Reviews

Doctor Who: The Writer's Tale by Russell T. Davies, Benjamin Cook

nmw2412's review

funny informative inspiring lighthearted reflective relaxing medium-paced

5.0

dp112's review

emotional funny hopeful informative inspiring reflective medium-paced

5.0

Life changing

vrimnivrim's review

funny informative inspiring fast-paced

4.75

trickeyjoe's review

funny informative inspiring medium-paced

4.0

mferber's review

5.0

Totally engrossing, if you like this sort of thing.

bookishhill's review

5.0

I absolutely loved this book. When I bought it, I was expecting a behind-the-scenes look at Doctor Who (one of my favorite shows), but was pleasantly surprised with how personal and emotional it turned out to be. Throughout the book - written as emails between Davies and Cook - you really got to see inside Davies' head and experience his happiness, joy, sorrow, and turmoil as he wrote for Doctor Who. I laughed and cried (sometimes I cringed) and genuinely hated finishing it.

iridaceae's review

adventurous challenging dark emotional funny hopeful informative inspiring reflective slow-paced

4.0

nwhyte's review

5.0

"http://nwhyte.livejournal.com/1278783.html[return][return]This book is essential reading, not just for the Doctor Who fan, but for anyone who is even slightly interested in the show, or more broadly who is interested in the process of writing for television.[return][return]It is structured as a year-long email conversation between journalist Benjamin Cook and Russell T Davies about the process of writing the fourth season of New Who, from Voyage of the Damned to Journey's End. (Also briefly including Time Crash.) On the scale of loving or hating RTD, I am sort of in the middle: I respect and admire his achievement in reviving Who in the first place, which I think in the end puts me just slightly on the 'love' side of the divide, but I don't always like his writing, or his public persona. This book reinforced both my positive and negative prejudices about him as a professional, but it grounded them in a much deeper understanding of his personality, and in the awful responsibility of the writer on a show like Who: his loyalty and his guilt circulate around his key colleagues - Julie Gardner, Phil Collinson, David Tennant - and worrying that he won't produce the goods with adequate quality or promptness.[return][return]Vast amounts of draft script are included in the book, much of which made it to screen. I found the roads not taken rather interesting - who was the comedienne who might have played Penny, the companion who never was because Catherine Tate accepted the invitation to return? Imagine if Dennis Hopper had been available? And at the very end of the book, Cook rightly persuades Davies to drop a really awful linking script between Journey's End and The Next Doctor. [return][return]But even more interesting is to see what the fundamental idea of each story actually is. They are not always very strong. The Stolen Earth/Journey's End is almost entirely about showing rather than telling:[return][return]...Daleks, en masse. Lots of gunfire and exterminations. And the biggest Dalek spaceship ever - more like a Dalek temple. Christ almighty! The skies over the Earth need to be changed to weird outer space vistas. Also, visible in the sky, a huge Dalek ship exterior. The size of a solar system! This will probably explode. Like they do.[return][return]And Davros.[return][return]So the episodes are seen at this point largely as spectacle rather than story; the most effective bit, the end of Donna's travels with the Doctor, emerges rather late in the day from Davies' fevered imagination. One may not always like the solutions he comes up with, but the insight into the creative process. Is utterly fascinating and compelling.[return][return](Certain sections of fandom will not be pleased by what he has to say about the internet. Too bad. To paraphrase Neil Gaiman on George R.R. Martin, Russell T Davies is not your bitch.)[return][return]There is a surprising amount of death in the book: Christopher Ecclestone's driver, David Tennant's mother, Verity Lambert, and most of all Howard Attfield, called from his sick bed to reprise his role as Donna's father, but unable to complete the scripts. After his death, his scenes are reshot with Bernard Cribbins. The show must go on.[return][return]Indeed, that is the bigger lesson from the. Book. If Doctor Who is sometimes less than perfect, it happens basically because The Show Must Go On, and because the writers and producers have determined to put on screen what they can. It is rather amazing that it ended up so well as often as it did.[return][return]Anyway, this is probably the most interesting book about Doctor Who that will ever be written. If you are even slightly interested in the subject, get it."

ianbanks's review

5.0

There are any number of books on writing that detail how to go about it. I've read more than my fair share of them, seeking advice on how to spark up my own literary offerings (hint: the only advice that ALL writers offer is to read a ton and write a ton and to keep doing it). To read about the process from the guy who restarted possibly-my-all-time-favourite TV show is, to coin a phrase, FANTASTIC!

Mr Davies reads like he talks, at about a mile a minute. I think I would have hated to have had him in my classroom as he appears to be that kid with an opinion on everything. But he does sparkle, and he does make you nod and he does make you understand how writing can transform a life and that, while it may seem effortless - and, when you're in the moment, rattling off several thousand words a day is pretty easy - making it read well is a completely different matter. He also really enjoys writing and telling stories and creating memorable characters and situations and, while I don't think his era of The Show was particularly brilliant about realistic SF (Season 18 was about the only time in the shows 35 seasons/ 50-something years, IMNSHO, that there were people involved who really tried to make the S as prominent as the F), he did create some terrific drama.

It helps that he has a sounding board in Benjamin Cook, who interrupts or erratically steers the conversation back on topic with some well-thought or well-targeted questions about the creative process. And, in true organic collaborative style, some of the ideas brought up influence the direction of the scripts.

And it is the scripts that are another real highlight here: we get draft versions of four episodes (Voyage Of The Damned, Partners In Crime, The Stolen Earth and Journey's End) and it is really interesting to see them in comparison to their televised counterparts, with commentary from Mr Davies about how they would/ did change from paper to screen.

Great fun, insightful and often hilarious.

logenbarry's review

adventurous emotional funny hopeful informative inspiring lighthearted reflective sad medium-paced

5.0

As someone who’s always been interested writing and grew up on Doctor Who, this was wonderful snapshot of the process. The unique aspect of the emails provides a wonderful conversational frame to the discussion.