rltinha's review against another edition
5.0
An odyssey inhabited by the unpredictable and creative stunts that only the best are able to pull without losing the reader.
Full closure for a run that deserved no less.
Full closure for a run that deserved no less.
jammasterjamie's review against another edition
5.0
What can I say that hasn't already been said? There's a reason why Alan Moore's run on Swamp Thing is legendary.
ostrava's review against another edition
4.0
Yeah, Swamp Thing starts to lose some of its charm towards the end, but not enough to finish off poorly or anything. I imagine that Moore was distracted by other projects and he might have abandoned some of the issues on the other writers of the run, with varying results.
Does it matter?
No.
This is an all-time classic and a wonderful masterpiece. I'm not happy with all of the issues collected here, but I'm definitely happy with the results of the entire run of Moore's Swamp Thing. It lives up to the hype.
Does it matter?
No.
This is an all-time classic and a wonderful masterpiece. I'm not happy with all of the issues collected here, but I'm definitely happy with the results of the entire run of Moore's Swamp Thing. It lives up to the hype.
some_okie_dude27's review against another edition
5.0
All good things must come to an end, as the old saying goes. Though I must say that I am still saddened to see Alan Moore’s Swamp Thing go. Much like the titular muck and crusted monstrosity, I feel like I have come to the end of a perilous journey, fraught with complexities, intense emotions, and a deep feeling of sorrow by the time that it’s come to an end.
I’m saddened to see that there probably won’t be anything that’ll ever come remotely close to the quality of Alan’s strange little run on this swamp creature, despite how hard many people try. There will be good runs after Alan’s run on Swamp Thing, yes. There will even be the occasional great run after Moore’s Swamp Thing. But I find it highly implausible that there will be anything quite like Alan’s Swamp Thing, as hard as we try to recreate it. I don’t believe there will ever be another story quite like The Anatomy Lesson, or another Pog, or another Monkey King. I could go on.
Sadly, the sixth volume is not quite as strong as the other five. Alan was just beginning work on the seminal Watchmen, and one could definitely tell that Alan’s focus was on Watchmen more than it was on Swamp Thing. Yet still, Alan manages to do what he can with what he has left and plays in the science fiction realm, which is my favorite genre. Alan’s knack for playing with conventions plays into this volume as well, but it isn’t quite as strong in this volume. The stories didn’t quite have the flare or touching sincerity of some of the other stories that I mentioned before, though I was quite interested to see Alan bring back more obscure characters like Adam Strange and Hawkman in this volume. As I’ve mentioned before, I often enjoy when writers bring back older, obscure characters. It brings a unique flare to the series and offers new, fresh ideas to be explored with these characters and to also expose these characters to new audiences.
Rich Veitch’s art still remains to be a worthy successor to Bissette and Totleben’s superbly unsettling artwork, with Alfredo Alcala providing inks that are respectful and allusive to the classic style of this series. But the art also takes a much more psychedelic tone as well, going into some completely new directions in terms of the draughtsmanship. Bissette and Totleben did return for a few issues, with Bissette even writing an issue of Swamp Thing, which he did a very good job with. Veitch would also come to write an issue as well, which was also pretty good as well.
Despite this volume not being as strong, Alan waited until the end to pull out all the punches, writing a heartfelt, tender conclusion to the saga of the titular Swamp Thing. It’s one of the few comics that actually had me feeling emotional during the end. Of course, we never like when a story that we love ends, but Swamp Thing felt like more than just a story that I enjoyed. It was a journey that Alan, Swampy, and I took and it was fun while it lasted...but now it’s all over, and now I must find something else to read.
I’m also saddened by the end as I find that it’s the end of a part of Alan that I wish that we could’ve seen more of. The dreamer who would have completely reinvigorated American comics and sent off its properties into an entirely new direction. We lost the optimistic Alan, who so believed that his beloved medium could be more than the limitations that were placed on it and gave everything that he had in order to do just that. Though I suppose there is a sweetness to it in that Alan did change American comics, as well as comics in general and that his efforts did come to be worthwhile. But of course, I am still saddened that this journey is at an end.
