Reviews

Season of Ice by Diane Les Becquets

ebroadbent22's review

Go to review page

5.0

Incredible! I haven't read a more serious book in quite a while-I too have been struggling to overcome the Meg Cabot light and fruity style-and Season Of Ice couldn't have been a better way to get back on track. Glowing with imagery and emotion, which is overshadowed with a darker tone of sadness, Season Of Ice perfectly captures the grief and misery the befalls a family after the loss of a loved one.

dfmaiwat's review

Go to review page

2.0

It's one of those books that I read but couldn't invest myself in the story.

christiek's review

Go to review page

4.0

I am going to read more of Diane Les Becquets. This book ends with mostly expository story telling which made for essentially a long epilogue and takes the punch out of the excellent first 3/4 of the book. I really enjoyed Les Becquets craft, her descriptions, Gen's character, and except the part at the end, the narrative voice.

pandamans's review

Go to review page

4.0

As winter draws near, Genesis's father, a timber man, takes on a dock repair job while a storm looms on the horizon. As the hours pass and her father still hasn't returned, Genesis increasingly grows concerned. Her knowledge of her father's habit of not wearing a life jacket, rather tossing it nearby on the boat's deck "just in case" becomes more ominous. The wind has kicked up and the waves have grown choppy on the sea; her father has still not returned. Genesis and her step-mom Linda contact the sheriff and a search party is organized. Eventually the weather forces the sheriff to call off the search. Genesis is numb from both the cold and the recognition that her father is still missing. As the days go by and the ice blankets the sea, she is left to wonder whether her father is entombed below the surface.[return][return]I found the story and the detail wonderfully tied together with the setting. The exterior world of ice and snow matches the interior of Genesis's struggle. She is frozen in uncertainty, waiting for the thaw - and the author does an excellent job of meshing the two. I feel that Season of Ice is a compelling read that was very well written.

nancyotoole's review

Go to review page

3.0

In late fall, Genesis's father heads out to Moosehead Lake and vanishes. A frantic search takes place with no results, and it is determined that he has perished beneath the frozen waters of the lake. Recovery is delayed until spring, and Genesis and her family must go on living without any concrete answers. But when she hears a rumor that her father is still alive, and has run away with another women, Genesis begins to ask more questions about her father's disappearance.

Season of Ice is a realistic work of young adult fiction that takes place in Maine. One of the things that impressed me the most about the novel is how accurate Les Becquets captures life in rural Maine. It's obvious from the small details she provides, from plastic on the windows in winter to front yards filled with broken down cars, that that author has a real life connection to the place. As someone who lives in Maine, I could make real life connections with a lot of details she provides. Another thing I really liked about this novel is it's protagonist Genesis. I admired her maturity, but also feel sympathetic towards her plight. Genesis has to grow up too fast due to events in her life. While reading, I often found myself wishing that she had more time just to be a seventeen-year-old girl. On occasion, the writing is surprisingly lovely. I found myself pausing to reread over certain passages several times.

Admittedly, there are a few issues I had with Season of Ice, but I'm willing to admit that this had a lot to do with my own expectations coming into the novel. One is due to the poor way in which the jacket blurb advertises the book. The blurb talks about how Genesis and her family must struggle in poverty as a result of not receiving any insurance money when her father's body is not recovered. I was a little disappointed when I discovered that this isn't really what the book is about. Instead it focuses on Genesis's quest to determine the truth behind her father's disappearance. Another thing that dragged my enjoyment down at times is the pacing. Season of Ice is a novel that emphasizes setting and characterization over plot, resulting in a book that is surprisingly slow paced for a young adult novel. Once I grew used to it, I found I enjoyed the calm pacing. I grew to love this story which, despite it's sad premise, feels very grounded in reality, and is free of any cheap thrills or melodrama.

Season of Ice was not what I expected, but I found that I grew to appreciate Genesis and her story. This beautifully written story should hold appeal to more patient young adults, and should appeal to adult readers as well.

libscote's review

Go to review page

3.0

Lupine Winner 2008-2009, MSBA Nominee 2009-2010

It was definitely better than I thought it would be, and different too. Genesis's father goes out on his boat to repair a dock one day, and doesn't return. Before his body can be found, the lake freezes over. I thought the story was going to be more about the financial and insurance complications that would ensue following such an event, but it wasn't. It was more about how the people deal with the situation, which I think made it better. I just think that the description of the book makes it seem different.
More...