plot twists were predictable at times but there were a couple that snuck up on me and I did sincerely appreciate them! The worldbuilding in this is also great, while at times it felt a tad info dump-y they spread around the information so it was never confusing and the reader can always understand what's going on.

I can't say that the storyline, over-all, had me thrilled. I'm hoping this gets amped up with the rest of the books in the series because it's a really cool dystopian world that Marie Lu has built and I'm here for the rest of it but I kept feeling like through this one, not enough weight was beside their actions to make me feel like they mattered. I think this book may have been much better if it was longer.

adda_grace's review

Go to review page

adventurous medium-paced

4.25

notyourvegetable's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

OMG. ich liebs. Ich hab schon so lange kein Buch mehr so schnell durchgesuchtet. Und dieses Ende. Woahhhhh. Ich weiß gar nicht mehr, wo oben und unten ist. Einfach so krass.

crissfm's review

Go to review page

5.0

Es la 1:00 de la mañana del 30 de julio. Día de mi cumpleaños. HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO ME!!!!

Nunca me han gustado los libros con más de un punto de vista porque pienso que un puto de vista es más aburrido que el otro pero este es una excepción. Los dos personajes son tan interesantes y la historia tan genial que no puedas parar de leer el libro en ningún momento. Me muero de ganas de leer la segunda parte!

Ahora, si me disculpáis, tengo que responder a los mensajes de felicitación.

anfaal's review

Go to review page

adventurous mysterious sad tense fast-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.25

gardenofejw's review

Go to review page

5.0

A very classic/typical YA novel but one of my absolute favorites when I was younger. I actually have the book signed by Marie Lu when I met her at a book fair in LA! (Before I knew who she was though haha)