But, as one blue demigod put it, nothing ever truly ends, does it?
ethorwitz's review against another edition
5.0
The Swamp Thing can manifest its consciousness into physical form by manipulating the vegetation of an area. In many of the later stories the forms he takes become increasingly abstract and bizarre as he travels to worlds with stranger and more sparse versions of "vegetation." I think this works as a great metaphor for how Alan Moore managed to get these stories told. DC Comics hired Moore to write a reboot of an obscure superhero and he took that opportunity to craft some amazing scifi/fantasy. But the raw material of superheroes remain awkwardly part of its genetic code. For example there are frequent references to Gotham City and Batman, or other superheroes with backstories the comic assumes you know already will make cameo appearances. I'm a big believer in self-continuity so the sprawling soap opera of superhero comics never appealed to me that much. But even here Moore excels. Even without reading the last one hundred runs of a certain character their personalities, arcs, and general backstories are instantly apparent. I knew nothing of Metron (for example) but his pompous monologue, his casual cruelty, his obsession with his "miracle chair," even his general appearance made him an instantly recognizable foil to the zen and gentle Swamp Thing.
Neil Gaiman managed a similar feat with his Sandman, which also told its own great self-contained story while incorporating elements from DC. Also Moore attempted this again with more mainstream characters like Batman but DC objected to radical changes for their more high profile characters. Instead Moore reworked them into his [b:Watchmen|472331|Watchmen|Alan Moore|https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1442239711s/472331.jpg|4358649], which is his most famous work but I honestly don't feel like it does as good a job as Swamp Thing.
Neil Gaiman managed a similar feat with his Sandman, which also told its own great self-contained story while incorporating elements from DC. Also Moore attempted this again with more mainstream characters like Batman but DC objected to radical changes for their more high profile characters. Instead Moore reworked them into his [b:Watchmen|472331|Watchmen|Alan Moore|https://images.gr-assets.com/books/1442239711s/472331.jpg|4358649], which is his most famous work but I honestly don't feel like it does as good a job as Swamp Thing.
has3000's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
With this volume comes a satisfying end to the Saga of the Swamp Thing. As his powers have grown, this book continues Swamp Thing’s journey through space, which lasts longer than I expected. Most comic “deaths” are reversed far too quickly. And while this technically revives him the next issue, it leaves him stranded in space for quite a few issues.
This book goes super weird places and I loved it. Swamp Thing travels through space trying to return home and dealing with completely new issues compared to his time on earth. “Loving the Alien” especially was unique in both story and style, and I’m sure was very controversial.
When it finally comes time for his 64-issue story to end, Alan Moore wraps it in a way that I felt was right for the character.
This book goes super weird places and I loved it. Swamp Thing travels through space trying to return home and dealing with completely new issues compared to his time on earth. “Loving the Alien” especially was unique in both story and style, and I’m sure was very controversial.
When it finally comes time for his 64-issue story to end, Alan Moore wraps it in a way that I felt was right for the character.
Content Warnings
Moderate: Rape, Torture, and Violence
bae0fpigs's review against another edition
adventurous
lighthearted
reflective
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.75
lookhome's review against another edition
5.0
An endearing, satisfying conclusion to a contemporary myth.
The summation of a fully developed character study and an in depth look at what people are capable of doing for love.
Moore uses a higher quota of science fiction here and there are a few new artists that develop the aesthetic look and feel of Moore's refined creation.
Well worth a look if you've read anything else in the series.
The summation of a fully developed character study and an in depth look at what people are capable of doing for love.
Moore uses a higher quota of science fiction here and there are a few new artists that develop the aesthetic look and feel of Moore's refined creation.
Well worth a look if you've read anything else in the series.
crookedtreehouse's review against another edition
4.0
If you have enjoyed Moore's Swamp Thing run, then this is a five star book. It starts as an Adam Strange/Rann Thanagar / Darkseid DC cosmic book before it settles back down to the story More has been focusing on since volume two of his run. Then it puts all the pieces he's been playing with back in the box and ends with a Happily For Now conclusion.
I didn't love most of it, but in the second it third issue in the collection, Moore switches up his entire narrative device game in service of some trippy, non-traditional art. He gets very spiritual, but allowed the art to be center stage.
It works. Aside from the first appearance of John Constantine, it's easily my favorite part of his run. And it made me a little less irritated that Swamp Thing In Space was happening.
I'm still not a huge fan of this run, but he does close it off nicely.
I didn't love most of it, but in the second it third issue in the collection, Moore switches up his entire narrative device game in service of some trippy, non-traditional art. He gets very spiritual, but allowed the art to be center stage.
It works. Aside from the first appearance of John Constantine, it's easily my favorite part of his run. And it made me a little less irritated that Swamp Thing In Space was happening.
I'm still not a huge fan of this run, but he does close it off nicely.